[目的/意义]作为一种新兴的文献采访模式,读者决策采购(PDA)在一些发达国家已经得到广泛应用,但是利用该模式采购图书的质量受到了部分业界人士的质疑。采用馆藏适用性方法对馆际互借型PDA图书质量进行考察,提出优化该模式的建议,以利于PDA模式在我国的应用中具有更大的适应性和劣势可控性。[方法/过程]从项目性质、实施的时间跨度、评估方法以及研究问题的角度出发,遴选3所国外大学图书馆的PDA项目作为案例,围绕业界对PDA模式的争论点,从文献的内容、价格、利用情况及读者与馆员对文献的评价4个方面分析评估馆际互借型PDA图书质量,并针对该模式在我国的应用提出几点建议。[结果/结论]从图书质量评价角度探讨完善国内馆际互借型PDA项目的干预措施,使馆际互借型PDA在我国图书馆资源建设中发挥更大的作用。
[Purpose/significance] As a new mode of literature acquisition, although PDA(patron-driven acquisition) is widely applied in some developed countries, many librarians are suspicious of the quality of the patron-driven books. This paper analyzes and evaluates the quality of the patron-driven books via interlibrary loan with the method of collection resource applicability, and proposes some suggestions to optimize the mode, making its application in our country to have more adaptability and the disadvantage to be more in controllable. [Method/process] This paper selects three PDA projects of America universities as cases according to the projects' nature, time span of implementation, evaluation method, and the perspective of the research question. Then it analyzes and evaluates the quality of the patron-driven books via interlibrary loan around the major issues from four aspects, which are the resource content, resource price, resource utilization, and librarians and readers' satisfaction. And lastly, this paper proposes some suggestions for our country to implement ILL PDA projects. [Result/conclusion] The intervention measures proposed in this paper from the angle of book quality evaluation are beneficial to the application of ILL PDA, expecting it to play more constructive role in the construction of library resources in our country.
[1] 胡小菁.PDA——读者决策采购[J].中国图书馆学报,2011(2):50.
[2] DEBORAH L, EMILIE D. Give the people what they want:patron driven acquisition[EB/OL].[2015-10-15].http://www.stm-assoc.org/2010_04_27_Spring_Conference_Lenares_Patron_Driven_Acquisition.pdf.
[3] 张丹,肖平.读者驱动采购(PDA)实施过程中相关争议问题的思考[J].图书馆杂志,2012(7):24-27.
[4] 史丽香.纸本图书PDA:境外图书馆的实践及其启示[J].图书馆杂志,2013(11):83-87.
[5] DUNCAN J, CARROLL J. Patron-driven acquisition practices of US research libraries:east VS. West[C/OL].[2015-09-20].http://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1227&context=charleston.
[6] FOSS M. Books-on-demand and pilot program:an innovative "patron-centric" approach to enhance the library collection[J].Journal of access services,2008(5):305-315.
[7] HODGES D, PRESTON C, HAMILTON M J. Patron-initiated collection development:progress of a paradigm shift[J].Collection management, 2010,35(3/4):208-211.
[8] NIXON J M, SAUNDERS E S.A study of circulation statistics of books on demand:a decade of patron driven collection development, part 3[J].Collection management,2010,35(3/4):151-161.
[9] 杜洁芳.内蒙古图书馆首创"我阅读,你买单"彩云服务[EB/OL].[2015-10-10].http://epaper.ccdy.cn/html/2015-02/09/content_146782.htm.
[10] 田碧.读者自主选购与新书阅览室[J].图书与情报,2009(3):79-81.
[11] 张彦静.我国图书馆读者自主采购的探索与思考——以佛山市图书馆"新书借阅处"为例[J].图书馆学研究,2013(15):54-58,76.
[12] 刘华."读者决策采购"在美国大学图书馆的实践及其对我国的启示[J].大学图书馆学报,2012(1):45-50.
[13] TYLER D C, MELVIN J C. Don't fear the reader:librarian versus interlibrary loan patron-driven acquisition of print books at an academic library by relative collecting level and by library of congress classes and subclasses[J]. College & research libraries,2014(9):684-704.
[14] DOUG W. The assessment of patron-initiated collection development via interlibrary loan at a comprehensive university[J]. Journal of interlibrary loan, document delivery & electronic reserve, 2009(19):299-308.
[15] 胡振华.馆藏资源质量的适用性评价研究[J].图书馆杂志,2009(1):15-18.
[16] NIXON J M, ANDERSON K J, FREEMAN R S. Liberal arts books on demand:a decade of patron-driven collection development, part 1[J].Collection management,2010,35(3/4):125-141.
[17] MARIANNE B. Science and technology books on demand:a decade of patron-driven collection development,part2[J].Collection management,2010,35(3/4):142-150.
[18] TYLER D C, XU Y, MELVIN J C. Just how right are the customers? an analysis of the relative performance of patron-initiated interlibrary loan monograph purchases[J]. Collection management, 2010,35(3/4):162-179.
[19] 孙书霞,彭艳.美国大学图书馆"读者决策采购"的实践及启示[J].图书与情报,2012(4):98-102.
