[目的/意义]在梳理数字叙事在人文与社会科学领域发展现状的基础上,探讨其在数字人文研究与实践中方法化的可能性与潜在的价值。[方法/过程]对数字时代下产生的与数字人文研究息息相关的"数据叙事"与"数字叙事"概念进行辨析,对在传媒领域与公共史学领域首先提出并已经得到充分发展的数字叙事的相关实践进行分析,并针对目前在数字人文项目中已经体现的数字叙事实践从资源组织与成果呈现、交互体验与增进认知两个方面进行总结。[结果/结论]提出数字人文视野下数字叙事的概念、内涵、特殊性以及数字叙事作为数字人文方法的可能性,并对形式化叙事及数字人文叙事评价的前景作出展望,构建"数字人文形式化叙事及信效度评价模型",以期对数字叙事在数字人文研究中的价值与潜能进行探索。
[Purpose/significance] On the basis of sorting out the existing research of digital storytelling in the field of humanities and social sciences, this paper explores its methodological possibilities and potential value in digital humanities research and practice. [Method/process] This paper differentiated and analyzed the concepts of 'data storytelling' and 'digital storytelling' which were closely related to digital humanities research in the digital age, and reviewed the practice of digital storytelling in the fields of media and public history where it was first proposed and had been well-developed. It summarized the digital storytelling practice that had been embodied in the digital humanities project from two aspects of resource organization and outcome presentation, interactive experience and cognitive enhancement. [Result/conclusion] This paper proposes the definition, meaning, and characteristics of digital storytelling in DH, and discusses the potential of using digital storytelling as a research method in DH. It also looks forward to the prospect of auto-structuring stories and the evaluation of DH storytelling, and constructs the "digital humanities auto-structuring storytelling and reliability and validity evaluation model" with a goal to explore the value and potential of digital storytelling in DH.
[1] BARBER J F. Digital storytelling:new opportunities for humanities scholarship and pedagogy[J]. Cogent arts&humanities, 2016, 3(1):1181037.
[2] MUNSTER S, APOLLONIO F I, BELL P, et al. Digital cultural heritage meets digital humanities[C]//27th Cipa international symposium:documenting the past for a better future. Spain:ISPRS, 2019:812-820.
[3] MOLONEY K, UNGER M. Transmedia storytelling in science communication:one subject, multiple media, unlimited stories[M]//New trends in earth-science outreach and engagement. Cham:Springer, 2014.
[4] CRAWFORD C. Interactive storytelling[M]//The video game theory reader. Berkeley:Routledge, 2013.
[5] ECHEVERRIA V, MARTINEZ-MALDONADO R, GRANDA R, et al. Driving data storytelling from learning design[C]//Proceedings of the 8th international conference on learning analytics and knowledge. New York:Association for Computing Machinery, 2018:131-140.
[6] 朝乐门,张晨.数据故事化:从数据感知到数据认知[J].中国图书馆学报, 2019, 45(5):61-78.
[7] 张晨,朝乐门,孙智中.数据故事叙述的关键技术研究[J].情报资料工作, 2021, 42(2):73-80.
[8] 丁家友,唐馨雨.数字人文视角下的数据叙事及其应用研究[J].情报理论与实践,2022(2):121-128.
[9] NOIRET S. Digital public history[M]//DEAN D. A companion to public history. Hoboken:Wiley, 2018.
[10] 甘锋,李坤.从文本分析到过程研究:数字叙事理论的生成与流变[J].云南社会科学, 2019(1):170-177.
[11] LAUREL B. Computers as theatre[M]. Boston:Addison-Wesley, 2013.
[12] MILLER C.H. Digital storytelling:a creator's guide to interactive entertainment[M]. London:Routledge, 2014.
[13] 张新军.用媒介思维:数字叙事学的研究进路[J].山东外语教学, 2012, 33(5):84-88.
[14] 龙家庆.叙事表达在档案宣传中的运用与优化策略[J].浙江档案, 2020(1):30-32.
[15] 冯惠玲.数字人文视角下的数字记忆——兼议数字记忆的方法特点[J].数字人文研究, 2021, 1(1):87.
[16] 黄水清.人文计算与数字人文:概念、问题、范式及关键环节[J].图书馆建设,2019(5):68-78.
