Library and Information Service >
A Review of Citation Context Classifications and Implementation Methods
Received date: 2015-12-22
Revised date: 2016-03-05
Online published: 2016-03-20
[Purpose/significance] This paper systematically summarizes the citation context classification standards and compares the implement methods, concludes the existing sides of application, to analyze the exiting problems and propose directions for improvement.[Method/process] It introduces several current points of classifying the citation context, such as citation functions, attitudes toward, citation influence, and compares the different implementations to analyze its advantages and disadvantages.[Result/conclusion] The current classification standards has no uniform rules, the access of all citation context is difficult and the computer processing is low accuracy and rarely no experiments of Chinese citation contexts. Future research directions are integrating classification rules, improving the accuracy of computer technology of citation context analysis, and increasing the range of applications.
Wang Wenjuan , Ma Jianxia , Chen Chun , Zhang Lingbo . A Review of Citation Context Classifications and Implementation Methods[J]. Library and Information Service, 2016 , 60(6) : 118 -127 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2016.06.018
[1] BORNMANN L, DANIEL H D. What do citation counts measure? a review of studies on citing behavior[J].Journal of documentation,2008,64(1):45-80.
[2] LIU M X. Progress in documentation-the complexities of citation practice-a review of crtation studies[J]. Journal of documentation,1993,49(4):370-408.
[3] NICOLAISEN J. Citation analysis[J]. Annual review of information science and technology,2007,41:609-641.
[4] RITCHIE A.Citation context analysis for information retrieval[D].Cambridge:University of Cambridge,2009.
[5] DING Y,ZHANG G, CHAMBERS T, et al. Content-based citation analysis:the next generation of citation analysis[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2014,65(9):1820-1833.
[6] 祝清松, 冷伏海. 引文内容分析方法研究综述[J]. 情报资料工作,2013(5):39-43.
[7] 祝清松, 冷伏海. 引文类型识别研究进展[J]. 图书情报知识,2013(6):70-76.
[8] 刘盛博, 丁堃, 唐德龙. 引用内容分析的理论与方法[J]. 情报理论与实践,2015(10):27-32.
[9] WHITE H D. Citation analysis and discourse analysis revisited[J]. Applied linguistics,2004,25(1):89-116.
[10] MERTON R K. The Matthew effect in science[J]. Science,1968,3810(159):59-63.
[11] GARFIELD E. Citation indexes for science-new dimension in documentation through association of ideas[J]. Science,1955,122(3159):108-111.
[12] LIPETZ B A. Improvement of the selectivity of citation indexes to science literature through inclusion of citation relationship indicators[J]. American documentation,1965,16(2):81-90.
[13] FROST C O. Use of citations in literary research-preliminary classification of citation functions[J]. Library quarterly,1979,49(4):399-414.
[14] CRONIN B. Norms and functions in citation-the view of journal editors and referees in psychology[J]. Social science information studies,1982,2(2):65-78.
[15] MORAVCSIK M J, MURUGESAN P. Some results on function and quality of citations[J]. Social studies of science,1975,5(1):86-92.
[16] OPPENHEIM C, RENN S P. Highly cited old papers and reasons why they continue to be cited[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1978,29(5):225-231.
[17] COLE S. Citations and the evaluation of individual scientists[J]. Trends in biochemical dciences,1989,14(1):9-14.
[18] CHANG Y W. A comparison of citation contexts between natural sciences and social sciences and humanities[J]. Scientometrics,2013,96(2):535-553.
[19] CAMACHO-MINANO M D M, NUNEZ-NICKEL M. The multilayered nature of reference selection[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2009,60(4):754-777.
[20] CHUBIN D E, MOITRA S D. Content-analysis of references-adjunct or alternative to citation counting[J]. Social studies of science,1975,5(4):423-441.
[21] 陈晓丽. 引文类型比较分析[J]. 图书与情报,1998(4):51-54.
[22] PERITZ B C. A classification of citation roles for the soclal-sciences and related fields[J]. Scientometrics,1983,5(5):303-312.
[23] COZZENS S E. Comparing the sciences-citation context analysis of papers from neuropharmacology and the sociology of science[J]. Scientometrics,1983,5(1):127-153.
[24] GILBERT G N. Referencing as persuasion[J]. Social studies of science,1977,7(1):113-122.
[25] BONZI S, SNYDER H W. Motivations for citation-a comparison of self citation and citation to others[J]. Scientometrics,1991,21(2):245-254.
[26] ROUSSEAU R. The gozinto theorem-using citations to determine influences on a scientific publication[J]. Scientometrics,1987,11(3/4):217-229.
[27] GARFIELDS E. Can citation indexing be automated? Essays of an Information Scientist[M].Philadelphia:ISI Press,1977:84-90.
[28] WEINSTOCK M. Citation index[M].Philadephia Institute for scientific Information,1971.
[29] THORNE F C. Citation index-another case of spurious validity[J]. Journal of clinical psychology,1977,33(4):1157-1161.
[30] SEN S K. A theoretical glance at citation process[J]. International forum on information and documentation,1990,15(1):1-7.
[31] VINKLER P. Comparative investigation of frequency and strength of motives toward referencing, the reference threshold model-comments on theories of citation?[J].Scientometrics,1998,43(1):107-127.
[32] BROOKS T A. Private acts and public objects-an investigation of citer motivations[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1985,36(4):223-229.
[33] CASE D O, MILLER J B. Do bibliometricians cite differently from other scholars?[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2011,62(3):421-432.
[34] 邱均平, 陈晓宇, 何文静.科研人员论文引用动机及相互影响关系研究[J]. 图书情报工作,2015,59(9):36-44.
[35] 马凤, 武夷山. 关于论文引用动机的问卷调查研究——以中国期刊研究界和情报学界为例[J]. 情报杂志,2009(6):9-14,18.
[36] MORAVCSIK M J, MURUGESAN P. Citation patterns in scientific revolutions[J]. Scientometrics,1979,1(2):161-169.
[37] MARTENS B V D, GOODRUM A A. The diffusion of theories:a functional approach[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):330-341.
[38] SULA C A, MILLER M. Citations, contexts, and humanistic discourse:toward automatic extraction and classification[J]. Literary and linguistic computing,2014,29(3):452-464.
[39] 刘盛博, 丁堃, 张春博.基于引用内容性质的引文评价研究[J]. 情报理论与实践,2015(3):77-81.
[40] MACROBERTS M H, MACROBERTS B R. Quantitative measures of communication in science-a study of the formal level[J]. Social studies of science,1986,16(1):151-172.
[41] BONZI S. Characteristics of a literature as predictors of relatedness between cited and citing works[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1982,33(4):208-216.
[42] WAN X J, LIU F. Are all literature citations equally important? Automatic citation strength estimation and its applications[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2014,65(9):1929-1938.
[43] MACROBERTS M H, MACROBERTS B R. Citation content analysis of a botany journal[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1997,48(3):274-275.
[44] TEUFEL S, SIDDHARTHAN A, TIDHAR D. Automatic classification of citation function[C]//EMNLP 2007, Proceedings of the 2006 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, 22-23 July 2006, Sydney, Australia.Stroudsburg:Association for Computational Linguistics,2006:73-92.
[45] 陈晓丽. 引文评价中的引文方式与力度因素[J]. 图书馆,2000(6):43-45.
[46] BERTIN M, ATANASSOVA I, GINGRAS Y, et al.The invariant distribution of references in scientific articles[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2016,67(1):164-177.
[47] HERLACH G. Can retrieval of information from citation indexes be simplified-multiple mention of a reference as a characteristic of link between cited and citing article[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1978,29(6):308-310.
[48] HALEVI G, MOED H F. The thematic and conceptual flow of disciplinary research:a citation context analysis of the journal of informetrics, 2007[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2013,64(9):1903-1913.
[49] 刘茜, 王健, 王剑.基于引文动机的文献老化研究[J]. 情报探索,2015(10):1-4.
[50] MURUGESAN P, MORAVCSIK M J. Variation of nature of citation measures with journals and scientific speclalties[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1978,29(3):141-147.
[51] SWALES J. Citation analysis and discourse analysis[J]. Applied linguistics,1986,7(1):39-56.
[52] GARZONE M, MERCER R E. Towards an automated citation classifier[C]//13th Biennial Conference of the Canadian Society for Computational Studies of Intelligence, AI 2000 Montéal, Quebec, Canada.Berlin:Springer,2000:337-346.
[53] NANBA H,OKUMURA M. Towards multi-paper Summarization Using Reference Information[C]//Proceedings of the Sixteenth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI '99). San Francisco:Morgan Kaufmann Publishers Inc., 1999:926-931.
[54] 刘盛博, 丁堃. 基于引用内容的引文评价分析[C]//中国科技政策与管理学术年会.北京:中国科学学与科技政策研究会,2013.
[55] PHAM S B, HOFFMANN A. A new approach for scientific citation classification using cue phrases[J].Advances in artificial intelligence,2003,2903:759-771.
[56] ZHU X D,TURNEY P, LEMIRE D,et al. Measuring academic influence:not all citations are equal[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2015,66(2):408-427.
[57] Radoslav R. Exploring automatic citation classification[D].Ontario:University of Waterloo, 2008.
[58] AGARWAL N K, XU Y J, POO D C C. A context-based investigation into source use by information seekers[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2011,62(6):1087-1104.
[59] LE M H, HO T B, NAKAMORI Y. Detecting citation types using finite-state machines[C]//10th Pacific-Asia Conference, PAKDD 2006.Singapore:Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2006:265-274.
[60] WANG S M, YANG W P, CHOU H P, et al.Automatic bibliographic component extraction using conditional random fields[J]. Journal of Internet Technology,2012,13(5):737-747.
[61] CHRISTIAN C, NICOLA L, ALEXANDER O. The incidence and role of negative citations in science[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2015, 112(45):13823-13826.
[62] McCAIN K W, SALVUCCI L J. How influential is Brooks' law? a iongitudinal citation context analysis of Frederick Brooks' The Mythical Man-Month[J]. Journal of information science,2006,32(3):277-295.
[63] 孙海生, 黄燕. 引用内容分析法在领域发展轨迹研究中的应用[J]. 情报探索,2015(9):56-60.
[64] COZZENS S E. Split citation identity-a case-study from economics[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1982,33(4):233-236.
[65] Giles L,Mitra P, WU J. CiteSeerX[EB/OL].[2015-12-21].http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/imdex.
[66] FUJIWARA T, YAMAMOTO Y. Colil:a database and search service for citation contexts in the life sciences domain[J]. Journal of biomedical semantics, 2015, 6(1):1-11.
[67] SHOTTON D, PORTWIN K, KLYNE G, et al.Adventures in semantic publishing:exemplar semantic enhancements of a research article[J]. PLOS computational biology,2009,5(4):17.
[68] LIU S B, CHEN C M, DING K, et al.Literature retrieval based on citation context[J]. Scientometrics,2014,101(2):1293-1307.
[69] DUNCAN J. Computer-assisted production of bibliographic databases in history[J]. Indexer,1981,12(3):131-139.
[70] HE Q,PEI J,KIFER D,et al.Context-aware citation recommendation[C]//Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on World Wide Web, WWW 2010.Raleigh, North Carolina, USA.New York:ACM,2010:421-430.
[71] ZARRINKALAM F, KAHANI M. SemCiR A citation recommendation system based on a novel semantic distance measure[J]. Program-electronic library and information systems,2013,47(1):92-112.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
