Library and Information Service >
An Overview of Mental Models Study in Library Field Abroad
Received date: 2016-05-31
Revised date: 2016-07-21
Online published: 2016-08-05
[Purpose/significance] The paper investigated and analyzed foreign literature of mental models in library area abroad as an important reference for domestic related study.[Method/process] The paper summarizes research methods, research contents and mental models measuring methods of mental model study in library and information area, based on literatures of Duxiu knowledge base and SpecialSciDBS.[Result/conclusion] We analyze the main issues of mental models studies from three levels of librarian, user and group, and review the deficiency of mental model measuring methods and study content and the development trend of mental models study in library field. The paper suggests that domestic mental model should be studied from four aspects:broaden the research contents, attention to new issues under the new surroundings; expand research horizons, enhance the study of; explore new methods of measuring mental models, carry out empirical research; and attach importance to a comparative study between librarian level and user level.
Key words： mental models; library; users; measuring methods
Liu Yingmei . An Overview of Mental Models Study in Library Field Abroad[J]. Library and Information Service, 2016 , 60(15) : 116 -125 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2016.15.016
[1] MICHELL G,DEWDNEY P.Mental models theory:applications for library and information science[J].Journal of education for library and information science,1998,39(4):275-281.
[2] JONHNSON-LAIRD P N.Mental models[M]//POSNER M I.Foundations of cognitive science.Cambridge,MA:MIT Press,1989:469-499.
[3] 文献分析法[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=axW5KY3KTPeGXnTeWOIOfLcRmqzIuNXOZXFr DhXDGGx7maV3ZtyYeyDbLBu93HkHwW8IC-u2PjUAle8GongDK.
[4] MARCUM J W.Mental models for sustainability[J].The bottom line:managing library finances,2009,22(2):45-49.
[5] 对比分析法[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://wiki.mbalib.com/wiki/对比分析法.
[6] TALLMAN J I,HENDERSON L.Constructing mental model paradigms for teaching electronic resources[J].School library media research,1999(2):1-10.
[7] VELDOF J,BEAVERS K.Going mental:tackling mental models for the online library tutorial[J].Research strategies,2001,18(1):3-20.
[8] MAKRI S,BLANDFORD A,GOW J.A library or just another information resource? A case study of users'mental models of traditionaland digital libraries[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2007,58(3):433-445.
[9] 实验法的基本步骤[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://wenku.baidu.com/link?url=Mdi-jnGLsenoMmWy4kA78Xu63h6Lo054FEPcZ9i4Z4p5e-A6TOpwJbqurZePOzDGwRch0CGkg7QUbFbB2P4wJwKGesbLqFyVI7PbuBfVO.
[10] LEE M,JOHNSON T,JIN M H.Toward understanding the dynamic relationship between team and task shared mental models as determinants of team and individual performances[J].International journal of information technology and business management,2012,8(1):1-14.
[11] HE W,ERDELEZ S,WANG F K,et al.The effects of conceptual description and search practiceon users'mental models and information seeking in acase-based reasoning retrieval system[J].Information processing and management,2008,44(1):294-309.
[12] 访谈法[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=FXEKvtYszohgoHx-boaf1Mz-FFQryct62U9kC-bNTFRpmM9YVLYTHM1j5YoPqmJQ2S0FlBD5rVFMMXs2VZnaa.
[13] ZHANG Y.The development of users' mental models of MedlinePlus in information searching[J].Library&information science research,2013,35(2):159-170.
[14] TURNER N B.Librarians do it differently:comparative usabilitytesting with students and library staff[J].Journal of Web librarianship,2011,5(4):286-298.
[15] 观察法[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=e3GtMxQValG5vWt6GFxdqmYqH4PG-dxp2UnhXUjWOAx-YBxpftSZ3bE_N5qN5fEKdxxazpitHu438iKrMeiQWq.
[16] HOLMAN L.Millennial students' online search strategies are associated with their mental models of search[J].Journal of academic librarianship,2011,37(1):19-27.
[17] 心智模型综述[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://www.docin.com/p-660380718.html.
[18] SINKINSON C,ALEXANDER S,HICKSA,et al.Guiding design:exposing librarian and student mental models of research guides[J].Libraries and the academy,2012,12(1):63-84.
[19] PISANSKI J,?UMER M.Mental models of the bibliographic universe.Part 1:mental models of descriptions[J].Journal of documentation,2010,66(5):643-667.
[20] 问卷调查法[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=NtylyYwsp0J0t7ingVdLzhXe5FSEYMYYvp5w21kg9UxhPKKFA_uCGOrkbwRLr6nOzprvpOh2e4EQE20MIad-xq.
[21] HUANG M H.A study of decision trees for search terms selections andmental models:acase study in National Taiwan University[J].Journal of libraryand information studies,2002(12):1-33.
[22] NAUGHTON R,AGOSTO D E.Favorite websites:understanding prior knowledge of teens' mental models of public library websites for teens[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2012,49(1):1-11.
[23] 信息检索[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=i-IUlljxrU32NcpbKtZ0cpKb0hapziyEmqYLabPZVCDMwbBGwTT9rcrKVBkQXRZk3zQeCRjS3DCLVz8XqzmDlx6DMsVOdLVDM3E0xKUd-zi.
[24] MCGREGOR J H.Information seeking and use:students thinking and their mental models[J].Journal of youth services in libraries,1994,8(1):69-76.
[25] WESTBROOK L.Mental models:a theoretical overview and preliminary study[J].Journal of information science,2006,32(6):563-579.
[26] MELGUIZO M C P,LEMMERT V R,VAN OOSTENDORP H.Lostness,mental models and performance[DB/OL].[2016-02-10].http://lib.zqu.edu.cn/.
[27] KHOO M,HALL C.What would ‘Google’ do? Usersmental models of a digital library search engine[C]//International conference on theory and practice of digital libraries 2nd:theory and practice of digital libraries.Cyprus:Springer-Verlag,2012:1-12.
[28] CHEN Y N,KE H R.A study on mental models of taggers and experts for article indexing based on analysis of keyword usage[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2014,65(8):1675-1694.
[29] ZUPANI S.Mental models and user training[J].Knji?nica,1997,41(2-3):315-333.
[30] BRANDT D S.Reference,mental modelsand teaching technology[J].The reference librarian,2002,35(74):37-47.
[31] SCHEEPEERS M D,DEBOER A L,BOTHMAT J D,et al.A mental model for successful inter-disciplinary collaboration in curriculum innovation for information literacy[J].South African journal of libraries and information science,2011,77(1):75-84.
[32] 目录[EB/OL].[2016-02-09].http://www.baike.com/wiki/%E7%9B%AE% E5%BD%95.
[33] DIMITROFF A.Mental models theory and search outcome in a bibliographic retrieval-system[J].Library and information science research,1992,14(2):141-156.
[34] KELLY J J.What do they think they're doing? Mental models of online catalog users in an academic library[D].Georgia:University of Georgia,1995:10-14.
[35] DE SILVA S M,ZAINAB A N.An adviser for cataloguingconference proceedings:design and developmentof CoPAS[J].Cataloging and classification quarterly,2000,29(3):63-80.
[36] CONTEH-MORGAN M.Journey with new maps:adjusting mental models and rethinking instruction to language minority students[C]//learning to make a difference:proceedings of the 11th ACRL national conference.Charlotte:Thompson Association of College and Research Libraries,2003.
[37] ZIEFLE M,ARNING K,BAY S.Cross platform consistency and cognitivecompatibility:the importance of users' mental modelfor the interaction with mobile devices[C]//Proceedings of CHI 2006 workshop on the many faces of consistency in cross-platform design.Aachen:RWTH Aachen University,2006:75-81.
[38] MCLAREN T S,VUONG D C H,GRANT K.Do you know what you don't know? Critical reflection and concept mapping in aninformation systems strategy course[J].Communications of the Association for Information Systems,2007,20(12):892-908.
[39] ZHANG Y.The Construction of mental models of information-rich web spaces:the development process and the impact of task complexity[D].Chapel Hill:University of North Carolina,2009:5-15.
[40] TSENG L F,TSENG L T.Using ZMET to construct the consensus map of the users on Yahoo auction platforms[J].Advances in information sciences and service sciences,2012,4(14):334-340.
[41] DEROSA A.Mental model construction in MedlinePlus information searching involves changes and developments in cognition,emotion,and behaviour[J].Evidence based library&information practice,2013,8(4):129-131.
[42] RIGGINS F J,SHAUGHTER K T.The role of collective mental models in IOS adoption:opening the black box of rationality in RFID deployment[C]//The proceedings of the thirty-ninth annual Hawaii international conference on systems sciences.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota,2006:1-22.
