研究论文

中国和欧盟网络信息内容治理政策文本量化对比分析

  • 赵静 ,
  • 杨梦翔 ,
  • 樊宁馨 ,
  • 余星宇
展开
  • 郑州航空工业管理学院信息管理学院 郑州 450046
赵静,教授,博士,E-mail:horsezhaojing@126.com;杨梦翔,硕士研究生;樊宁馨,硕士研究生;余星宇,硕士研究生。

收稿日期: 2024-11-25

  修回日期: 2025-03-05

  网络出版日期: 2026-02-09

基金资助

本文系国家社会科学基金项目“信息生态视域下信息疫情的形成机理和治理路径研究”(项目编号:22BTQ075)研究成果之一。

Quantitative Comparative Analysis of China’s and EU’s Online Information Content Governance Policies Text

  • Zhao Jing ,
  • Yang Mengxiang ,
  • Fan Ningxin ,
  • Yu Xingyu
Expand
  • School of Information Management, Zhengzhou University of Aeronautics, Zhengzhou 450046

Received date: 2024-11-25

  Revised date: 2025-03-05

  Online published: 2026-02-09

Supported by

This work is supported by the National Social Science Fund of China project titled “Research on the Formation Mechanism and Governance Path of Information Epidemic in the Context of Information Ecology” (Grant No. 22BTQ075).

摘要

[目的/意义] 网络信息内容治理政策在保障网络安全、营造良好网络生态方面有着重要作用,对比分析现阶段我国和欧盟的网络信息内容治理政策,可以为后续我国网络信息内容治理领域相关政策的制定和优化提供理论借鉴。[方法/过程] 利用文本挖掘手段提取核心词汇,应用PMC指数模型构建网络信息内容治理政策评价指标,各选3项我国和欧盟的网络信息内容治理政策作为实证文本进行量化对比分析。[结果/结论] 6项政策等级排序为P1>P5>P4>P6>P3>P2,其中P1和P5为优秀政策,其余为可接受等级政策。中国和欧盟政策差异不显著,欧盟政策的一致性优于我国,我国在“政策性质”“政策保障”“治理策略”维度有待优化。

本文引用格式

赵静 , 杨梦翔 , 樊宁馨 , 余星宇 . 中国和欧盟网络信息内容治理政策文本量化对比分析[J]. 图书情报工作, 2026 , 70(3) : 45 -58 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2026.03.005

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] Network information content governance policies play an important role in ensuring network security and creating a good network ecosystem. Comparative analysis of the policies in China and the European Union can provide theoretical references for the formulation and optimization of relevant policies in China in the future. [Method/Process] This paper adopted text mining to extract core vocabulary, used the PMC index model to construct an evaluation index system, and selected three governance policies each from China and the European Union as empirical texts for quantitative comparative analysis. [Result/Conclusion] The ranking of the six policies is P1>P5>P4>P6>P3>P2, of which P1 and P5 are excellent policies and the rest are acceptable ones. There are no significant differences in policies between China and the European Union. The consistency of EU policies is better than that of China’s, and China needs to optimize its “policy nature”, “policy guarantee”, and “governance strategy” dimensions.

