综述述评

基于内容分析的数字人文领域中知识组织价值体现研究综述

  • 司莉 ,
  • 郭财强
展开
  • 1. 武汉大学信息资源研究中心 武汉 430072;
    2. 武汉大学信息管理学院 武汉 430072
司莉,教授,博士生导师,E-mail:lsiwhu@163.com;郭财强,博士研究生。

收稿日期: 2021-11-16

  修回日期: 2022-03-28

  网络出版日期: 2022-07-06

A Review of the Value Embodiment of Knowledge Organization in the Digital Humanities Field Based on Content Analysis

  • Si Li ,
  • Guo Caiqiang
Expand
  • 1. Research Center of Information Resource, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072;
    2. School of Information Management, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072

Received date: 2021-11-16

  Revised date: 2022-03-28

  Online published: 2022-07-06

摘要

[目的/意义]对知识组织方法与技术在数字人文领域的应用情况进行系统梳理,以更好地把握其实际应用特点,明确数字人文领域知识组织的价值,并为后续相关研究与实践提供借鉴。[方法/过程]采用文献调研法获取国内外数字人文领域相关研究文献,并基于内容分析法对其进行深入分析。[结果/结论]研究发现:元数据、本体、语义标注、关联数据等知识组织方法与技术贯穿数字人文的始终,是数字人文的有机组成部分;知识组织可为数字人文资源的组织提供解决方案与方法工具,为人们观察文化现象历史演化提供新视角,赋予人们获取新知识、发现新问题的能力;知识组织在数字人文领域发挥了方法价值和中介价值,为数字人文领域资源的组织与利用提供方法工具,充当用户与数字人文领域资源之间的桥梁。

本文引用格式

司莉 , 郭财强 . 基于内容分析的数字人文领域中知识组织价值体现研究综述[J]. 图书情报工作, 2022 , 66(13) : 127 -137 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2022.13.012

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] A systematic review of the application of knowledge organization (KO) methods and technologies in the digital humanities (DH) field can better grasp the characteristics of their practical applications and clarify the value of KO in the DH field, and provide references for future related research and practice. [Method/Process] Using the literature research method to obtain relevant research literature in the DH field at home and abroad, after which in-depth analysis based on the content analysis method was conducted. [Result/Conclusion] The research finds that KO methods and technologies such as metadata, ontology, semantic annotation, and linked data run through the whole process of DH, and they are an organic part of DH; KO can provide solutions, methods and tools for the organization of DH resources, provide a new perspective for people to observe the historical evolution of cultural phenomena, and endow people with the ability to acquire new knowledge and find new problems. KO plays a methodological and intermediary value in the DH field, and provides methods and tools for organizing and utilizing resources in the DH field, which act as a bridge between users and resources in the DH field.