[17] 刘圣婴,王丽华,刘炜,等.数字人文的研究范式与平台建设[J].图书情报知识,2022,39(1):6-29.
[18] ROBIN B.R. Digital storytelling:a powerful technology tool for the 21st century classroom[J]. Theory into practice, 2008, 47(3):220-228.
[19] RAHIEM M D. Storytelling in early childhood education:time to go digital[J]. International journal of child care and education policy, 2021, 15(1):1-20.
[20] DAVIS A, WEINSHENKER D. Digital storytelling and authoring identity[M]//CHING C,FOLEY B. Constructing the self in a digital world (Learning in doing:social, cognitive and computational perspectives), Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2012:47-74.
[21] MEADOWS D. Digital storytelling:research-based practice in new media[J]. Visual communication, 2003, 2(2):189-193.
[22] StoryCenter[EB/OL].[2022-04-28]. https://www.storycenter.org.
[23] BURGESS J. Hearing ordinary voices:cultural studies, vernacular creativity and digital storytelling[J]. Continuum, 2006, 20(2):201-214.
[24] CLARKE R, ADAM A. Digital storytelling in Australia:academic perspectives and reflections[J]. Arts and humanities in higher education, 2012, 11(1/2):157-176.
[25] CANELLA G. Social movement documentary practices:digital storytelling, social media and organizing[J]. Digital creativity, 2017, 28(1):24-37.
[26] 陈新."公众史学"的理论基础与学科框架[J].学术月刊, 2012(3):117-123.
[27] 王旭东.应当厘清公众史学与公共史学的区别[J].徐州工程学院学报:社会科学版, 2017, 32(2):55-58.
[28] DANNIAU F. Public history in a digital context:back to the future or back to basics?[J]. BMGN-Low countries historical review, 2013, 128(4):118-144.
[29] BURROWS T, EMERY D, FRAAS M, et al. Mapping manuscript migrations knowledge graph:data for tracing the history and provenance of medieval and renaissance manuscripts[J]. Journal of open humanities data, 2020, 6(1):1-3.
[30] XIA C, WANG L, LIU W. Shanghai memory as a digital humanities platform to rebuild the history of the city[J]. Digital scholarship in the humanities, 2021, 36(4):841-857.
[31] 牛力,高晨翔,张宇锋,等.发现,重构与故事化:数字人文视角下档案研究的路径与方法[J].中国图书馆学报, 2021, 47(1):88-107.
[32] 冯惠玲,梁继红,马林青.台州古村落数字记忆平台建设研究——以高迁古村为例[J].中国档案, 2019(5):74-75.
[33] HALL E, SMITHIES J. Misremembering machines:a creative collaboration on memory in AI-driven storytelling[C]//Digital Humanities Conference 2019. Utrecht:2019.
[34] 刘子曦.故事与讲故事:叙事社会学何以可能——兼谈如何讲述中国故事[J].社会学研究,2018,33(2):164-188, 245.
[35] 陈静.当下中国"数字人文"研究状况及意义[J].山东社会科学, 2018(7):61-65.
[36] 马诺维奇.新媒体的语言[M].车琳,译.贵阳:贵州人民出版社, 2020.
[37] BUSA R. The annals of humanities computing:the index thomisticus[J]. Computers and the humanities, 1980(14):83-90.
[38] ABBOTT A. The'time machine'reconstructing ancient Venice's social networks[J]. Nature, 2017, 546(7658):341-344.
[39] UNSWORTH J. Scholarly primitives:what methods do humanities researchers have in common, and how might our tools reflect this[C]//Symposium on humanities computing:formal methods, experimental practice. London:King's College London, 2000:12.
[40] 王军.从人文计算到可视化——数字人文的发展脉络梳理[J].文艺理论与批评, 2020(2):18-23.
[41] 周翔,仲建琴.智能化背景下"中国故事"叙事模式创新研究[J].新闻大学,2020(9):79-94,122.
[42] 曾蕾,王晓光,范炜.图档博领域的智慧数据及其在数字人文研究中的角色[J].中国图书馆学报,2018,44(1):17-34.作者贡献说明:付雅明:题目构思、论文框架设计、初稿撰写;张永娟:案例收集、修改建议;刘炜:核心论点总指导、修改建议;朱庆华:论文格式指导、修改建议。