参考文献

[1] 莫祖英, 盘大清.信息茧房效应对用户虚假信息识别能力的影响关系探析[J]. 图书馆学研究, 2023(3): 50-57. (MO Z Y, PAN D Q. An analysis of the influence of information cocoons on users' ability to identify false information[J]. Researches on library science, 2023(3): 50-57.)
[2] 莫祖英, 王垲烁, 赵悦名. 社交媒体用户虚假信息从众传播行为影响模型实证研究[J]. 情报资料工作, 2023, 44(1): 72-81. (MO Z Y, WANG K S, ZHAO Y M. Empirical research on the influence model of social media users' false information conformity spreading behavior[J]. Information and documentation services, 2023, 44(1): 72-81.)
[3] 丁汉青, 韩玥. 事件与传播:网络暴力事件传播力影响因素分析——基于49例网络暴力事件的定性比较分析(QCA)[J]. 广州大学学报(社会科学版), 2023, 22(1): 183-192. (DING H Q, HAN Y. Event and communication: qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) on the influential factors for the effect of cyber violence cases[J]. Journal of Guangzhou University(social science edition), 2023, 22(1): 183-192.)
[4] 中央网络安全和信息化委员会办公室. 2023年“清朗”系列专项行动举行新闻发布会[EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. https://www.cac.gov.cn/2023-03/28/c_1681651403641157.htm. (Office of the central committee for network security and information. press conference on the "Clear" series of special operations in 2023[EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. https://www.cac.gov.cn/2023-03/28/c_1681651403641157.htm.)
[5] 周毅. 总体国家安全观视域的网络信息内容治理:进展、内涵与研究逻辑[J]. 情报理论与实践, 2020, 43(8): 44-50. (ZHOU Y. Network information content governance from the perspective of overall national security: progress, connotation and research logic[J]. Information studies: theory & application, 2020, 43(8): 44-50.)
[6] 金晶. 欧盟的规则, 全球的标准?数据跨境流动监管的“逐顶竞争”[J]. 中外法学, 2023, 35(1): 46-65. (JIN J. EU rules, global standards? the "race to the top" in the regulation of cross-border data flows[J]. Peking University law journal, 2023, 35(1): 46-65.)
[7] 程娅. 面向未来:欧盟数据治理框架的要素分析与经验启示[J]. 数字图书馆论坛, 2022(12): 47-53. (CHENG Y. Facing the future: element analysis and experience enlightenment of EU data governance framework[J]. Digital library forum, 2022(12): 47-53.)
[8] 崔文波, 张涛, 马海群, 等. 欧盟数据与算法安全治理:特征与启示[J]. 信息资源管理学报, 2023, 13(2): 30-41. (CUI W B, ZHANG T, MA H Q, et al. Data and algorithm security governance in the European Union: characteristics and implications[J]. Journal of information resources management, 2023, 13(2): 30-41.)
[9] 彭均. 祛魅与超越:新时代网络意识形态风险及其防范[J]. 理论导刊, 2022(1): 66-72, 92. (PENG J. Dispelling and transcending: internet ideological risks and their prevention in the new era[J]. Journal of socialist theory guide, 2022(1): 66-72, 92.)
[10] 漆晨航. 生成式人工智能的虚假信息风险特征及其治理路径[J]. 情报理论与实践, 2024, 47(3): 112-120. (QI C H. Research on the risks of disinformation from generative artificial intelligence and its governance paths[J]. Information studies: theory & application, 2024, 47(3): 112-120.)
[11] 周建青, 张世政. 信息供需视域下网络空间内容风险及其治理[J]. 福建师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2023(3): 81-90, 169. (ZHOU J Q, ZHANG S Z. Cyberspace content risk and its governance from the perspective of information supply and demand[J]. Journal of Fujian Normal University(philosophy and social sciences edition), 2023(3): 81-90, 169.)
[12] 李铭轩, 文继荣. AIGC时代网络信息内容的法律治理——以大语言模型为例[J]. 北京理工大学学报(社会科学版), 2023, 25(6): 83-92. (LI M X, WEN J R. Legal governance of internet information content in AIGC era: taking large language model as an example[J]. Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology (social sciences edition), 2023, 25(6): 83-92.)
[13] 徐伟, 李睿恒. 网络暴力的治理逻辑与优化建议——基于2009—2024年政策文本的扎根分析[J]. 重庆大学学报(社会科学版), 2025, 31(2): 267-279. (XU W, LI R H. The governance logic and optimization suggestions of network violence: based on the grounded analysis of policy texts from 2009 to 2024[J]. Journal of Chongqing university (social science edition), 2025, 31(2): 267-279.)
[14] 刘恩东. 美国网络内容监管与治理的政策体系[J]. 治理研究, 2019, 35(3): 102-111. (LIU E D. The policy system of internet content supervision and governance in the United States [J]. Governance studies, 2019, 35(3): 102-111.)
