图书情报工作

图书情报工作 >

2019 , Vol. 63 >Issue 20: 129 - 138

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2019.20.015

综述述评

颠覆性技术识别方法发展现状及启示

  • 苏鹏 ,
  • 苏成 ,
  • 潘云涛
展开
  • 中国科学技术信息研究所 北京 100038
苏鹏(ORCID:0000-0003-1275-235X),硕士研究生;潘云涛(ORCID:0000-0002-9930-9416),研究员。

收稿日期: 2019-01-04

  修回日期: 2019-04-01

  网络出版日期: 2019-10-20

基金资助

本文系中国科学技术信息研究所重点项目"颠覆性技术感知响应平台研发与应用示范"（项目编号：ZD2019-13）研究成果之一。

收起

Overview and Considerations on Disruptive Technology Identification Method

  • Su Peng ,
  • Su Cheng ,
  • Pan Yuntao
Expand
  • Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China, Beijing 100038

Received date: 2019-01-04

  Revised date: 2019-04-01

  Online published: 2019-10-20

Fold

摘要

[目的/意义]颠覆性技术能变革传统生产模式和消费结构，使产业格局巨变。识别潜在颠覆性技术有助于抢占科技制高点，在科技竞争中取得先发优势。[方法/过程]通过主题检索和引文回溯搜集文献，梳理颠覆性技术现阶段的主要识别方法。[结果/结论]发现方法的选择与研究人员学科背景密切相关，根据研究人员的主要研究领域，将其划分为图书情报、工程管理、经济研究和Christansen流派4类识别方法。在此基础上对识别方法进行7个维度的比较，指出现有方法存在3个问题：过度依赖专家评价、识别标准针对性不足和超前识别效果不佳，其中识别标准针对性不足是核心问题。鉴于此，在后续研究中应当从多种角度不断探究和完善技术颠覆潜力的评价方法。

关键词： 颠覆性技术; 识别方法; 综述

本文引用格式

苏鹏 , 苏成 , 潘云涛 . 颠覆性技术识别方法发展现状及启示[J]. 图书情报工作, 2019 , 63(20) : 129 -138 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2019.20.015

Abstract

[Purpose/significance] The disruptive technology can change the traditional production mode and consumption structure, to make the industrial pattern change dramatically. Identifying potential disruptive technologies will help people to seize the commanding heights of science & technology and gain the first-mover advantage.[Method/process] Collecting literature through subject retrieval and citation tracing, the present stage of the main identification method of the disruptive technology is summarized.[Result/conclusion] The selection of methods is closely related to the academic backgroud of researchers. According to their main research fields, they are divided into four kinds of method:library and information, engineering management, economic research and Christansen School. And then, seven dimensions of recognition methonds are compared and three problems are poinrted out:over-reliance on expert evaluation, inadequate pertinence of indentification standards and inadequate effect of advance indentification. So, in future study, disruptive technology indentification should be explored in various perspectives.