参考文献

[1] 王晓光."数字人文"的产生、发展与前沿[C]//教育部人文社会科学研究方法创新论坛文集.武汉:武汉大学出版社, 2010:207-220.
[2] 王知津,李培,李颖,等.知识组织理论与方法[M].北京:知识产权出版社,2009.
[3] STUDER R, BENJAMINS V R, FENSEL D. Knowledge engineering:principles and methods[J]. Data&knowledge engineering, 1998, 25(1/2):161-197.
[4] 刘炜.关联数据:概念、技术及应用展望[J].大学图书馆学报,2011,29(2):5-12.
[5] 刘晓娟,潘银蓉,刘慧平,等.数字人文视角下古建筑描述模型设计研究——以什刹海地区为例[J].图书情报工作,2020,64(19):119-127.
[6] 吴琼,鲍泓.基于地理本体的不可移动文物信息参考模型研究及应用[J].计算机科学,2008,35(3):113-116,212.
[7] 雷鸣宇.数字化背景下我国不可移动文物的类型与关联性表达[D].合肥:中国科学技术大学,2017.
[8] 侯西龙,谈国新,庄文杰,等.基于关联数据的非物质文化遗产知识管理研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2019,45(2):88-108.
[9] MESSAOUDI T, VERON P, HALIN G, et al. An ontological model for the reality-based 3D annotation of heritage building conservation state[J]. Journal of cultural heritage, 2018,29(1/2):100-112.
[10] WANG X G, CHANG W L, TAN X. Representing and linking Dunhuang cultural heritage information resources using knowledge graph[J].Knowledge organization,2020,47(7):604-615.
[11] 郝挺雷.传统节日知识本体的构建及表示方法研究[D].武汉:华中师范大学,2011.
[12] TAN G X, HAO T L, ZHONG Z. A knowledge modeling framework for intangible cultural heritage based on ontology[C]//2009 second international symposium on knowledge acquisition and modeling, New York:IEEE, 2009:304-307.
[13] 隗昊,孙瑜.基于OWL的民族节日领域本体的构建研究[J].信息技术与信息化,2016(11):87-89.
[14] DOU J H, QIN J Y, JIN Z X, et al. Knowledge graph based on domain ontology and natural language processing technology for Chinese intangible cultural heritage[J]. Journal of visual languages&computing, 2018,48:19-28.
[15] HU J, LV Y C, ZHANG M.The ontology design of intangible cultural heritage based on CIDOC CRM[J].International journal of u-&e-service,science&technology,2014,7(1):261-274.
[16] 周耀林,赵跃,孙晶琼.非物质文化遗产信息资源组织与检索研究路径——基于本体方法的考察与设计[J].情报杂志,2017,36(8):166-174.
[17] 孙传明.民俗舞蹈类非物质文化遗产数字化技术研究[D].武汉:华中师范大学,2013.
[18] DAQUINO M, MAMBELLI F, PERONI S, et al. Enhancing semantic expressivity in the cultural heritage domain:exposing the Zeri Photo Archive as linked open data[J]. Journal on computing&cultural heritage, 2016,10(4):1-21.
[19] MORAITOU E, KAVAKLI E. Knowledge management using ontology on the domain of artworks conservation[C]//Digital cultural heritage.Cham:Springer, 2018:50-62.
[20] 董坤.非物质文化遗产本体构建与语义化组织研究[J].数字图书馆论坛,2014(10):40-45.
[21] HERNANDEZ F, RODRIGO L, CONTRERAS J, et al. Building a cultural heritage ontology for Cantabria[C]//Proceedings of the 2008 annual conference of the international documentation committee of the international council of museums. Athens:CIDOC,2008:1-14.
[22] 谈国新,侯西龙,庄文杰.非物质文化遗产多媒体资源语义组织研究[J].图书馆学研究,2017(24):42-52.
[23] 侯西龙.非物质文化遗产视频资源语义组织研究[D].武汉:华中师范大学,2018.
[24] 曾子明,周知,蒋琳.基于关联数据的数字人文视觉资源知识组织研究[J].情报资料工作,2018,39(6):6-12.
[25] 姚天泓,陈艳梅,刘革,等.基于CIDOC-CRM的数字人文史料资源语义化知识组织研究——以张学良史料资源为例[J].图书馆学刊,2019,41(7):35-43.
[26] 李跃艳,王昊,孟镇,等.基于关联数据的汉语文本语义化描述和展示[J].情报理论与实践,2021,44(6):171-179.
[27] LI H, ZHU L L, SHEN W, et al.Research on knowledge organization and visualization of historical events in the republic of China era[J]. Library trends, 2020,69(1):138-163.
[28] MAKELA E, TORNROOS J, LINDQUIST T, et al. WW1LOD:an application of CIDOC-CRM to World War 1 linked data[J]. International journal on digital libraries, 2017, 18(4):333-343.
[29] HYVONEN E, HEINO E,LESKINEN P,et al. WarSampo data service and semantic portal for publishing linked open data about the Second World War history[C]//International semantic Web conference. Cham:Springer,2016:758-773.