[15] 魏娜, 范梓腾, 孟庆国. 中国互联网信息服务治理机构网络关系演化与变迁——基于政策文献的量化考察[J]. 公共管理学报, 2019, 16(2): 91-104, 172-173. (WEI N, FAN Z T, MENG Q G. The network relations' evolution and change of the internet information service governance institutions in China: quantitative review based on policy literature[J]. Journal of public management, 2019, 16(2): 91-104, 172-173.)
[16] WIJERMARS M, MAKHORTYKH M. Sociotechnical imaginaries of algorithmic governance in EU policy on online disinformation and fin tech[J]. New media & society, 2022, 24(4): 942-963.
[17] ZHOU Y, YAN L, LIU X. A quantitative study of disruptive technology policy texts: an example of China’s artificial intelligence policy[J]. Journal of data and information science, 2024, 9(3): 155-180.
[18] 李佳轩, 常帅峰, 袁勤俭.中外生成式人工智能监管政策比较研究[J].情报理论与实践, 2025, 48(6): 37-46. ((LI J X, CHANG S F, YUAN Q J. Comparative study of China's and foreign generative artificial intelligence regulatory policies[J]. Information studies: theory & application, 2025, 48(6): 37-46.)
[19] 邓卫华, 左静. “十八大”以来互联网内容治理政策变迁——基于政策文献计量的研究[J]. 信息资源管理学报, 2021, 11(3): 88-98. (DENG W H, ZUO J. The changes of Internet content governance policy since the 18th CPC national congress: a bibliometrics research[J]. Journal of information resources management, 2021, 11(3): 88-98.)
[20] 柴宝勇, 陈若凡, 陈浩龙. 中国网络内容治理政策:变迁脉络与工具选择——基于政策文本的内容分析[J]. 中南大学学报(社会科学版), 2023, 29(5): 148-161. (CHAI B Y, CHEN R F, CHEN H L. On China's policy of internet content governance: evolution network and tool selection: a policy-text-based content analysis[J]. Journal of Central South University(social sciences), 2023, 29(5): 148-161.)
[21] 赵雪芹, 李天娥, 董乐颖. 网络生态治理政策分析与对策研究——基于政策工具的视角[J]. 情报理论与实践, 2021, 44(4): 23-29, 39. (ZHAO X Q, LI T E, DONG L Y. Policy analysis and countermeasures of network ecological governance: based on the perspective of policy tools[J]. Information studies: theory & application, 2021, 44(4): 23-29, 39.)
[22] DZIUNDZIUK V B, KOTUKH Y V, KRUTII O M, et al. State information security policy (comparative legal aspect)[J]. Cuestiones politicas, 2021, 39(71): 166-186.
[23] KASSAB H S. Geographically small but not weak: comparing the national security policies of Israel and Singapore[J]. Defense & security analysis, 2024, 40(1): 120-137.
[24] LEE J, KIM K, PARK G, et al. The role of online news and social media in preventive action in times of infodemic from a social capital perspective: the case of the COVID-19 pandemic in South Korea[J]. Telematics and informatics, 2021, 64(11): 1-13.
[25] 徐剑, 钱烨夫.“信息疫情”的定义、传播及治理[J]. 上海交通大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2020, 28(5): 121-134. (XU J, QIAN Y F. The definition, transmission and governance of infodemic[J]. Journal of Shanghai Jiaotong University (philosophy and social sciences), 2020, 28(5): 121-134.)
[26] 陈思达, 张晶. “信息疫情”视角下的社交媒体管理[J]. 中国出版, 2021(18): 43-46. (CHEN S D, ZHANG J. Social media management in the context of an “information epidemic”[J]. China publishing journal, 2021(18): 43-46.)
[27] 赵泽睿. 网络信息内容生态共同治理的法治保障[J]. 交大法学, 2023(3): 48-62. (ZHAO Z R. Guaranteed by law for co-governance of network information content ecology[J]. SJTU law review, 2023(3): 48-62.)
[28] RUIZ ESTRADA M A. Policy modeling: definition, classification and evaluation[J]. Journal of policy modeling, 2011, 33(4): 523?536.
[29] RUIZ ESTRADA M A, YAP S F, NAGARAJ S. Beyond the ceteris paribus assumption: modeling demand and supply assuming Omnia Mobilis [J]. International journal of economics research, 2008(2): 185?194.
[30] 孙瑞英, 陈宜泓. 基于PMC指数模型的我国公共数据开放政策评价研究[J]. 情报理论与实践, 2023, 46(8): 33-42. (SUN R Y, CHEN Y H. Research on evaluation of China' s public data opening policy based on PMC index model[J]. Information studies: theory & application, 2023, 46(8): 33-42.)
[31] WANG P, WU J, GUANG X. Evaluation of regional science and technology innovation policy based on extended PMC index model: taking national high-tech zones in Hebei province as examples[J]. Geography and geo-information science, 2023, 39(4): 72-76, 120.