Key words： disruptive technology; identification method; review

参考文献

[1] CHRISTENSEN M C. The innovator's dilemma:when new technologies cause great firms to fail[M]. Cambridge:Harvard Business School Press, 1997.
[2] Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency.Innovation at DARPA[EB/OL].[2018-07-29].http://www.darpa.mil/attachments/DARPA_Innovation_2016.pdf.
[3] 中国科协创新战略研究院. 日本颠覆性技术创新计划研究要点[J]. 中国高新科技, 2017(1):93-95.
[4] 习近平. 决胜全面建成小康社会夺取新时代中国特色社会主义伟大胜利[EB/OL].[2018-07-29].https://www.guancha.cn/politics/2017_10_27_432557.html.
[5] BOWER J L, CHRISTENSEN M C. Disruptive technologies:catching the wave[J]. Harvard business review, 1995,73(1):75-76.
[6] HUSIG S, HIPP C, DOWLING M. Analyzing the disruptive potential:the case of wireless local area network and mobile communications network companies[J].R&D management,2005,35(1):17-25.
[7] STOICIU A, SZABO E, TOTEV M, et al. Assessing the disruptiveness of new energy technologies:an ex-ante perspective[EB/OL].[2018-07-29].http://bach-s49.wu-wien.ac.at/4310/1/ISM_ESTT_WP2_Assessing_the_Disruptiveness_of_New_Energy_Technologies.pdf.
[8] KELLER A, HUSIG S. Ex-ante identification of disruptive innovations in the software industry applied to web applications:the case of Microsofts Google's office applications[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2009, 76(8):1044-1054.
[9] NAGY D, SCHUESSLER J, DUBINSKY A. Defining and identifying disruptive innovations[J]. Industrial marketing management, 2016, 57(8):119-126.
[10] 王安,孙棕檀,沈艳波.国外颠覆性技术识别方法浅析[J].中国工程科学,2017, 19(5):79-84.
[11] DANNEELS E. Disruptive technology reconsidered:a critique and research agenda[J]. Journal of product innovation management, 2004, 21(4):246-258.
[12] GANGULY A, NILCHIANI R, FARR J V. Defining a set of metrics to evaluate the potential disruptiveness of a technology[J]. Engineering management journal, 2010, 22(1):34-44.
[13] GOVINDARAJAN V, KOPALLE P K. Disruptiveness of innovations:measurement and an assessment of reliability and validity[J]. Strategy manage,2006,27(2):189-199.
[14] KOSTOFF R N, BOYLAN R, Simons G R. Disruptive technology roadmaps[J].Technology forecast social, 2004, 71(1-2):141-159.
[15] KASSICHIEH S, RAHAL N. A model for disruptive technology forecasting in strategic regional economic development[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2007, 74(9):1718-1732.
[16] BUCHANAN B, CORKEN R. A toolkit for the systematic analysis of patent data to assess a potentially disruptive technology[R].[2018-07-29]. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.637.8497&rep=rep1&type=pdf.
[17] BLOODWORTH I. A search for discriminative linguistic markers in ICT practitioner discourse, for the ex-ante identification of disruptive innovation[J]. Proceedings of the IEEE, 2012, 6(9):1511-1519.
[18] 陈傲, 柳卸林. 突破性技术创新的形成机制[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 2013.
[19] 张金柱, 张晓林.利用引用科学知识突变识别突破性创新[J]. 情报学报, 2014, 33(3):259-266.
[20] 栾春娟, 程昉. 技术的市场潜力测度与预测——基于技术颠覆潜力与技术成熟度综合指标[J]. 科学学研究, 2016,36(12):1761-1768.
[21] MOMENI A, ROST K. Identification and monitoring of possible disruptive technologies by patent-development paths and topic modeling[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2016, 104(3):16-29.
[22] 苏敬勤, 刘建华, 王智琦, 等. 颠覆性技术的演化轨迹及早期识别——以智能手机等技术为例[J]. 科研管理, 2016, 37(3):13-19.
[23] DOTSIKA F, WATKINS A. Identifying potentially disruptive trends by means of keyword network analysis[J]. Technological forecasting and social change,2017, 119(3):114-127.
[24] 赵格.基于多源异构数据的颠覆性技术识别[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2017.
[25] 白光祖,郑玉荣,吴新年.基于文献知识关联的颠覆性技术预见方法研究与实证[J].情报杂志,2017,36(9):38-44.
[26] 刘秋艳.基于科学论文和专利数据的颠覆性技术识别方法研究[D].兰州:中国科学院兰州文献情报中心,2017.
[27] 黄鲁成,蒋林杉,吴菲菲.萌芽期颠覆性技术识别研究[J].科技进步与对策,2019,36(1):10-17.
[28] 黄鲁成, 成雨, 吴菲菲, 等. 关于颠覆性技术识别框架的探索[J]. 科学学研究, 2015, 33(5):654-664.
[29] CHENG Y, HUANG L, RAMLOGAN R. Forecasting of potential impacts of disruptive technology in promising technological areas:elaborating the SIRS epidemic model in RFID technology[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2017, 117(4):170-183.
