INFORMATION RESEARCH

Analysis of the Factors Influencing Users’ Utilization Ability of Open Government Data: Based on DEMATEL-ISM

  • Chen Mei ,
  • Wang Cuicui
Expand
  • School of Public Administration, Zhongnan University of Economics and Law, Wuhan 430073

Received date: 2023-10-13

  Revised date: 2024-01-19

  Online published: 2024-07-30

Supported by

This work is supported by Zhongnan University of Economics and Law Central University Fundamental Research Funds Special Fund Funded Project “Research on Open Government Data Utilization and Protection” and Zhongnan University of Economics and Law Central University Basic Research Expenses (graduate research innovation platform) project “How local government performance feedback contributes to performance improvement:Evidence from the Open Forest Index”(Grant No.202351206).

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] To explore the factors influencing the users’ utilization ability of open government data, it can maximize the utilization effect of open government data from the perspective of users, and help fully release its value. [Method/Process] Firstly, based on the human-data interaction theory and related literature, it constructed an index system of influencing factors. On this basis, it identified the key influencing factors using DEMATEL method, and then analyzed the internal logical relationship and action path between the factors using ISM method. [Result/Conclusion] The analysis shows that data awareness and data knowledge are the most influential factors to users’ utilization ability of open government data. Data discovery, data download, data preservation and data application are the four surface factors that directly impact on users’ utilization ability. The five factors, such as data quantity, data knowledge, and data collection, are middle-level transition factors. The seven factors, such as data quality, data awareness, and social role, are the deep driving factors. It proposes countermeasures and suggestions related to platform data quality, environmental and social atmosphere, and users’ data literacy, aiming to provide a certain reference for improving users’ utilization ability to open government data.

Cite this article

Chen Mei , Wang Cuicui . Analysis of the Factors Influencing Users’ Utilization Ability of Open Government Data: Based on DEMATEL-ISM[J]. Library and Information Service, 2024 , 68(14) : 128 -141 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2024.14.011

References

[1] 袁红,王焘.政府数据开放可持续发展关键影响因素识别与作用机理分析[J].图书情报工作, 2022, 66(9):53-65.(YUAN H, WANG T. Identification and analysis of key influencing factors of sustainable development of government data openness[J]. Library and information service, 2022, 66(9):53-65.)
[2] 袁莉,赵婧.破译能力黑箱:公共数据开放之用户能力新探[J].中国图书馆学报, 2023, 49(4):88-102.(YUAN L, ZHAO J. Decoding ability black box:a new exploration of user ability in public data opening[J]. Journal of library science in China, 2023, 49(4):88-102.)
[3] 袁莉,李霞.开放政府数据用户参与过程重构--情境、鸿沟与使用[J].现代情报, 2023, 43(6):121-129, 138.(YUAN L, LI X. Open government data user participation process reconstruction:context, divide and use[J]. Journal of modern information, 2023, 43(6):121-129, 138.)
[4] 雷鸿竹,王谦. WSR视角下政府数据开放价值实现路径研究[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2023, 44(1):233-240.(LEI H Z, WANG Q. Research on the path of realizing the value of government data openness from the perspective[J]. Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and social sciences edition), 2023, 44(1):233-240.)
[5] 袁静,李森涛.用户参与政府开放数据价值共创动因研究[J].数字图书馆论坛, 2023, 19(2):1-9.(YUAN J, LI S T. Users participate in the research on the co-creation drivers of the value of government open data[J]. Digital library forum, 2023, 19(2):1-9.)
[6] ZUIDERWIJK A, JANSSEN M, DWIVEDI Y K. Acceptance and use predictors of open data technologies:drawing upon the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology[J]. Government information quarterly, 2015, 32(4):429-440.
[7] BENITEZ-PAEZ F, DEGBELO A, TRILLES S et al. Roadblocks hindering the reuse of open geodata in Colombia and Spain:a data user's perspective[J]. ISPRS international journal of geoinformation, 2018, 7(1):6.
[8] GONZALE-ZAPATA F, HEEKS R. The multiple meanings of open government data:understanding different stakeholders and their perspective[J]. Government information quarterly, 2015, 32(4):441-452.
[9] 赵龙文,洪逸飞,赵雪琦.政府开放数据资源利用与创新应用效能评价研究[J].现代情报, 2023, 43(7):133-144.(ZHAO W L, HONG Y F, ZHAO X Q. Research on efficiency evaluation of open government data resource utilization and innovative application[J]. Journal of modern information, 2023, 43(7):133-144.)
[10] 袁莉,姚乐野.政府数据开放的整体能力:概念、框架及演化机制[J].图书情报工作, 2021, 65(19):53-60.(YUAN L, YAO L Y. Overall capabilities of government data openness:concept, framework and evolutionary mechanism[J]. Library and information service, 2021, 65(19):53-60.)
[11] 门理想,杜亚斌,王芮,等.政府数据开放的利用行为与持续利用意愿研究[J].数字图书馆论坛, 2023, 19(7):73-81.(MEN L X, DU Y B, WANG R, et al. Utilization behavior and sustained utilization willingness of open government data[J]. Digital library forum, 2023, 19(7):73-81.)
[12] SMITH G, SANDBERG J. Barriers to innovating with open government data:exploring experiences across service phases and user types[J]. Information polity, 2018, 23(3):249-265.
[13] 胡水星,荆洲,王会军.我国高校大数据治理体系的关键要素与优化路径研究--基于DEMATEL-ISM的视角[J].电化教育研究, 2022, 43(11):38-44, 52.(HU S X, JIN Z, WANG H J. Research on the key elements and optimization path of big data governance system in Chinese universities--based on the perspective of DEMATEL-ISM[J]. E-education research, 2022, 43(11):38-44, 52.)
[14] 赵霞霞,母睿.公共数据开放对学术创新的作用机制--基于人-数交互理论[J].科技管理研究, 2023, 43(9):1-10.(ZHAO X X, MU R. The mechanism of public data opening on academic innovation:based on human-number interaction theory[J]. Science and technology management research, 2023, 43(9):1-10.)
[15] XIAO F H, CHI Y, HE D Q. Promoting data use through understanding user behaviors:a model for human open government data interaction[J]. Journal of the association for information science and technology, 2023, 74(13):1498-1514.
[16] VICTORELLI E Z, DOSREIS J C, HORNUNG H, et al. Understanding human-data interaction:literature review and recommendations for design[J]. International journal of humancomputer studies, 2020, 134:13-32.
[17] 徐慧娜,郑磊.面向用户利用的开放政府数据平台:纽约与上海比较研究[J].电子政务, 2015(7):37-45.(XU H N, ZHEN L. Open government data platform for user utilization:a comparative study between New York and Shanghai[J]. E-government, 2015(7):37-45.)
[18] PURWANTO A, ZUIDERWIJK A. Citizen engagement with open government data:a systematic literature review of drivers and inhibitors[J]. International journal of electronic government research, 2020, 16(3):1-25.
[19] 郑磊,韩笑,朱晓婷.地方政府数据开放平台研究:功能与体验[J].电子政务, 2019(9):12-22.(ZHEN L, HAN X, ZHU X T. Research on local government data open platform:function and experience[J]. E-government, 2019(9):12-22.)
[20] PARASUREMAN A, ZEITHAML V, MALHOTRA A. E-SQUAL:a multiple-item scale for assessing electronic service quality[J]. Journal of service research, 2005, 7(3):213-233.
[21] 钱明辉,徐志轩,王珊.基于用户参与的在线健康平台信息服务质量研究[J].情报学报, 2019, 38(2):132-142.(QIAN M H, XU Z X, WANG S. Research on information service quality of online health platform based on user participation[J]. Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information, 2019, 38(2):132-142.)
[22] 白献阳,孙梦皎,安小米.大数据环境下我国政府数据开放政策体系研究[J].图书馆学研究, 2018(24):48-56.(BAI X Y, SUN M J, AN X M. Research on Chinese government data open policy system under big data environment[J]. Research on library science, 2018(24):48-56.)
[23] SIMONOFSKI A, ZUIDERWOJL A, CLARINVAL A. Tailoring open government data portals for lay citizens:a gamification theory approach[J]. International journal of information management, 2022, 65:102511.