[32] HONG S, WANG T, FU X, et al. Research on quantitative evaluation of digital economy policy in China based on the PMC index model[J]. Plos one, 2024, 19(2): e0298312.
[33] 苏芳荔, 李世豪. 基于PMC指数模型的非物质文化遗产政策评价研究[J]. 情报科学, 2023, 41(11): 151-161. (SU F L, LI S H. Policy evaluation of intangible cultural heritage based on PMC index mode[J]. Information science, 2023, 41(11): 151-161.)
[34] GU Y, HE D, HUANG J, et al. Research on the policy environment of China's healthcare big data development based on PMC index model[J]. Chinese journal of health policy, 2022, 15(4): 45-51.
[35] 何林莹, 马海群. 地方公共数据政策量化评价研究——基于PMC指数模型[J]. 现代情报, 2023, 43(8): 14-26. (HE L Q, MA H Q. Quantitative evaluation of local public data policy: based on PMC index model[J]. Journal of modern information, 2023, 43(8): 14-26.)
[36] 张永安, 耿喆. 我国区域科技创新政策的量化评价——基于PMC指数模型[J]. 科技管理研究, 2015, 35(14): 26-31. (ZHANG Y A, GENG Z. The quantitative evaluation of regional science and technology innovation policy: based on the index of PMC model[J]. Science and technology management research, 2015, 35(14): 26-31.)
[37] 马超, 陈亚丽.基于Citespace和Vosviewer的国内外网络治理研究的可视化分析[J]. 西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2021, 42(8): 229-240. (MA C, CHEN Y L. Visualization and analysis of domestic and international research on network governance based on Citespace and Vosviewer[J]. Journal of Southwest Minzu University(humanities and social sciences edition), 2021, 42(8): 229-240.)
[38] 支振锋, 刘佳琨. 互联网信息内容治理的中国方案[J]. 江西社会科学, 2023, 43(11): 176-187. (ZHI Z F, LIU J K. China's program on internet information content governance[J]. Jiangxi social sciences, 2023, 43(11): 176-187.)
[39] 王建亚, 马榕培, 周毅. 网络信息内容安全风险:特征、演变及场景要素解构[J]. 图书情报工作, 2022, 66(5): 13-23. (WANG J Y, MA R P, ZHOU Y. Characteristics, evolution and deconstruction of scene elements on security risks of network information contents[J]. Library and information service, 2022, 66(5): 13-23.)
[40] 霍帆帆, 霍朝光, 马海群.我国数据治理相关政策量化剖析:发展脉络、政策主体、政策渊源与政策工具[J]. 情报学报, 2023, 42(12): 1424-1437. (HUO F F, HUO C G, MA H Q. Quantitative analysis of data governance policies in China: policy evolution path, policy subject, sources of policy, and policy tools[J]. Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information, 2023, 42(12): 1424-1437.)
[41] 姜博胧. 网络谣言的法律规制研究[J]. 现代商贸工业, 2021, 42(34): 116-117. (JIANG B L. China's program on internet information content governance[J]. Modern business trade industry, 2021, 42(34): 116-117.)
[42] 周建青, 张世政. 网络空间内容治理政策评价及其优化——基于PMC指数模型的分析[J]. 东北大学学报(社会科学版), 2023, 25(4): 70-80. (ZHOU J Q, ZHANG S Z. Evaluation and optimization of cyberspace content governance policies: an analysis based on PMC index model[J]. Journal of Northeastern University(social science), 2023, 25(4): 70-80.)
[43] 张倩, 马海群, 牛晓宏. 基于PMC指数模型的我国数据安全政策评价研究[J]. 现代情报, 2024, 44(8): 13-27, 136. (ZHANG Q, MA H Q, NIU X H. Research on Chinese data security policy evaluation based on РMC index model [J]. Journal of modern information, 2024, 44(8): 13-27, 136.)
[44] 张凌寒. 中国需要一部怎样的《人工智能法》?中国人工智能立法的基本逻辑与制度架构[J]. 法律科学(西北政法大学学报), 2024, 42(3): 3-17. (ZHANG L H. What kind of "Al law" should China have? Basic logic and systemic structure of China's Al legislative framework [J]. Science of law (journal of northwest university of political science and law), 2024, 42(3): 3-17.)
[45] 中华人民共和国国家互联网信息办公室. 专家解读|筑牢网络暴力信息治理法制底座[EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. https://www.cac.gov.cn/2024-06/14/c_1720043915013831.htm. (Cyberspace administration of China. expert interpretation | building a solid legal foundation for the governance of online violence information [EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. https://www.cac.gov.cn/2024-06/14/c_1720043915013831.htm.)
[46] European commission. shaping Europe’s digital future. illegal content on online platforms [EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/illegal-content-online-platforms.
