SERVICE RESEARCH

A Study on the Differences in Mobile Reading Effects Among College Students:Taking the Contexts of Reading and Listening to Books on Mobile Phones as an Example

  • Ye Shasha ,
  • Yang Qin ,
  • Ma Xiaoxuan
Expand
  • College of Applied Arts and Science, Beijing Union University, Beijing 100191

Received date: 2023-08-14

  Revised date: 2023-11-12

  Online published: 2024-04-24

Supported by

mobile reading reading on mobile phone listening to books on mobile phone college student reading effect

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] Taking college students as the research object, this study explores the difference in their reading performance between reading and listening on mobile phone, and proposes relevant suggestions to improve the mobile phone reading effect.[Method/Process] Through the experimental method, college students in different regions were selected for group experiments. They were allowed to read books and listen to books on mobile phone at the same time, and the reading effect was evaluated, and finally the evaluation data was analyzed and statistically tested.[Result/Conclusion] The results show that there is a significant difference in the reading effect between reading and listening to books on mobile phone among college students. The effect of reading books on mobile phone is better than that of listening. Gender has no significant influence on it, and suitable mobile reading methods can be selected according to individual differences.

Cite this article

Ye Shasha , Yang Qin , Ma Xiaoxuan . A Study on the Differences in Mobile Reading Effects Among College Students:Taking the Contexts of Reading and Listening to Books on Mobile Phones as an Example[J]. Library and Information Service, 2024 , 68(7) : 36 -45 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2024.07.004

