SPECIAL TOPIC: Preprint and Preprint Platform Construction

Research Progress and Prospect of Preprints at Home and Abroad

  • Ren Jiaohan ,
  • Wang Jue ,
  • Deng Jun
Expand
  • 1 National Science Library, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190;
    2 Department of Information Resources Management, School of Economics and Management, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190;
    3 School of Business and Management, Jilin University, Changchun 130012

Received date: 2022-11-30

  Revised date: 2022-12-30

  Online published: 2023-04-05

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] To provide a theoretical and practical basis for the development of domestic preprints, and to promote the development of domestic preprint platform construction practices. [Method/Process] Through literature research and network research, the research summarized the basic situation of preprint research and related practices at home and abroad, and reviewed from 6 levels: the characteristics of regularity, cognitive development, relationship with journals, quality control mechanism, influence evaluation, and practical application. [Result/Conclusion] The research on preprints at home and abroad has achieved relatively fruitful results. At present, scholars pay more attention to the relationship between preprints and journal papers, the quality control mechanism of preprints and their influence evaluation, but there are still some shortcomings. Future research can carry out the specification of statement contents of preprints and preprint platforms, the systematic exploration of influence evaluation, and the analysis of the development status of common preprint platforms.

Cite this article

Ren Jiaohan , Wang Jue , Deng Jun . Research Progress and Prospect of Preprints at Home and Abroad[J]. Library and Information Service, 2023 , 67(5) : 4 -14 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2023.05.001

References

[1] 重磅发布|UNESCO开放科学建议书[EB/OL].[2022-07-20]. https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/nIFegVmHlDQKABm2YnQlPQ.
[2] PULVERER B. Preparing for preprints[J]. The EMBO journal, 2016, 35(24):2617-2619.
[3] GINSPARG P. It was twenty years ago today...[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:1108.2700, 2011.
[4] FRY N K, MARSHALL H, MELLINS-COHEN T. In praise of preprints[EB/OL].[2022-07-19]. https://doi.org/10.1099/acmi.0.000013.
[5] 孙异凡, 陈一, 蒋子可, 等. 开放科学视域下预印本认可政策研究[J]. 数字图书馆论坛, 2021(6):2-12.
[6] arxiv[EB/OL].[2022-09-27]. http://arxiv.org/about.
[7] 新华社. 中共中央关于制定国民经济和社会发展第十四个五年规划和二〇三五年远景目标的建议[EB/OL].[2022-07-20]. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2020-11/03/content_5556991.htm.
[8] BLACKWELDER R E. Preprints of Proc. US National Museum, 1890-1897[J]. Systematic zoology, 1952, 1(2):86-89.
[9] Committee on Publication Ethics. COPE discussion documents:Preprints[EB/OL].[2022-07-19]. www.publicationethics.org/files/u7140/COPE_Preprints_Mar18.pdf.
[10] BACHELET V C. What are preprints?[EB/OL].[2022-07- 16]. https://www.medwave.cl/link.cgi/Medwave/Persp Editorial/7091.
[11] RODRÍGUEZ E G. Preprints and preprint servers as academic communication tools[J]. Revista Cubana de Información en Ciencias de la Salud (ACIMED), 2019, 30(1):1-27.
[12] RUTKA J T. Preprint servers and neurosurgical publications[J]. Journal of neurosurgery, 2020, 133(5):1285-1287.
[13] CARÀ P D, CIRIMINNA R, PAGLIARO M. Has the time come for preprints in chemistry?[J]. ACS Omega, 2017, 2(11):7923- 7928.
[14] ETTINGER C L, SADANANDAPPA M K, GORGULU K. A guide to preprinting for early-career researchers[J]. Biology open, 2022, 11(7):1-8.
[15] KIRKHAM J J, PENFOLD N C, MURPHY F. Systematic examination of preprint platforms for use in the medical and biomedical sciences setting[J]. BMJ open, 2020, 10(12):1-12.
[16] 吴光伟. 预印本——一条重要的情报渠道[J]. 情报学刊, 1985(1):44-46, 55.
[17] WOLF J F, MACKAY L, HAWORTH S E, et al. Preprinting is positively associated with early career researcher status in ecology and evolution[J]. Ecology and evolution, 2021, 11(20):13624-13632.
[18] ABDILL R J, ADAMOWICZ E M, BLEKHMAN R. MetaResearch:international authorship and collaboration across bioRxiv preprints[J]. Elife, 2020, 9:e58496.
[19] 谢维熙, 张光耀, 郑轩, 等. 开放获取背景和疫情形势下预印本发表模式的扩散研究——以bioRxiv为例[J]. 图书情报知识, 2022, 39(3):50-59.
[20] 宗倩倩. 预印本大繁荣对科学发现优先权确认机制的挑战及其应对[J]. 编辑学报, 2021, 33(3):253-258.
[21] HIGGINS J, STEINER R D. Author preprint behaviour and noncompliance with journal preprint policies:one biomedical journal's experience[J]. Learned publishing, 2021, 34(3):389-395.
[22] VUONG Q H. The rise of preprints and their value in social sciences and humanities[J]. Science editing, 2020, 7(1):70-72.
[23] 吴健雄. 基于预印本的多类用户行为模式研究[D]. 大连:大连外国语大学, 2022.
[24] BERTIN M, ATANASSOVA I. Preprint citation practice in PLOS[J]. Scientometrics, 2022, 127:6895-6912.
[25] NISHIOKA C, FÄRBER M, SAIER T. How does author affiliation affect preprint citation count? analyzing citation bias at the institution and country level[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.02033, 2022.
[26] BORDIGNON F, ERMAKOVA L, NOEL M. Over-promotion and caution in abstracts of preprints during the COVID-19 crisis[J]. Learned publishing, 2021, 34(4):622-636.
[27] CARLSON J, HARRIS K. Quantifying and contextualizing the impact of bioRxiv preprints through automated social media audience segmentation[J]. PLoS biology, 2020, 18(9):e3000860.
[28] YI H J, HUH S. Korean editors' and researchers' experiences with preprints and attitudes towards preprint policies[J]. Science editing, 2021, 8(1):4-9.
[29] 徐锐. 日本首个预印本平台" 遇冷"[N]. 中国科学报, 2022- 06-08(1).
[30] BAŽDARIĆ K, VRKIĆ I, ARH E, et al. Attitudes and practices of open data, preprinting, and peer-review-a cross sectional study on Croatian scientists[J]. PLoS one, 2021, 16(6):e0244529.
[31] 唐耕砚. 国外预印本平台建设的历程、特点及启示[J]. 中国出版史研究, 2021(3):144-155.
[32] 唐桂芬. 预印本发展和研究探析[J]. 出版与印刷, 2020(2):61-69.
[33] 解贺嘉, 刘筱敏. 国外预印本平台研究述评[J]. 科技与出版, 2020(6):21-27.
[34] KIM L, PORTENOY J H, WEST J D, et al. Scientific journals still matter in the era of academic search engines and preprint archives[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2020, 71(10):1218-1226.
[35] KLEBEL T, REICHMANN S, POLKA J, et al. Peer review and preprint policies are unclear at most major journals[J]. PLoS one, 2020, 15(10):e0239518.
[36] MASSEY D S, OPARE M A, WALLACH J D, et al. Assessment of preprint policies of top-ranked clinical journals[J]. Jama network open, 2020, 3(7):e2011127.
[37] 唐桂芬. 预印本发展和研究探析[J]. 出版与印刷, 2020(2):61-69.
[38] 汪庆, 任慧玲. 开放融合环境下预印本发展态势分析[J]. 数字图书馆论坛, 2021(8):59-64.
[39] LIN J, YU Y, ZHOU Y, et al. How many preprints have actually been printed and why:a case study of computer science preprints on arXiv[J]. Scientometrics, 2020, 124:555-574.
[40] KRAMER B. Links from preprints to published papers in preprint metadata[C]//18th international conference on scientometrics and informetrics conference. Leuven:ISSI, 2021:609-614.
[41] CABANAC G, OIKONOMIDI T, BOUTRON I. Day-to-day discovery of preprint-publication links[J]. Scientometrics, 2021, 126:5285-5304.
[42] 杨硕. 预印本库与传统期刊合作的典型模式研究[J]. 科技与出版, 2020(7):130-136.
[43] MOUSTAFA K. Postprints-to-preprints linkage to enhance access to scientific literature[J]. Accountability in research, 2021:1-5.
[44] CLYNE B, WALSH K A, O'MURCHU E, et al. Using preprints in evidence synthesis:commentary on experience during the COVID-19 pandemic[J]. Journal of clinical epidemiology, 2021, 138:203-210.
[45] SHI X, ROSS J S, AMANCHARLA N, et al. Assessment of concordance and discordance among clinical studies posted as preprints and subsequently published in high-impact journals[J]. JAMA network open, 2021, 4(3):e212110.
[46] AKBARITABAR A, STEPHEN D, SQUAZZONI F. A study of referencing changes in preprint-publication pairs across multiple fields[J]. Journal of informetrics, 2022, 16(2):101258.
[47] BRIERLEY L, NANNI F, POLKA J K, et al. Tracking changes between preprint posting and journal publication during a pandemic[J]. PLoS biology, 2022, 20(2):e3001285.
[48] ITANI D, LABABIDI G, ITANI R, et al. Reporting of funding and conflicts of interest improved from preprints to peerreviewed publications of biomedical research[J]. Journal of clinical epidemiology, 2022, 149:146-153.
[49] HAMADE L, ALI A, HIJAZI A R A, et al. Policies of biomedical preprint servers on conflicts of interest, authorship, and research integrity lacked important details[J]. Journal of clinical epidemiology, 2022, 146:47-59.
[50] CARNEIRO C F D, QUEIROZ V G S, MOULIN T C, et al. Comparing quality of reporting between preprints and peerreviewed articles in the biomedical literature[J]. Research integrity and peer review, 2020, 5(1):1-19.
[51] PENFOLD N C, POLKA J K. Technical and social issues influencing the adoption of preprints in the life sciences[J]. PLoS genetics, 2020, 16(4):e1008565.
[52] NICHOLSON D N, RUBINETTI V, HU D, et al. Examining linguistic shifts between preprints and publications[J]. PLoS biology, 2022, 20(2):e3001470.
[53] TILL J E. Predecessors of preprint servers[J]. Learned publishing, 2001, 14(1):7-13.
[54] SMART P. The evolution, benefits, and challenges of preprints and their interaction with journals[J]. Science, 2022(1):79-84.
[55] 都平平, 彭琳. 利用平台创新期刊出版服务——预印本平台出版的启示[J]. 科技与出版, 2021(4):11-16.
[56] 和鸿鹏. 预印本可否替代学术期刊?——基于科学社会学的视角[J]. 自然辩证法研究, 2021, 37(7):72-77.
[57] 曾建勋. 重视预印本及其系统生态建设[J]. 数字图书馆论坛, 2020(10):1-2.
[58] 许玉俊. 基于预印本的科学交流机制探析[J]. 科学技术哲学研究, 2022, 39(4):111-116.
[59] 王凌峰, 韩子晴. 知识创新加速器" 预印本2.0":概念、设计与实现路径[J]. 情报杂志, 2021, 40(6):171-177.
[60] 解贺嘉, 刘筱敏. 预印本平台开放评议运行模式实证研究[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2021, 32(10):1227-1233.
[61] 付江阳, 贺颖. 预印本自组织同行评议的通证激励机制研究[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2021, 32(1):23-27.
[62] HE Y, TIAN K, FU J. An incentive mechanism-based framework to assure the quality of self-organizing peer review in preprint[J]. Data technologies and applications, 2021, 55(5):609-621.
[63] MALIČKI M, JERONČIĆ A, TER RIET G, et al. Preprint servers' policies, submission requirements, and transparency in reporting and research integrity recommendations[J]. JAMA, 2020, 324(18):1901-1903.
[64] DA SILVA J A T. Adjusting the use of preprints to accommodate the 'quality' factor in response to COVID-19[J]. Journal of Taibah University Medical Sciences, 2021, 16(4):477-481.
[65] 宋现山. 预印本服务的发展态势、困境与变革思路[J]. 哈尔滨师范大学社会科学学报, 2022, 12(1):156-162.