[47] 王晓丽, 严驰. 生成式AI大模型的风险问题与规制进路:以GPT-4为例[J]. 北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版), 2025, 38(2): 17-27. (WANG X L, YAN C. Risk problem and regulation approach of generative Al foundation models: a case study of GPT-4[J]. Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics (social sciences edition), 2025, 38(2): 17-27.)
[48] 王智珑. 中国如何因应欧盟《数字服务法》“布鲁塞尔效应”[J]. 西昌学院学报(社会科学版), 2024, 36(6): 75-85. (WANG Z L. The "Brussels Effect" of the EU digital services act in the context of the global digital platform governance game and China's response [J]. Journal of Xichang University(social science edition), 2024, 36(6): 75-85.)
[49] 孙晋, 帕孜丽娅·玉苏甫. ChatGPT对数据合规的风险叠加及法律因应[J]. 法治现代化研究, 2023, 7(6): 53-70. (SUN J, PAZILIYA YUSUF. The impact of Chat GPT on data compliance and the response strategies[J]. Law and modernization, 2023, 7(6): 53-70.)
[50] 周巍, 张美丽. 西北五省(区)数字政府建设政策文本量化评价——基于PMC指数模型的分析[J]. 情报科学, 2023, 41(12): 99-109. (ZHOU W, ZHANG M L. Quantitative evaluation of digital government construction policy texts in five northwestern provinces: analysis based on PMC index model [J]. Information science, 2023, 41(12): 99-109.)
[51] 吴欣宇, 王品芝, 杨万淑, 等. 65.3%受访青年表示自己或周围人遭遇过网络暴力[N]. 中国青年报, 2023-06-20(7). (WU X Y, WANG P Z, YANG W S, et al. 65.3% of the surveyed youth reported experiencing online violence themselves or those around them [N]. China youth news, 2023-06-20(7).)
[52] 朱垚颖, 张博诚. 演进与调节:互联网内容治理中的政府主体研究[J]. 人民论坛·学术前沿, 2021(5): 102-107. (ZHU G Y, ZHANG B C. Evolution and adjustment: a study of government bodies in the internet content governance[J]. Frontiers, 2021(5): 102-107.)
[53] 中华人民共和国国务院新闻办公室. 《新时代的中国网络法治建设》白皮书(全文)[EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. http://www.scio.gov.cn/zfbps/zfbps_2279/202303/t20230320_709278.html. (The state council information office of the people's republic of China. China's law-based cyberspace governance in the new era[EB/OL]. [2025-04-26]. http://www.scio.gov.cn/zfbps/zfbps_2279/202303/t20230320_709278.html.)
[54] 余波, 邱均平. 文化强国背景下中国学术话语权评价体系的构建与提升路径探析——以中国社会科学学科为例[J]. 现代情报, 2024, 44(2): 160-169. (YU B, QIU J P. The construction of the system for evaluating China's academic in the context of cultural power strategy and exploring the path to enhancement---a case study of China social sciences [J]. Journal of modern information, 2024, 44(2): 160-169.)
[55] 敬力嘉. 网络参与行为刑事归责的“风险犯”模式及其反思[J]. 政治与法律, 2018(6): 41-54. (JING L J. Comments and rethinking about the "Risk Offence" mode of identifying criminal responsibility for internet participating conducts[J]. Political science and law, 2018(6): 41-54.)
[56] 罗斌, 宋素红. “避风港”内外“守门人”——中欧网络平台内容规制格局、模式比较[J]. 新闻记者, 2024(5): 98-112. (LUO B, SONG S H. The "gatekeepers" inside and outside the "safe harbor": a comparison of content regulation patterns and models between China and Europe's online platforms [J]. Shanghai journalism review, 2024(5): 98-112.)
[57] 杨龙, 吴涵博. 国家治理的空间建构:治理单元的设定与运用[J]. 天津社会科学, 2022(2): 40-47. (YANG L, WU H B. The spatial construction of national governance: the setting and application of governance units[J]. Tianjin social sciences, 2022(2): 40-47.)
[58] 刘慧, 范德波特. 欧洲研究区跨区域协同创新治理举措及启示[J]. 科技管理研究, 2024, 44(4): 159-166. (LIU H, KIM Van der Borght. Measures and enlightenment on cross regional collaborative innovation governance in European research area[J]. Science and technology management research, 2024, 44(4): 159-166.)
[59] 陈道英. 我国互联网非法有害信息的法律治理体系及其完善[J]. 东南学术, 2020(1): 222-228. (CHEN D Y. The system for legal governance of illegal and harmful information on the internet and its improvement in China[J]. Southeast academic research, 2020(1): 222-228.)
[60] 黄楚新, 许可. 融合十年:从新闻传播现代化到国家治理现代化[J]. 新闻与写作, 2023(11): 5-11. (HUANG C X, XU K. Ten years of integration: from the modernization of news communication to the modernization of national governance[J]. News and writing, 2023(11): 5-11.)
[61] 王天凡. 数字平台的“阶梯式”监管模式:以欧盟《数字服务法》为鉴[J]. 欧洲研究, 2023, 41(2): 50-77, 6. (WANG T F. The "Laddered" model of digital platform regulation: with the EU's "Digital Services Act" as a lesson[J]. Chinese journal of European studies, 2023, 41(2): 50-77, 6.)
文章导航

/

〈 〉