北京大学信息管理系成立75周年学术专辑

引文分析视角下的中国古诗词用典问题初探

  • 蔡竹娟 ,
  • 赵丹群
展开
  • 北京大学信息管理系 北京 100871
蔡竹娟,硕士研究生。

收稿日期: 2022-07-29

  修回日期: 2022-09-12

  网络出版日期: 2022-11-17

Research on Allusions Usage in Ancient Chinese Poetry from the Perspective of Citation Analysis

  • Cai Zhujuan ,
  • Zhao Danqun
Expand
  • Department of Information Management, Peking University, Beijing 100871

Received date: 2022-07-29

  Revised date: 2022-09-12

  Online published: 2022-11-17

摘要

[目的/意义] 基于引文分析视角对中国古诗词用典问题进行理论分析和实证研究,致力于促进传统人文研究范式向当前大数据时代基于数据驱动的量化研究范式的转变与拓展,推动中国古诗词用典研究与文献计量学方法的交叉融合与创新性发展。[方法/过程] 首先通过对中国古诗词用典行为(现象)与学术论文引用行为(现象)之间异同点的比较对照,对古诗词用典现象的产生与发展、用典动机与用典行为、用典关系与用典网络等进行理论分析;其次,选用《全宋词》和《全宋词典故辞典》等语料,从施典维度和典源维度对宋词用典开展量化实证研究。[结果/结论] 中国古诗词用典现象历史悠久,研究议题丰富,现阶段亟需研究范式的创新和转变。通过理论分析和实证结果可以看出,引文分析法有助于在较大规模古诗词语料上开展更深入的探索。目前研究存在的最大困难在于典故自动识别和提取。未来需加强与NLP技术的密切结合,致力在典故识别提取、用典动机与用典行为分类、用典网络与典故知识图谱构建等问题上提出更有效的自动化解决方案和量化分析策略,以有力促进传统人文研究范式由理论阐释到实证解读、由主观判断到客观揭示、由定性分析到定量分析的转变,并在更多数字人文研究议题上产生出具有创新性的成果。

本文引用格式

蔡竹娟 , 赵丹群 . 引文分析视角下的中国古诗词用典问题初探[J]. 图书情报工作, 2022 , 66(20) : 82 -92 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2022.20.009

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] From the perspective of citation analysis (CA), the paper theoretically analyzes and empirically studies the use of allusions in ancient Chinese poetry in order to promote the transformation and expansion of paradigm from traditional humanistic research to data-driven quantitative research in the era of big data, which is helpful in integration and innovative development of ancient Chinese poetry allusion studies and bibliometric methods. [Method/Process] Firstly, the paper gave a completely comparative discussion focusing on their similarities and differences between the allusion behaviors (phenomenons) in ancient Chinese poetry and the citation behaviors (phenomenons) among academic papers from the following three aspects:① ancient Chinese poetry allusion phenomenon and its emergence & development; ② motivations and behaviors while using allusions; ③ allusion relationships and allusion networks. Secondly, a quantitive empirical study about allusions using based on The Complete Song Ci & The Allusions' Dictionary of Song Ci was carried out in two dimensions:the literatures of using allusions and the literatures of producing allusions. [Result/Conclusion] The phenomenon of using allusions in ancient Chinese poetry has a long history along with rich topics to be studied, the innovation and transformation of research paradigm are needed urgently at present stage. Through theoretical analysis and empirical results, it can be seen that the citation analysis method is helpful to carry out more in-depth exploration on a large scale of ancient Chinese poetry corpus. The biggest difficulty in current research lies in automatic recognition and extraction of allusions. In the future, it is necessary to strengthen the close combination with NLP technology, and strive to put forward more effective automatic solutions and quantitative analysis strategies in allusion identification and extraction, motivation and behavior classification of using allusions, allusion network and allusion knowledge graph construction, so as to effectively promote the transformation of traditional humanistic research paradigm from theoretical analysis to empirical interpretation, from subjective judgment to objective disclosure, from qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis, and produce innovative results on more Digital Humanities(DH) research topics.