[66] ROY S, EDWARDS M A. Addressing the preprint dilemma[J]. International Journal of hygiene and environmental health, 2022, 240:113896.
[67] IBORRA S F, POLKA J, PUEBLA I. Point of view:promoting constructive feedback on preprints with the FAST principles[J]. Elife, 2022, 11:e78424.
[68] MOSHONTZ H, BINION G, WALTON H, et al. A guide to posting and managing preprints[J]. Advances in methods and practices in psychological science, 2021, 4(2):1-11.
[69] RAVINETTO R, CAILLET C, ZAMAN M H, et al. Preprints in times of COVID19:the time is ripe for agreeing on terminology and good practices[J]. BMC medical ethics, 2021, 22(1):1-5.
[70] SUBRAMANIAN K, NALLI A, SENTHIL V, et al. Pharmaceutical industry-authored preprints:scientific and social media impact[J]. Current medical research and opinion, 2021, 37(2):269-273.
[71] 王智琦. 预印本的科学交流功能及其多维测评[D]. 大连:大连理工大学, 2020.
[72] WANG Z, GLÄNZEL W, CHEN Y. The impact of preprints in library and information science:an analysis of citations, usage and social attention indicators[J]. Scientometrics, 2020, 125(2):1403-1423.
[73] WANG Z, CHEN Y, GLÄNZEL W. Preprints as accelerator of scholarly communication:an empirical analysis in Mathematics[J]. Journal of informetrics, 2020, 14(4):101097.
[74] FRASER N, MOMENI F, MAYR P, et al. The relationship between bioRxiv preprints, citations and altmetrics[J]. Quantitative science studies 2020, 1(2):618-638.
[75] XU F, OU G, MA T, et al. The consistency of impact of preprints and their journal publications[J]. Journal of informetrics, 2021, 15(2):101153.
[76] 刘春丽, 盛南洪. bioRxiv自存档的期刊论文多维度影响力优势实证研究[J]. 信息资源管理学报, 2022, 12(4):33-45.
[77] 杨蕙鸣. 预印本文献影响力评估系统的设计与实现[D]. 大连:大连理工大学, 2021.
[78] VASCONCELOS G L, CORDEIRO L P, DUARTE-FILHO G C, et al. Modeling the epidemic growth of preprints on COVID-19 and SARS-CoV-2[J]. Frontiers in physics, 2021, 9:603502.
[79] GINSPARG P. Lessons from arXiv's 30 years of information sharing[J]. Nature reviews physics, 2021, 3(9):602-603.
[80] MATTHEW B. Hoy, rise of the Rxivs:how preprint servers are changing the publishing process, medical reference services quarterly, 2020, 39(1):84-89.
[81] SINGH V K, SRICHANDAN S S, PIRYANI R. Preprint submissions by Indian scientists in arXiv[J]. Current science, 2020, 119(6):904.
[82] 高永. arXiv电子印本与期刊发表文章的引用合并方案设计及其在科研评价中的应用研究[D]. 合肥:中国科学技术大学, 2020.
[83] HE J, YAN E, NI C. Examining international research collaboration during the COVID-19 pandemic using arXiv preprints[C]//18th international conference on scientometrics and informetrics conference. Leuven:ISSI. 2021:511-516.
[84] MAJUMDER M S, MANDL K D. Early in the epidemic:impact of preprints on global discourse about COVID-19 transmissibility[J]. The lancet global health, 2020, 8(5):e627-e630.
[85] 蔡妙芝, 郭进京, 赵嘉玮, 等. 突发公共卫生事件下生物医学电子预印本资源的作用及其启示[J]. 中华医学图书情报杂志, 2020, 29(5):30-36.
[86] ABRAMO G, D'ANGELO C A, MELE I. Gendered impact of COVID-19 pandemic on research production:a cross-country analysis based on bioRxiv[C]//18th international conference on scientometrics and informetrics. Leuven:ISSI. 2021:19-30.
[87] UCAR I, TORRE M, ELÍAS A. Mind the gender gap:COVID-19 lockdown effects on gender differences in preprint submissions[J]. PloS one, 2022, 17(3):e0264265.
[88] STRCIC J, CIVLJAK A, GLOZINIC T, et al. Open data and data sharing in articles about COVID-19 published in preprint servers medRxiv and bioRxiv[J]. Scientometrics, 2022, 127(5):2791-2802.
[89] 曹仁猛, 谢维熙, 耿屿, 等. 新冠疫情爆发前后我国国际科研合作模式的变化——基于bioRxiv的分析[J]. 图书情报知识, 2022, 39(3):41-49.
[90] 唐耕砚, 蔡豪. 预印本平台的舆论治理困境与应对策略——基于" 新型冠状病毒肺炎" 事件的反思[J]. 科学学研究, 2021, 39(4):587-593.
[91] FEITLER B. A caminho de uma "cultura de preprints"?[J]. Revista Brasileira de história, 2019, 39:7-11.
[92] Nature. Springer Nature journals unify their policy to encourage preprint sharing[J]. Nature, 2019, 569:307.
[93] BRISCOE J, GREWAL S. Preprints in development[J]. Development, 2022, 149(7):dev200711.
[94] CORROSION. Online early preprints[J]. Corrosion, 2012, 68(8):675.
[95] CHEN C. Preprint publication option[J]. International surgery, 2015, 100(3):387.
[96] 《图书情报工作》杂志社预印本政策声明[EB/OL].[2022- 10-10]. http://www.lis.ac.cn/CN/column/column37.shtml.
[97] 《智库理论与实践》预印本政策声明[EB/OL].[2022-10-10]. https://zksl.cbpt.cnki.net/WKG/WebPublication/wkTextContent.aspx?navigationContentID=146399f6-c7a9-4fa8-b670- b44f8f020c3c.
Outlines

/