[43] SCOZZI B,CROWSTON K,ESERYELU Y,et al.Shared mental models among open source software developers[J].Working papers on information systems,2008,8(10):1-10.
[44] ANDRES H.Testing a second-order factor structure of team cognition in distributed teams[C]//Proceedings of the southern association for information systems conference.Atlanta:North Carolina A&T State University,2010:89-94.
[45] JI X,CAI L,SHEN H.Team communication and team knowledge sharing[J].Advances in information sciences and service sciences,2012,4(18):586-592.
[46] MCNEESE N J,REDDY M.Studying team cognition during collaborative informationseeking:aposition paper[C]//Collaborative information seeking workshop at CSCW 2013,San Antonio:The Pennsylvania State University,2013.
[47] AZGHANDI M,ARASTEH M.The role of organizational psychology in management:through the application of mental models[J].Journal of American science,2014,10(6):29-34.
[48] MATTESON M.Capturing shared mental models:anapproach for bona fide groups[J].Journal of librarianship and information science,2015,47(1):56-70.
[49] SEADLE M.Mental models for personal digital assistants[J].Library Hi Tech,2003,21(4):390-392.
[50] CROASDELL D T,FREEMAN L A,URBACZEWSKI A.Concept maps for teaching and assessment[J].Communications of the association for information systems,2003,12(10):396-405.
[51] RINDERKNECHT C.A survey on teaching and learningrecursive programming[J].Informatics in education,2014,13(1):87-119.
[52] CROWLEY B.Differing mentalmodels andthe futuresof libraries,librarians,andreaders' advisory[J].Reference&user services quarterly,2015,55(2):91-96.
[53] HOAG B.Odd bedfellows or perfect partners:a case study analysis of academic librarians and student affairs professionals mental modelstoward collaboration and student learning[C]//ACRL 2015 Proceedings on Creating Sustainable Community.Portland:Bowling Green State University,2015:585-592.
[54] MURAMATSU J,PRATT W.Transparent queries:investigating users' mental models of search engines[C]//SIGIR 2001,New Orleans:Information&Computer Science University of California,2001:217-224.
[55] 共享心智模型[EB/OL].[2016-03-24].http://wiki.mbalib.com/wiki/%E5%85%B1%E4%BA%AB%E5%BF%83%E6%99%BA%E6%A8%A1%E5%9E%8B.
[56] 张丽军.基于日志挖掘的网站分类目录用户心智模型研究[D].南京:南京理工大学,2014:11-14.
[57] 尤少伟,吴鹏,汤丽娟,等.基于路径搜索法的政府网站分类目录用户心智模型研究[J].图书情报工作,2012,56(9):129-135.
[58] 盛小平,肖碧云.建立21世纪的学习型图书馆[J].图书馆建设,2003(1):8-10.
[59] 刘崇学.学习型组织:图书馆管理创新[J].图书馆理论与实践,2006(1):31-32.
[60] 刘清.学习型组织理论与图书馆的管理[J].图书馆工作与研究,2004(5):18-20.
[61] 钱敏,朱晶晶,张红.大学生用户心智模型测量研究[J].情报科学,2011,29(5):752-762.
[62] 李海涛,宋琳琳.用户使用网站的心智模型测量方法的选择及应用[J].情报理论与实践,2015,38(2):11-16.
[63] 卢小宾,王克平.隐性知识共享的制约因素与实现对策研究[J].情报资料工作,2011(3):6-9.
[64] 韩正彪.综合性文献数据库用户心智模型理论问题初探[J].图书情报工作,2013,57(18):67-72.
[65] 韩正彪.基于访谈法的综合性文献数据库用户心智模型研究[J].图书情报知识,2014(1):90-96.
[66] 韩正彪.综合性文献数据库大学生用户心智模型影响因素及效用分析:以CNKI为例[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(21):81-91.
[67] 李娟.文献数据库用户心智模型演进驱动因素建模分析[J].科技与创新,2015(7):77.
[68] 顾立平.基于共异变数结构方程式的Web 2.0用户心智模型[J].图书情报工作,2009,53(10):45-49.
[69] 史飞.人机交互环境下学术搜索功能学习的心智模型动态改变研究[D].南京:南京理工大学,2012:17-30.
[70] CANNON-BOWERS J A,SALAS E,CONVERSE S A.Cognitive psychology and team training:training shared mental models and complex systems[J].Human factors society bulletin,1990,33(12):1-4.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