[30] VOJAK B A, CHAMBERS F A. Roadmapping disruptive technical threats and opportunities in complex, technology-based subsystems:the SAILS methodology[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2004, 71(1-2):121-139.
[31] WALSH S T. Roadmapping a disruptive technology:a case study:the emerging microsystems and top-down nanosystems industry[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2004,71(1-2):161-185.
[32] 卢光松, 卢平. 企业颠覆性技术路线图制定研究[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2011, 28(11):81-86.
[33] DREW S A. Building technology foresight:using scenarios to embrace innovation[J]. European journal of innovation management, 2006, 9(3):241-257.
[34] SCHOEMAKER P J, MAVADDAT V M. Wharton on managing emerging technologies[M]. New Jersey:John Wiley & Sons,2000:206-241.
[35] KOSTOFF R N, BOYLAN R, Simons G R. Disruptive technology roadmaps[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2004,71(1):141-159.
[36] 孙建广, 檀润华, 江屏.基于技术进化理论的破坏性创新预测与实现模型[J]. 机械工程学报,2012,48(11):11-20.
[37] 许泽浩, 张光宇, 亢凯,等. 基于TRIZ理论的颠覆性技术选择环境研究[J]. 工业工程, 2016,19(4):44-47.
[38] 许泽浩. 颠覆性技术的选择及管理对策研究:基于TRIZ理论与SNM理论视角[D].广州:广东工业大学,2017.
[39] LINTON J D. Forecasting the market diffusion of disruptive and discontinuous innovation[J]. IEEE transactionson engineering management, 2002,49(4):365-374.
[40] SCHMIDT G M, DRUEHL C T. When is a disruptive innovation disruptive[J]. Journal of product innovation management, 2008, 25(4):347-3698.
[41] 宋建元. 成熟型大企业开展破坏性创新的机理与途径研究[D].杭州:浙江大学, 2005.
[42] 李存斌, 鲁平. 基于突变理论的国网公司颠覆性创新技术评价研究[J]. 陕西电力, 2016, 44(4):60-64.
[43] SAINIO L M, PUUMALAINEN K. Evaluating technology disruptiveness in a strategic corporate context:a case study[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2007, 74(8):1315-1333.
[44] 许泽浩, 张光宇, 廖建聪. 基于战略生态位管理视角的颠覆性技术成长过程研究[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2016(2):5-9.
[45] ADAMS F P, BROMLEY B P, Moore M. Assessment of disruptive innovation in emerging energy technologies[EB/OL].[2018-07-29].https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=7051685.
[46] 陈劲, 戴凌燕, 李良德. 突破性创新及其识别[J]. 科技管理研究, 2002,22(5):22-28.
[47] 林春培, 张振刚, 薛捷. 破坏性创新的概念、类型、内在动力及事前识别[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2012(2):35-41.
[48] PAAP J, KATZ R. Anticipating disruptive innovation[J]. Research technology management, 2004, 32(5):74-85.
[49] VECCHIATO R. Disruptive innovation, managerial cognition, and technology competition outcomes[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2016,116(12):116-128.
[50] ADNER R. When are technologies disruptive? A demand-based view of the emergence of competition[J]. Strategic management journal,2002,23(8):667-688.
[51] SOOD A, TELLIS G J. Demystifying disruption:a new model for understanding and predicting disruptive technologies[J]. Marketing science, 2011,30(2):339-354.
[52] CHEN C, ZHANG J, GUO R S. The d-day, v-day, and bleak days of a disruptive technology:a new model for ex ante evaluation of the timing of technology disruption[J]. European journal of operational research, 2016,251(2):562-574.
[53] 季丹, 郭政. 破坏性创新:概念、比较与识别[J]. 经济与管理, 2009, 23(5):16-20.
[54] GAVIAO L O, FERRAZ F T, LIMA G B A, et al. Assessment of the "disrupt-o-meter" model by ordinal multicriteria methods[J]. RAI revista de administração eInovação, 2016,13(4):305-314.
[55] GOVINDARAJAN V, KOPALLE P K. Disruptiveness of innovations:measurement and an assessment of reliability and validity[J]. Strategy manage, 2006, 27(2):189-199.
[56] GUO J F,PAN J F,GUO J X.Measurement framework for assessing disruptive innovations[J]. Technological forecasting & social change,2019,139(1):205-265.
[57] 贾珍珍, 曾华锋, 刘戟锋.美国颠覆性军事技术的预研模式、管理与文化——以美国国防高级研究计划局(DARPA)为例[J]. 自然辩证法研究,2016,32(1):41-45.
[58] 樊琳. 美国防部启动技术监视/水平扫描项目,以监控全球潜在的颠覆性技术[EB/OL].[2018-08-10].http://roll.sohu.com/20140117/n393694401.shtml.
[59] 樊丽萍. 徐匡迪院士:对颠覆性创新意愿应宽容支持[EB/OL].[2018-09-11]. http://wenhui.sumg.com.cn/html/2016-08/16/content_456128.html.
[60] MURAT B T, RAMZI N. Forecasting emerging technologies with the aid of science and technology databases[J]. Technological forecasting and social change, 2006, 73(7):835-844.
[61] National Academy of Sciences. Persistent forecasting of disruptive technologies[EB/OL].[2019-03-37].http://www.nap.edu/catalog/12557.html.
Options
文章导航

/

〈 〉