参考文献

[1] 谌东飚. 唐前诗歌用典考察[J]. 长沙水电师院社会科学学报, 1996(4):57-62.
[2] 范之麟, 刘扬忠, 徐燕. 全宋词典故辞典[M]. 武汉:湖北辞书出版社, 2001:1.
[3] 林岗. 论引诗[J]. 文艺理论研究, 2007(4):43-49.
[4] 王思豪. 一个被遮蔽的语体结构选择现象——论汉赋用《诗》"《诗》曰"的隐去[J].文学遗产, 2013(4):55-61.
[5] 李鹏飞. 中古诗歌用典美学研究[M]. 武汉:武汉大学出版社,2016:29.
[6] 马草. 诗性功能与文学自觉——魏晋南北朝文学用典的审美原理考察[J]. 哈尔滨工业大学学报(社会科学版), 2018, 20(6):75-81.
[7] 胡大雷. 六朝诗歌用典论——兼论"诗言志"与集体无意识[J]. 文学评论, 2014(5):154-160.
[8] 秦红丽. 晚唐诗歌用典艺术研究[D]. 南京:南京师范大学,2019.
[9] 董朝刚. 也论宋诗特点——关于"以文字为诗,以议论为诗,以才学为诗"的若干思考[J].唐山师范学院学报, 2004(4):10-12,61.
[10] 刘颖. 文字、才学、议论——关于苏黄"以文字为诗,以才学为诗,以议论为诗"的若干思考[J]. 安徽文学(下半月), 2008(5):56-57.
[11] 莫砺锋. 黄庭坚"夺胎换骨"辨[J]. 中国社会科学, 1983(5):187-198.
[12] 陈福升. 论词中用典与唐宋词的发展[J]. 内蒙古社会科学(汉文版), 2003(S1):106-107.
[13] 李定广. 论北宋词与晚唐诗的近亲关系——兼论正确解读宋词化用唐诗现象的文化涵义[J]. 求索, 2006(11):170-172,187.
[14] 吴承学. 论宋代櫽括词[J]. 文学遗产, 2000(4):10.
[15] 郑园. 论东坡檃括词[J]. 文学遗产, 2006(3):147-149.
[16] 范进军. 试论稼轩词用典的方式[J]. 船山学刊, 2006(1):111-114.
[17] 张岳伦. 中国古典诗词用典简论[J]. 湖南人文科技学院学报, 2007(1):138-140.
[18] Chinses-Poetry中国诗歌古典文集数据库(CPDB)[EB/OL]. [2022-06-13]. https://github.com/chinese-poetry.
[19] GARFIELD E. Can citation indexing be automated?[C]// STEVENS M E, GIULIANO V E, HEILPRIN L B. Statistical association methods for mechanized documentation: symposium proceedings. Washington DC: The National Bureau of Standards, 1965:189-192.
[20] WEINSTOCK M. Citation indexes[M]//KENT A. Encyclopedia of library and information science: Vol.5. New York: Marcel Dekker,1971:16-40.
[21] THORNE F C. The citation index: another case of spurious validity[J]. Journal of clinical psychology, 1977, 33(4): 1157-1161.
[22] BROOKS T A. Private acts and public objects: an investigation of citer motivations[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 1985, 36(4):223-229.
[23] BORNMANN L, DANIEL H. What do citation counts measure? a review of studies on citing behavior[J]. Journal of documentation, 2008, 64 (1) : 45-80.
[24] 罗积勇. 用典研究[M]. 武汉:武汉大学出版社, 2005.
[25] 舒非, 丰鹂萱, 邱均平,等. 基于我国古籍引经据典现象的引文分析研究[J]. 情报学报, 2021, 40(12): 1338-1346.
[26] 朱栋. 唐代试律诗用典研究[D]. 武汉:武汉大学, 2013.
[27] 陈望道. 修辞学发凡[M]. 上海:上海人民出版社, 1976:97.
[28] 范之麟, 吴庚舜. 全唐诗典故辞典[M]. 武汉:湖北辞书出版社, 1989.
[29] 彭庆生, 曲令启. 诗词典故词典[M]. 太原:书海出版社, 1990.
[30] 赵应铎. 中国典故大辞典(辞书版)[M]. 上海:上海辞书出版社, 2014.
[31] 姚蕊. 基于典故领域本体的诗词用典自动分析系统[J]. 软件导刊, 2011,10(6):80-82.
[32] 搜韵[EB/OL].[2022-08-07]. https://sou-yun.cn/index.aspx.
[33] TANG X, LIANG S, ZHENG J, et al. Automatic recognition of allusions in Tang poetry based on BERT[C]//2019 international conference on Asian Language Processing (IALP). Piscataway: IEEE, 2019.
[34] 张明华. 集句诗的发展及其特点[J]. 南京师范大学文学院学报, 2006(4):24-29.
[35] 刘成国. "荆公体"别解[J]. 文学遗产, 2006(4):149-151.
[36] 左汉林, 高付军. 宋代集杜诗发展的三个阶段及其特征[J]. 渭南师范学院学报, 2012, 27(11):88-92.
[37] 唐圭璋, 缪钺, 叶嘉莹,等. 唐宋词鉴赏词典(唐·五代·北宋)[M]. 上海:上海辞书出版社, 1988:657.
[38] 文天祥. 文山先生全集[M]. 北京:北京市中国书店, 1985:387.
[39] 皎然. 诗式校注[M]. 周维德, 校注. 杭州:浙江古籍出版社, 1993:31.
[40] 张明华. 略论集句诗的文献价值及其相对性[J]. 文学遗产,2012(2):91-100.
[41] 卞仁海. 李善的征引式注释[J]. 信阳师范学院学报(哲学社会科学版), 2005(3):78-82.
[42] 萧统.《文选》[M]. 李善, 注. 北京:中华书局, 1977:329.
[43] 王乙珈. 用典与"注典"——宋代杜甫诗注中的《世说新语》及其学术意义[J]. 北京社会科学, 2021(3):13-24.
[44] 刘应竹. 学术论文中的引文失范问题刍议[J]. 编辑学报, 2014, 26(1):7-9.
[45] 唐圭璋. 全宋词[M]. 北京:中华书局, 1965.
[46] 王兆鹏. 论宋词的发展历程[J]. 暨南学报(哲学社会科学), 2000(6):14-23,29.作者贡献说明: 蔡竹娟:论文选题及写作,数据处理及实证分析; 赵丹群:选题指导,论文写作及后期修改。
文章导航

/