References

[1] 第十九次全国国民阅读调查结果发布[J].国家图书馆学刊, 2022, 31(3):38.(The 19th national reading survey results released[J]. Journal of the national library of China, 2022, 31(3):38.)
[2] 吴钊.中国式"听书"发展四阶段论[J].杭州师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2018, 40(1):116-122.(WU Z. The evolvement of "listening to the story-telling" in China[J]. Journal of Hangzhou Normal University (humanities and social sciences), 2018, 40(1):116-122.)
[3] 段朝辉,洪建中,王福兴.不同媒介阅读效果差异的作用机制探究[J].图书情报工作, 2018, 62(12):65-71.(DUAN C H, HONG J Z, WANG F X. Exploring the effect mechanism of different reading media on reading performance[J]. Library and information service, 2018, 62(12):65-71.)
[4] 袁征,白雪松.看屏幕不等于读书——文本呈现方式对学生阅读效果的影响[J].教育发展研究, 2016, 36(20):15-20.(YUAN Z, BAI X S. Watching computer screens is different from reading books[J]. Research in education development, 2016, 36(20):15-20.)
[5] 李洪晨,马捷,高鹤萌,等.面向发展性阅读障碍的数字阅读与纸质阅读比较研究[J].图书情报工作, 2022, 66(11):66-75.(LI H C, MA J, GAO H M, et al. A comparative study of digital reading and paper reading facing developmental dyslexia[J]. Library and information service, 2022, 66(11):66-75.)
[6] DELGADO P, VARGAS C, ACKERMAN R, et al. Don't throw away your printed books:a meta-analysis on the effects of reading media on reading comprehension[J]. Educational research review, 2018(25):23-38.
[7] 安伟.文本类型、呈现媒介与阅读方式对阅读效果的影响[D].南京:南京师范大学, 2020.(AN W. The influence of text type, presentation medium and reading mode on reading effect[D].Nanjing:Nanjing Normal University, 2020.)
[8] 徐军英,张康华,张怿.手机阅读与纸质阅读实验效果的对比分析[J].情报资料工作, 2015(6):92-96.(XU J Y, ZHANG K H, ZHANG Y. Comparative analysis of mobile reading and paper reading experimental effect[J]. Information and documentation services, 2015(6):92-96.)
[9] 马捷,张光媛,蒲泓宇.手机与纸媒条件下的数字原住民阅读效果实验——以新闻和小说为例[J].图书馆论坛, 2019, 39(9):108-117.(MA J, ZHANG G Y, PU H Y. An experimental study on digital aboriginals'reading effect under the conditions of mobile phone and paper media:——taking news and novels for example[J]. Library tribune, 2019, 39(9):108-117.)
[10] ROGOWSKY B A, CALHOUN B M, TALLAL P. Does modality matter?The effects of reading, listening, and dual modality on comprehension[J]. Sage open, 2016, 6(3):1-9
[11] VIRGINIA L C. Listening ears or reading eyes:a meta-analysis of reading and listening comprehension comparisons[J]. Review of educational research, 2022, 92(4):543-582.
[12] DENNING A, PEWONKA B, GRUNSPAN D, et al. Digital textbooks:the effects of input modality and distraction on student learning at a Hispanic-serving institution[J]. Scholarship of teaching and learning in psychology, 2018, 4(3):127-139.
[13] GANSCHOW L, WEBER D B. Effects of mode of presentation on comprehension of below average, average, and above average readers[J]. Perceptual and motor skills, 1987, 64(3):899-905.
[14] KINTSCH W, KOZMINSKY E. Summarizing stories after reading and listening[J]. Journal of educational psychology, 1977, 69(5):491-499.
[15] WOLFSON G. Using audiobooks to meet the needs of adolescent readers[J]. American secondary education, 2008, 2(36):105-114.
[16] 王笑语,华薇娜,柯青.听书还是看书?——信息媒体对低年级儿童阅读效果影响研究[J].图书馆建设, 2019(6):117-127.(WANG X Y, HUA W N, KE Q. Audiobooks or reading?——Study on the influence of information media on schoolchildren's reading effect[J]. Library development, 2019(6):117-127.)
[17] 王长潇,卢秋竹.听书抑或看书?——具身认知理论视角下媒介对阅读效果的影响[J].编辑之友, 2021(4):61-66.(WANG C X, LU Q Z. Listening or reading?The influence of media on reading effect from the perspective of embodied cognitive theory[J]. Editorial friend, 2021(4):61-66.)
[18] 王嵩,孙兮文.视觉和听觉记忆功能的MRI研究[J].医学影像学杂志, 2004(5):341-343.(WANG S, SUN X W. MRI study of visual and auditory memory[J]. Journal of medical imaging, 2004(5):341-343.)
[19] 张司邈.视觉记忆与听觉记忆的比较探究[J].考试周刊, 2015(4):83-84.(ZHANG S M. Comparative exploration of visual memory and auditory memory[J]. Examination weekly, 2015(4):83-84.)
[20] SANNOMIYA M. The effect of presentation modality on text memory as a function of difficulty level[J]. The Japanese journal of psychonomic science, 1982, 1(2):85-90.
[21] 关忠文.青年心理学[M].王永丽,周浙平,译.哈尔滨:黑龙江人民出版社, 1982.(GUAN Z W. Youth psychology[M]. WANG Y P, ZHOU Z P, trans. Harbin:Heilongjiang People's Publishing House, 1982.)
[22] 张必隐.阅读心理学[M].北京:北京师范大学出版社, 1992.(ZHANG B Y, Reading psychology[M]. Beijing:Beijing Normal University Press, 1992.)
[23] 梁昌豪,张鹏翼.学习材料知识表示形式对数字阅读效果的影响研究[J].图书情报工作, 2022, 66(8):13-20.(LIANG C H, ZHANG P Y. Research on the effect of knowledge representation forms of learning materials on digital reading[J]. Library and information service, 2022, 66(8):13-20.)
