Discussion on the Application of the First Sale Doctrine in the Distribution and Utilization of Digital Works in Libraries in China

  • Qin Ke
Expand
  • Xinxiang University Library, Xinxiang 453003

Received date: 2018-01-06

  Revised date: 2018-04-01

  Online published: 2018-08-20

Abstract

[Purpose/significance] This paper discussed the positive impact of the application of the first sale doctrine on distribution and utilization of digital works, and put forward legislative proposals.[Method/process] It analyzed the legal characteristics of the first sale doctrine and obstacles in the application of such doctrine to digital technology and network context, introduced theoretical study, legislation and judicial practice, and analyzed the application of distribution right to network context on the basis of China's judicial interpretation and library copyright cases.[Result/conclusion] In China's legal context, the behavior of communication through information network includes distribution. And when libraries' operations and services based on communication through information network are constrained by the distribution right, it is proper to legislate for the digital first sale doctrine. We should detail the application requirements in terms of the types of library, library's purpose, nature, object and behavior in spreading and utilizing digital works, and the scope of the works, and give such doctrine the attributes as that of peremptory norm.

Cite this article

Qin Ke . Discussion on the Application of the First Sale Doctrine in the Distribution and Utilization of Digital Works in Libraries in China[J]. Library and Information Service, 2018 , 62(16) : 15 -21 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2018.16.002

References

[1] 美国图书馆研究协会.数字环境下版权的穷竭和首次销售原则——图书馆协会在美国辩论中的立场[J].版权公报,2002(4):14-26.
[2] 王迁.网络环境中的著作权保护研究[M].北京:法律出版社,2011:69.
[3] 马强,王燕.论知识产权穷竭原则的正当性基础[J].知识产权,2011(1):55-57.
[4] 董凡.网络环境下二手数字作品转售行为合法性分析[J].山西省政法管理干部学院学报,2015(3):55-59.
[5] 马晶,张小强.数字作品首次销售原则的适用及版权人利益再平衡[J].科技与出版,2016(7):55-58.
[6] 陶乾.电子书转售的合法性分析[J].法学杂志,2015(7):80-86.
[7] 唐艳.数字化作品与首次销售原则[J].知识产权,2012(1):46-52.
[8] 王骏.版权穷竭原则适用范围探析[J].中国出版,2010(10):72-74.
[9] 李晓秋,李家胜.二手数字音乐作品转卖中的首次销售原则适用例外分析[J].重庆理工大学学报(社会科学),2014(4):72-76,133.
[10] 徐轩,孙益武.论国际图联关于图书馆版权限制与例外的立场及其启示[J].图书馆论坛,2014(12):36-41,57.
[11] 翟建雄,邓茜.电子图书与电子借阅权[J].法律文献与信息研究,2014(74):33-45.
[12] 吴伟光.著作权法研究——国际条约、中国立法与司法实践[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2013:400-401.
[13] 魏玮.论首次销售原则在数字版权作品转售中的适用[J].知识产权,2014(6):21-28.
[14] 华劼.数字网络环境下版权权利穷竭原则延伸性研究[J].江淮学刊,2017(1):209-214.
[15] 王微.著作权与图书馆:当前议题[EB/OL].[2017-12-18].http://Copyright.las.ac.an/.
[16] 黎晨.数字传播时代版权法的首次销售原则[J].法制与社会,2011(11):293-294.
[17] 杨红军.版权许可制度论[M].北京:知识产权出版社,2013:126.
[18] 朱理.著作权的边界[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2012:215-217.
[19] 李德成.网络服务商责任的哲学思考[J].科技与法律,2002(3):60-67.
[20] 诺尔曼,何育红.图书馆:需要特殊对待的角色[J].版权公报,1998(2):29-34.
Outlines

/