[30] 张乐,常娥.基于Drupal的民国建筑知识库关联数据的组织与发布研究[J].图书馆学研究,2018(19):64-70.
[31] CHEN J J, OU S Y. Research on the construction of the semantic model for Chinese ancient architectures based on architectural narratives[J]. The electronic library,2020,38(4):769-784.
[32] 刘美杏,徐芳.古道线性文化遗产信息资源关联数据模型构建及其实证研究[J].图书馆学研究,2019(14):40-50.
[33] BLANKE T,BODARD G,BRYANT M,et al. Linked data for humanities research-The SPQR experiment[C]//Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE international conference on digital ecosystems technologies. New York:IEEE,2012:1-6.
[34] KIM H, MATUSZKA T, KIM J I, et al. Ontology-based mobile augmented reality in cultural heritage sites:information modeling and user study[J]. Multimedia tools and applications, 2017, 76(24):26001-26029.
[35] 邓君,钟楚依,王阮,等.清代职官知识组织与关联分析——以《长春县志·长春职官考释表》为例[J].图书情报工作,2020,64(17):18-26.
[36] 郭建伟.《四库全书总目》职官类本体模型构建探究[J].情报探索,2014(4):84-87.
[37] 夏翠娟,林海青,刘炜.面向循证实践的中文古籍数据模型研究与设计[J].中国图书馆学报,2017,43(6):16-34.
[38] 夏翠娟,刘炜,张磊,等.基于书目框架(BIBFRAME)的家谱本体设计[J].图书馆论坛,2014,34(11):5-19.
[39] 陈玖瑜.数字人文视阈下民国报纸知识图谱构建研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2020.
[40] 夏翠娟,张磊,贺晨芝.面向知识服务的图书馆数字人文项目建设:方法、流程与技术[J].图书馆论坛,2018,38(1):1-9.
[41] LOMBARBO V, PIZZO A. Ontologies for the metadata annotation of stories[C]//Digital heritage international congress. New York:IEEE, 2013:153-160.
[42] LOMBARBO V, PIZZO A. Multimedia tool suite for the visualization of drama heritage metadata[J]. Multimedia tools&applications,2016,75(7):3901-3932.
[43] COLADANGELO L P. Thesaurus and ontology construction for contra dance:knowledge organization of a North American folk dance domain[J].Knowledge organization,2020,47(7):523-542.
[44] 刘宁静,刘音,王莫言,等.数字人文视角下学术名人知识模型构建研究——以李政道数字资源中心为例[J].图书情报工作,2019,63(23):113-121.
[45] 徐晨飞,包平,张惠敏,等.基于关联数据的方志物产史料语义化知识组织研究[J].大学图书馆学报,2020,38(6):78-88.
[46] 宋钰.古建筑领域本体模型的构建及检索[D].北京:北京建筑大学,2013.
[47] 徐晨飞,倪媛,钱智勇.基于本体的"江海文化"文献知识组织体系构建研究[J].现代情报,2015,35(10):62-71.
[48] 宋丹丹.数字人文视阈下云南少数民族节日文化信息资源建设研究[D].昆明:云南大学,2019.
[49] 徐月洁.古建筑领域本体的构建及应用研究[D].桂林:广西师范大学,2017.
[50] ACIERNO M, CURSI S, SIMEONE D, et al. Architectural heritage knowledge modelling:an ontology-based framework for conservation process[J]. Journal of cultural heritage, 2017,24(3/4):124-133.
[51] ISA W M W, ZIN N A M, ROSDI F, et al. Ontology modeling of intangible cultural heritage Terengganu Brassware craft[C]//2019 International conference on electrical engineering and informatics.New York:IEEE, 2019:1-6.
[52] ROBLEDANO-ARILLO J, NAVARRO-BONILLA D, CERDA-DIAZ J. Application of linked open data to the coding and dissemination of Spanish Civil War photographic archives[J]. Journal of documentation, 2020, 76(1):67-95.
[53] HASSAN J A, ODEJOBI O A, ÒGUNFOLAKAN B A, et al. Ontology engineering in Yorùbá cultural heritage domain[J]. African journal of computing&ICT,2013,6(5):181-189.
[54] SHIMIZU C, HITZLER P, HIRT Q, et al. The enslaved ontology:peoples of the historic slave trade[J]. Journal of Web semantics, 2020.DOI:10.1016/j.websem.2020.100567.
[55] 蔡璐,熊拥军,刘灿姣.基于本体和元数据的非遗资源知识组织体系构建[J].图书馆理论与实践,2016(3):39-43.
[56] 滕春娥,王萍.非物质文化遗产资源知识组织本体构建研究[J].情报科学,2018,36(4):160-163,176.
[57] 程齐凯,周耀林,戴旸.论基于本体的非物质文化遗产分类组织方法[J].信息资源管理学报,2011,1(3):78-83.
