图书情报工作 ›› 2022, Vol. 66 ›› Issue (14): 137-149.DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2022.14.014

• 综述述评 • 上一篇    下一篇

科学计量视角下的论文同行评议研究综述

张光耀1,2, 谢维熙1, 姜春林1, 王贤文1   

  1. 1. 大连理工大学科学学与科技管理研究所暨WISE实验室 大连 116024;
    2. 荷兰马斯特里赫特科技创新经济研究院(UNU-MERIT) 马斯特里赫特 6211AX
  • 收稿日期:2022-02-17 修回日期:2022-05-10 出版日期:2022-07-20 发布日期:2022-07-28
  • 通讯作者: 王贤文,教授,博士,通信作者,E-mail:xianwenwang@dlut.edu.cn。
  • 作者简介:张光耀,博士研究生;谢维熙,博士研究生;姜春林,教授
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家自然科学基金项目"科学文献全景大数据下的研究热点及研究前沿探测"(项目编号:71974029)研究成果之一。

A Review of Peer Review of Papers from the Scientometrics Perspective

Zhang Guangyao1,2, Xie Weixi1, Jiang Chunlin1, Wang Xianwen1   

  1. 1. Institute of Science of Science and S&T Management and WISE Lab, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024;
    2. Maastricht Economic and Social Research Institute on Innovation and Technology, United Nations University, Maastricht 6211AX
  • Received:2022-02-17 Revised:2022-05-10 Online:2022-07-20 Published:2022-07-28

摘要: [目的/意义]旨在通过梳理科学计量视角下同行评议相关研究,为深入开展同行评议研究提供参考。[方法/过程]在概括同行评议量化特征的基础上,从同行评议公平性、可靠性、预见性3个方面对国内外研究现状进行综述。[结果/结论]总结科学计量视角下的论文同行评议研究在研究方法多样性和数据应用全面性方面的趋势,并指出当下研究在结论的可解释性上仍然有待提升、国内同行评议实证研究相对不足等问题。

关键词: 同行评议, 开放同行评议, 科学学, 科学计量学

Abstract: [Purpose/significance] By combing related researches of peer review from the scientometrics perspective, this paper provides references for further in-depth research on peer review. [Method/process] This paper reviewed the current foreign and domestic status of research from three aspects:fairness, reliability, and validity of peer review on the basis of generalizing the quantitative characteristics of peer review. [Result/conclusion] The paper summarizes the trends in the diversity of research methods and the comprehensiveness of data application in peer review research from the scientometrics perspective, and points out that the interpretability of the current findings still needs to be improved, and the empirical research on peer review in China is still relatively insufficient.

Key words: peer review, open peer review, science of science, scientometrics

中图分类号: