[Purpose/significance] This study aims to summarize the patent analysis methods of identifying technology's transfer potential and main influence factors, to provide the theoretical support for effectively identifying patent technology with transfer potential.[Method/process] According to the current situation of patent analysis method in the application of technology transfer, this paper makes the review on the related achievements about the analysis methods of identifying technology's potential transfer and influence indicators affecting technology transfer.[Result/conclusion] The existing analysis methods of identifying the potential of technology transfer mainly include the patent citation analysis, social network analysis, statistical analysis model, binary semantic analysis method and TRIZ method, which are all in the exploring stage. The main influence factor of technology transfer is patent value or patent quality. The future study on analysis methods of identifying patent technology's transfer potential can be carried out in the following directions:systematically exploring the direct influence factors of patent transfer and their actual effect; exploring the difference of patent transfer behaviors between companies and universities; constructing the prediction model for effectively identifying technology's transfer potential.
[1] 谢富纪.技术转移与技术贸易[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2006.
[2] 杨林松.国际技术转移中专利技术转移研究[J].工业技术创新,2014,1(2):221-225.
[3] 陶鑫良.专利技术转移[M].北京:知识产权出版社,2011.
[4] ABBAS A,ZHANG L M,SAMEE U K.A literature review on the state-of-the-art in patent analysis[J].World patent information, 2014,37(6):3-13.
[5] PENUBARTI M.How trade-related are intellectual property rights?[J].Journal of international economics, 1995,39(3/4):227-248.
[6] SMITH P J.Are weak patent rights a barrier to U.S.exports?[J].Journal of international economics, 1999,48(1):151-177.
[7] AWOKUSE T O,YIN H.Does stronger intellectual property rights protection induce more bilateral trade? evidence from China's imports[J].World development, 2010,38(8):1094-1104.
[8] PARK W G,LIPPOLDT D C.Technology transfer and the economic implications of the strengthening of intellectual property rights in developing countries[R].Pairs:OECD Trade Policy Working Papers,2008.
[9] ARORA A,CECCAGNOLI M.Patent protection, complementary assets, and firms' incentives for technology licensing[J].Management Science,2006, 52(2):293-308.
[10] AUTM. Licensing activity survey:FY2012[EB/OL].[2015-10-21].http://www.autm.net/FY2012_Licensing_Activity_Survey/11449.htm.
[11] 刘强.国际贸易相关的专利强制许可制度研究[D].上海:复旦大学,2009.
[12] DU R, AI S.Cross-organizational knowledge acquisition through flexible hiring and joint R&D:insights from a survey in China[J].Expert systems with applications,2008,35(1/2):434-441.
[13] PARK H S, REE J J, KIM K S.Identification of promising patents for technology transfers using TRIZ evolution trends[J].Expert systems with applications,2013,40(2):736-743.
[14] VERHAEGEN P A, D'HONDTJ, et al.Relatingproperties and functions from patents to TRIZ trends[J].CIRP J ManufSci Technol,2009,1(3):126-130.
[15] PARK H, YOON J, KIM K.Identifying patent infringement using SAO based semantic technological similarities[J].Scientometrics,2012,90(2):515-529.
[16] LEE C, SONG B, PARK Y.How to assess patent infringement risks:a semanticpatent claim analysis using dependency relationships[J].Technol Anal StratManag,2013,25(1):23-38.
[17] YONG G K, JONG H S, SANG C P.Visualization of patent analysis for emerging technology[J].Expert systems with application,2008:34(3):1804-1812.
[18] 吴菲菲,李倩,黄鲁成. 基于专利SAO结构的技术应用领域识别方法研究[J].科研管理,2014,35(6):1-7.[19] BERGMAN K,GRAFF G D. The global stem cell patent landscape:implications for efficient technology transfer and commercial development[J]. Nature biotechnology,2007:25(4):416-424.
[20] PARK Y T, LEE S J, SORA L.Patent analysis for promoting technology transfer in multi-technology industries:the Korean aerospace industry case[J].The journal of technology transfer,2012, 37:355-374.
[21] SOHN S Y, MOON T H. Structural equation model for predicting technology commercialization success index (TCSI)[J]. Technological forecasting and social change,2003, 70(9):885-899.
[22] CHOI J H,JANG D S,JUN S H,et al. A predictive model of technology transfer using patent analysis[J].Sustainability.2015, 7(12):16175-16195.
[23] WANG G F, TIAN X T, GENG J H. Optimal selection method of process patents for technology transfer using fuzzy linguistic computing[J]. Mathematical problems in engineering,2014:1-10.
[24] NEUS P. Sleeping patents:any reason to wake up?[EB/OL].[2015-5-20]. http://www.iese.edu/research/pdfs/DI-0506-E.pdf.
[25] CARPENTER M, NARIN F,WOOLF P. Citation rates to technologically important patents[J]. World patentiInformation,2005,3(4):160-163.
[26] HARHOFF D, NARIN F, SCHERER F, VOPEL K. Citation frequency and the value of patented inventions[J]. Review of economics and statistics, 1999,81(3):511-515.
[27] HARHOFF D, SCHERER F. VOPEL K. Citations, family size,opposition and the value of patent rights[J]. Research policy, 2003,32(8):1343-1363.
[28] GUELLEC D, POTTELSBERGUE B. Applications, grants and the value of patent[J]. Economics letters, 2000,69(1):109-114.
[29] BESSEN J E. The value of U.S. patents by owner and patent characteristics[R].Boston:The Boston University School of Law Working Paper Series No.06-46,2006.
[30] PETRUZZELLI A M, ROTOLO D. Determinants of patent citations in biotechnology:an analysis of patent influence across the industrial and organizational boundaries[EB/OL].[2015-07-20]. http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1403/1403.2096.pdf.
[31] PARK J K, HEO E.Patent quality determinants based on technology life cycle with special reference to solar-cell technology field[J].Maejo international journal of science and technology,2013,7(2):315-328.
[32] 万小丽.专利质量指标研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2009.
[33] TRAJTENBERG M.A penny for your quotes-patent citations and the value of innovations[J]. The rand journal of economics, 1990,21(1):172-187.
[34] REITZIG M.What determines patent value?[J]. Insights from the semiconductor industry,2003,32(1):13-26.
[35] HARHOFF D, REITZIG M. Determinants of opposition against EPO patent grants-the case of biotechnology and pharmaceuticals[R].Munich:Centre for Economic Policy Research,2002.
[36] HALL B,JAFFE A, TRAJTENBERG M. Market value and patent citations[J]. The rand journal of economics, 2005,36(1):16-38.
[37] ALBA M R. Toward the definition of a structural equation model of patent value:pls path modelling with formative constructs[J]. Statistical journal,2009,7(3):265-290.
[38] 郑素丽,宋明顺.专利价值由何决定?基于文献综述的整体性框架[J].科学学研究,2012,30(9):1316-1320.
[39] MORGAN R P,KRUYTBOSCH C,KANNANKUTTY N. Patenting and invention activityof US scientist and engineers in the academic sector:comparisons with industry[J]. The journal of technology transfer,2001, 26(1):173-183.
[40] KUTSOATI E,ZABOJNIK J.Durable goods monopoly,learning-by doing and "sleeping patents"[EB/OL].[2015-06-20].http://ase.tufts.edu/economics/documents/papers/2001/papers05.pdf.
[41] GILBERY R J,NEWBERY D M.Preemptive patenting and the persistence of monopoly[EB/OL].[2015-06-20].http://econoca.unica.it/public/downloaddocenti/Gilbert.pdf.
[42] HALL B H. The patent paradox revisited:determinants of patenting in the US semiconductor industry:1980-1994[EB/OL].[2015-06-22]. http://eml.berkeley.edu//~bhhall/papers/HallZiedonis%20RJE01.pdf.
[43] HOPENHAYN H A, Mitchell M F.Innovation fertility and patent design[EB/OL].[2015-06-20].http://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6646346.pdf.
[44] SHANE S. 2001 technological opportunities and new firm creation[J]. Management science, 2001, 47(2):205-220.