[24] 高子惠,焦雨,王曦,等.电子绘本文字的动静态呈现方式对幼儿阅读体验和学习效果的影响[J].心理发展与教育, 2023(6):817-824.(GAO Z H, JIAO Y, WANG X, et al. The influence of dynamic and static text presentation mode of electronic picture books on children's reading experience and learning effect[J]. Psychological development and education, 2023(6):817-824.)
[25] 郭恋.手机移动阅读效果影响因素的实验研究[D].金华:浙江师范大学, 2012.(GUO L. Experimental study on the influence factors of mobile phone reading[D]. Jinhua:Zhejiang Normal University, 2012.)
[26] 姜丽红.电脑屏幕与纸面呈现载体对大学生阅读效果的影响研究[D].苏州:苏州大学, 2008.(JIANG L H. Research on the effect between computer screen and paper surface among university students[D]. Suzhou:Soochow University, 2008.)
[27] 祁卓麟,白君礼,杜香莉.当代大学生阅读效果及其影响因素研究[J].知识管理论坛, 2015(3):7-13.(QI Z L, BAI J L, DU X L. Research on the reading effect and its influencing factors of contemporary college students[J]. Knowledge management forum, 2015(3):7-13.)
[28] 柴阳丽.高校学生新媒体阅读现状、影响因素及改善途径——基于五所高校学生数字化阅读调查[J].开放教育研究, 2016, 22(2):59-66.(CHAI Y L. Research on college students'new media reading status, influencing factors, and methods for improvement:survey of 5 universities on current situation and demand of university students'digital reading[J]. Open education research, 2016, 22(2):59-66.)
[29] 于鸣镝.阅读效果研究[J].图书与情报, 2005(4):17-20.(YU M D. Research on reading effect[J]. Library and information, 2005(4):17-20.)
[30] HUANG Y M, LIANG T H, CHIU C H. Gender differences in the reading of e-books:investigating children's attitudes, reading behaviors and outcomes[J]. Educational technology & society, 2013, 16(4):97-110.
[31] 王红娟,卜娟娟.信息化学习环境下电子书阅读的性别差异探究[J].软件导刊(教育技术), 2013, 12(12):78-80.(WANG H J, BU J J. Gender differences in e-book reading in information learning environment[J]. Software guide (educational technology), 2013, 12(12):78-80.)
[32] 张喜艳,程康明,郭晓桃,等.纸质阅读效果优于数字阅读吗?——基于48项国内外研究的元分析[J].情报科学, 2021, 39(6):55-61, 91.(ZHANG X Y, CHENG K M, GUO X T, et al. Is paper reading better than digital reading?——a metaanalysis based on 48 domestic and foreign studies[J]. Information science, 2021, 39(6):55-61, 91.)
[33] 姜泽玮.内容、形态、场景与满足:移动新媒体有声书的用户使用研究——以移动应用"微信读书"与"微信听书"为中心[J].出版科学, 2021, 29(5):31-40.(JIANG Z W. Content, form, scene and satisfaction:a user use study of mobile new media audio books:taking "WeChat reading" and "WeChat listening" as the center[J]. Publishing journal, 2021, 29(5):31-40.)
[34] 方瑜雯,沈宇娟,刘少英.微信阅读与纸质阅读的阅读效果比较——客观指标与主观感受的证据[J].图书馆杂志, 2021, 40(5):36-43(FANG Y W, SHEN Y J, LIU S Y. Comparison of reading experience on WeChat and printed books:evidence from subjective evaluations and objective indicators[J]. Library journal, 2021, 40(5):36-43)
[35] 朱滢,周爱宝.字词视觉频率与听觉频率的差异和记忆的视优效应[J].应用心理学, 1992(3):38-41.(ZHU Y, ZHOU A B. The difference between visual frequency and auditory frequency of words and the visual superiority effect of memory[J]. Chinese journal of applied psychology, 1992(3):38-41.)
[36] 劳动观察."听书"和"看书"相比,哪个更深刻,能相互替代吗[EB/OL].[2023-10-23]. https://www.51ldb.com/shsldb/jiaoy/content/018367d63ccfc0010000df844d7e124a.htm.(Labor observation. Compared with "listening to books" and "reading books", which is more profound and can they replace each other[EB/OL].[2023-10-23]. https://www.51ldb.com/shsldb/jiaoy/content/018367d63ccfc0010000df844d7e124a.htm.)
[37] 白雪,曾元祥.电子书用户阅读体验偏好实证研究[J].数字图书馆论坛, 2016(3):54-59.(BAI X, ZENG Y X. Empirical research on e-books users'preference of reading experience[J]. Digital library forum, 2016(3):54-59.)
[38] 尹章池,徐景熙.高校学生有声阅读行为特征及其有声阅读推广策略研究——基于SPSS统计数据分析[J].传播与版权, 2023(3):43-46.(YIN Z C, XU J X. Research on the behavioral characteristics of audio reading of college students and its promotion strategy of audio reading——based on SPSS statistical data analysis[J]. Communication and copyright, 2023(3):43-46.)
[39] LEHMANN J, SEUFERT T. The interaction between text modality and the learner's modality preference influences comprehension and cognitive load[J]. Frontiers in psychology, 2020, 10:1-11.
[40] 孙易新.思维导图法应用宝典[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社, 2020.(SUN Y X. Mind mapping application manual[M]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang People's Publishing House, 2020.)
[41] JESTER R E, TRAVERS R M W. Comprehension of connected meaningful discourse as a function of rate and mode of presentation[J]. The journal of educational research, 1966, 59(7):297-302.
[42] 谈苹.浅谈阅读跨越——"听书":读者阅读的新选择[J].图书馆界, 2011(2):55-56, 71.(TAN P. Reading leapfrogging——"listening to books":a new choice for readers[J]. Library world, 2011(2):55-56, 71.)
[43] 王琦,陈文勇.高校图书馆移动阅读服务利用率的影响因素与应对策略[J].图书馆学研究, 2014(18):59-63, 43.(WANG Q, CHEN W Y. Impact factors and promotion strategies of university library mobile reading service utilization rate[J]. Research on library science, 2014(18):59-63, 43.)
Outlines

/