[58] DONIG S, CHRISTOFORAKI M, HANDSCHUH S. Neoclassica-a multilingual domain ontology[C]//International workshop on computational history&data-driven humanities. Cham:Springer, 2016:41-53.
[59] TIBAUT A, BRANKO K, PERHAVEC D D. Ontology-based data collection for heritage buildings[C]//Digital cultural heritage. Cham:Springer, 2018:63-78.
[60] 黄永,陆伟,程齐凯,等.非物质文化遗产知识本体构建系统的设计与实现——以西藏"锅庄"、"堆谐"为例[J].西藏民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2016,37(1):20-26,154.
[61] 王晓光,徐雷,李纲.敦煌壁画数字图像语义描述方法研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2014,40(1):50-59.
[62] 徐雷,王晓光.叙事型图像语义标注模型研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2017,43(5):70-83.
[63] LI X H, WU Y Q, WANG X G, et al. Towards a semantics representation framework for narrative images[J].The electronic library,2019,37(3):386-400.
[64] 曾子明,周知.面向数字人文的图像语义描述模型研究[J].情报理论与实践,2018,41(1):116-121.
[65] 陈涛,张永娟,单蓉蓉,等.数字人文图像资源语义化建设框架研究[J].数字人文,2020(2):106-115.
[66] 陈涛,单蓉蓉,李惠.数字人文中图像资源的语义化标注研究[J].农业图书情报学报,2020,32(9):6-14.
[67] 周知,蒋琳.数字人文图像资源知识组织模型构建研究[J].图书馆学研究,2021(8):66-72,65.
[68] STORK L, WEBER A, MIRACLE E, et al. Semantic annotation of natural history collections[J]. Journal of Web semantics, 2019,59:1-13.
[69] 宋宁远,王晓光.基于情节本体的叙事性文本语义结构化表示方法研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2020,46(2):96-113.
[70] 李斌,王璐,陈小荷,等.数字人文视域下的古文献文本标注与可视化研究——以《左传》知识库为例[J].大学图书馆学报,2020,38(5):72-80,90.
[71] VLACHIDIS A, TUDHOPE D. A knowledge-based approach to information extraction for semantic interoperability in the archaeology domain[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology, 2016,67(5):1138-1152.
[72] CHEN C M, CHEN Y T, LIU C Y. Development and evaluation of an automatic text annotation system for supporting digital humanities research[J]. Library hi tech, 2019,37(3):436-455.
[73] CHEN C M, TSAY M Y, BLOECHLE M. Applications of collaborative annotation system in digital curation, crowdsourcing, and digital humanities[J]. The electronic library,2017,35(6):1122-1140.
[74] 左丹,欧石燕.人文信息资源语义描述、语义组织研究与实践述评[J].图书馆论坛,2019,39(8):21-31.
[75] 王伟,许鑫.融合关联数据和分众分类的徽州文化数字资源多维度聚合研究[J].图书情报工作,2015,59(14):31-36,58.
[76] 董行.面向跨语言家谱服务的多源关联数据匹配研究——上海图书馆开放数据应用比赛作品Learn Chinese Surnames[J].大学图书馆学报,2018,36(4):50-57,103.
[77] FREIRE N, MEIJERS E, VALK S d, et al. Aggregation of linked data:a case study in the cultural heritage domain[C]//IEEE international conference on big data.New York:IEEE, 2018:522-527.
[78] 张志美,陈涛,钱智勇,等.面向数字人文的辞书关联数据知识组织[J].图书馆论坛,2021,41(12):124-134.
[79] 陈涛,刘炜,单蓉蓉,等.知识图谱在数字人文中的应用研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2019,45(6):34-49.
[80] 周莉娜,洪亮,高子阳.唐诗知识图谱的构建及其智能知识服务设计[J].图书情报工作,2019,63(2):24-33.
[81] 刘昱彤,吴斌,白婷.古诗词图谱的构建及分析研究[J].计算机研究与发展,2020,57(6):1252-1268.
[82] 夏翠娟,张磊.关联数据在家谱数字人文服务中的应用[J].图书馆杂志,2016,35(10):26-34.
[83] 夏翠娟,刘炜,陈涛,等.家谱关联数据服务平台的开发实践[J].中国图书馆学报, 2016,42(3):27-38.
[84] 蔡迎春.数字人文视域下的图书馆特藏资源数字化建设——以"民国时期文献目录数据平台"为例[J].图书馆建设,2018(7):31-36,41.
[85] 张毅,李欣.面向数字人文的特藏资源揭示研究——以方志数据库建设为例[J].图书馆,2019(6):100-105.
[86] 鲁丹,李欣.整合异构特藏资源构建数字人文系统[J].图书馆论坛,2018,38(10):38-46,29.
[87] 李姗姗,赵跃.基于关联数据的非物质文化遗产档案资源开发[J].中国档案,2016(6):71-73.
[88] 舒忠梅.数字人文背景下的档案知识图谱构建研究[J].山西档案,2020(2):53-60.
[89] NIU L, LIU L C, GAO C X, et al. Building a memory map to reconstruct an urban memory:the case of the Beijing city gates[J].Library trends, 2020,69(1):76-100.
[90] 崔春,毕强.关联数据在数字人文领域中的应用剖析——以关联爵士项目为例[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(24):99-105.
[91] 仝召娟,许鑫,钱佳轶.基于关联数据的非遗数字资源聚合研究[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(21):21-26.
[92] 童茵,张彬.董其昌数字人文项目的探索与实践[J].中国博物馆,2018(4):114-118.
[93] 杨海慈,王军.宋代学术师承知识图谱的构建与可视化[J].数据分析与知识发现,2019,3(6):109-116.
[94] WEI J Z, LIU R. An approach of constructing knowledge graph of the hundred schools of thought in ancient China[C]//2019 ACM/IEEE joint conference on digital libraries. New York:IEEE, 2019:335-336.
[95] SANDE M V, VERBORGH R,HOCHSTENBACH P,et al. Toward sustainable publishing and querying of distributed linked data archives[J]. Journal of documentation, 2018,74(1):195-222.
[96] YANG Y, ZHANG G G, WANG J, et al. Public cultural knowledge graph platform[C]//2017 IEEE 11th international conference on semantic computing. New York:IEEE, 2017:322-327.
[97] BAIERER K, DROGE E, ECKERT K, et al. DM2E:a linked data source of digitised manuscripts for the digital humanities[J]. Semantic Web,2017,8(5):733-745.
[98] SZTYLER T, HUBER J, NOESSNER J, et al. LODE:linking digital humanities content to the Web of data[C]//IEEE/ACM joint conference on digital libraries.New York:IEEE, 2014:423-424.
[99] HYVONEN E. Linked open data infrastructure for digital humanities in Finland[C]//Proceedings of digital humanities in Nordic Countries 5th conference. Aachen:CEUR Workshop Proceedings, 2020:254-259.
[100] 顾建新,袁曦临,常娥.南京民国建筑与文化数字博物馆建设研究[J].新世纪图书馆,2011(12):37-39,26.
[101] 刘美杏,徐芳.古道文化遗产信息资源元数据标准制定——以潇贺古道为例[J].情报资料工作,2019,40(4):77-83.
[102] 李建伟.特色文化资源信息组织方法与数据共享模型研究——以"世界客都"古民居数字记忆工程为例[J].图书馆杂志,2018,37(5):39-44.
[103] 倪冬冬,达吾提.维吾尔族达斯坦元数据规范化研究[J].山西档案,2015(4):108-111.
[104] MI X Y, POLLOCK B M. Metadata schema to facilitate linked data for 3D digital models of cultural heritage collections:a university of South Florida libraries case study[J]. Cataloging&classification quarterly, 2018,56(2/3):273-286.
[105] 许鑫,张悦悦.非遗数字资源的元数据规范与应用研究[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(21):13-20.
[106] 胡以涛,惠富平.元数据方法在数字人文视域下的应用探索——以农业文化遗产为例[J].图书馆,2019(1):82-87.
[107] 兰绪柳,孟放.数字文化资源的元数据格式分析[J].现代情报,2013,33(8):61-64.
[108] MI X Y, BERNARDY R, SCHMIDT L E. Building an archaeological data repository:a digital library and digital humanities collaboration at the University of South Florida[J].International journal on digital libraries,2021,22(1):135-145.
[109] QUBUMO B, GUO C X, YIN H B, et al. Customizing discipline based metadata standards for digital preservation of living epic traditions in China:basic principles and challenges[C]//Proceedings of digital heritage international congress. New York:IEEE,2013:145-151.
[110] CHAO G J. Ethnic oral tradition archives of the institute of ethnic literature:its dilemma and a way out[C]//The fourth forum on china-US intangible cultural heritage:fieldwork,documentation, preservation,and access. Washington,DC:National Museum of the American Indian,Smithsonian Institution,2013:11-17.
[111] 李波.非物质文化遗产信息资源元数据模型研究[J].图书馆界,2011(5):38-41.
[112] YE P, ZHOU Y L. The framework and standards of Chinese intangible cultural heritage metadata[C]//2013 international conference on applied social science research. Paris:Atlantis Press,2013:688-691.
[113] 宋丽华,李万社,董涛.非物质文化遗产数字化保护与知识整合平台建设[J].图书馆杂志,2015,34(1):73-81.
[114] 鲁丹,李欣.数字人文环境下异构方志元数据整合策略[J].图书馆论坛,2019,39(4):158-165.
[115] 王丽丽,朱小梅.古籍钤印元数据著录规范设计与应用研究[J].图书馆,2020(1):106-111.
[116] 夏翠娟.文化记忆资源的知识融通:从异构资源元数据应用纲要到一体化本体设计[J].图书情报知识,2021(1):53-65.作者贡献说明:司莉:提出研究思路,设计研究方案,修订论文最终版本;郭财强:撰写论文初稿及修改。
文章导航

/