[24] 郑磊,关文雯.开放政府数据评估框架、指标与方法研究[J].图书情报工作, 2016, 60(18):43-55.(ZHEN L, GUAN W W. Research on open government data evaluation framework, indicators and methods[J]. Library and information service, 2016, 60(18):43-55.)
[25] NIKIFOROVA A, LNENICKA M. A multi-perspective knowledge-driven approach for analysis of the demand side of the open government data portal[J]. Government information quarterly, 2021, 38(4):101622. 233-240.(LEI H Z, WANG Q. Research on the path of realizing the value of government data openness from the perspective[J]. Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and social sciences edition), 2023, 44(1):233-240.)
[5] 袁静,李森涛.用户参与政府开放数据价值共创动因研究[J].数字图书馆论坛, 2023, 19(2):1-9.(YUAN J, LI S T. Users participate in the research on the co-creation drivers of the value of government open data[J]. Digital library forum, 2023, 19(2):1-9.)
[6] ZUIDERWIJK A, JANSSEN M, DWIVEDI Y K. Acceptance and use predictors of open data technologies:drawing upon the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology[J]. Government information quarterly, 2015, 32(4):429-440.
[7] BENITEZ-PAEZ F, DEGBELO A, TRILLES S et al. Roadblocks hindering the reuse of open geodata in Colombia and Spain:a data user's perspective[J]. ISPRS international journal of geoinformation, 2018, 7(1):6.
[8] GONZALE-ZAPATA F, HEEKS R. The multiple meanings of open government data:understanding different stakeholders and their perspective[J]. Government information quarterly, 2015, 32(4):441-452.
[9] 赵龙文,洪逸飞,赵雪琦.政府开放数据资源利用与创新应用效能评价研究[J].现代情报, 2023, 43(7):133-144.(ZHAO W L, HONG Y F, ZHAO X Q. Research on efficiency evaluation of open government data resource utilization and innovative application[J]. Journal of modern information, 2023, 43(7):133-144.)
[10] 袁莉,姚乐野.政府数据开放的整体能力:概念、框架及演化机制[J].图书情报工作, 2021, 65(19):53-60.(YUAN L, YAO L Y. Overall capabilities of government data openness:concept, framework and evolutionary mechanism[J]. Library and information service, 2021, 65(19):53-60.)
[11] 门理想,杜亚斌,王芮,等.政府数据开放的利用行为与持续利用意愿研究[J].数字图书馆论坛, 2023, 19(7):73-81.(MEN L X, DU Y B, WANG R, et al. Utilization behavior and sustained utilization willingness of open government data[J]. Digital library forum, 2023, 19(7):73-81.)
[12] SMITH G, SANDBERG J. Barriers to innovating with open government data:exploring experiences across service phases and user types[J]. Information polity, 2018, 23(3):249-265.
[13] 胡水星,荆洲,王会军.我国高校大数据治理体系的关键要素与优化路径研究--基于DEMATEL-ISM的视角[J].电化教育研究, 2022, 43(11):38-44, 52.(HU S X, JIN Z, WANG H J. Research on the key elements and optimization path of big data governance system in Chinese universities--based on the perspective of DEMATEL-ISM[J]. E-education research, 2022, 43(11):38-44, 52.)
[14] 赵霞霞,母睿.公共数据开放对学术创新的作用机制--基于人-数交互理论[J].科技管理研究, 2023, 43(9):1-10.(ZHAO X X, MU R. The mechanism of public data opening on academic innovation:based on human-number interaction theory[J]. Science and technology management research, 2023, 43(9):1-10.)
[15] XIAO F H, CHI Y, HE D Q. Promoting data use through understanding user behaviors:a model for human open government data interaction[J]. Journal of the association for information science and technology, 2023, 74(13):1498-1514.
[16] VICTORELLI E Z, DOSREIS J C, HORNUNG H, et al. Understanding human-data interaction:literature review and recommendations for design[J]. International journal of humancomputer studies, 2020, 134:13-32.
[17] 徐慧娜,郑磊.面向用户利用的开放政府数据平台:纽约与上海比较研究[J].电子政务, 2015(7):37-45.(XU H N, ZHEN L. Open government data platform for user utilization:a comparative study between New York and Shanghai[J]. E-government, 2015(7):37-45.)
[18] PURWANTO A, ZUIDERWIJK A. Citizen engagement with open government data:a systematic literature review of drivers and inhibitors[J]. International journal of electronic government research, 2020, 16(3):1-25.
[19] 郑磊,韩笑,朱晓婷.地方政府数据开放平台研究:功能与体验[J].电子政务, 2019(9):12-22.(ZHEN L, HAN X, ZHU X T. Research on local government data open platform:function and experience[J]. E-government, 2019(9):12-22.)
[20] PARASUREMAN A, ZEITHAML V, MALHOTRA A. E-SQUAL:a multiple-item scale for assessing electronic service quality[J]. Journal of service research, 2005, 7(3):213-233.
[21] 钱明辉,徐志轩,王珊.基于用户参与的在线健康平台信息服务质量研究[J].情报学报, 2019, 38(2):132-142.(QIAN M H, XU Z X, WANG S. Research on information service quality of online health platform based on user participation[J]. Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information, 2019, 38(2):132-142.)
[22] 白献阳,孙梦皎,安小米.大数据环境下我国政府数据开放政策体系研究[J].图书馆学研究, 2018(24):48-56.(BAI X Y, SUN M J, AN X M. Research on Chinese government data open policy system under big data environment[J]. Research on library science, 2018(24):48-56.)
[23] SIMONOFSKI A, ZUIDERWOJL A, CLARINVAL A. Tailoring open government data portals for lay citizens:a gamification theory approach[J]. International journal of information management, 2022, 65:102511.
[24] 郑磊,关文雯.开放政府数据评估框架、指标与方法研究[J].图书情报工作, 2016, 60(18):43-55.(ZHEN L, GUAN W W. Research on open government data evaluation framework, indicators and methods[J]. Library and information service, 2016, 60(18):43-55.)
[25] NIKIFOROVA A, LNENICKA M. A multi-perspective knowledge-driven approach for analysis of the demand side of the open government data portal[J]. Government information quarterly, 2021, 38(4):101622.
[26] 李白杨.我国政府数据开放的用户需求及其保障策略研究[D].武汉:武汉大学, 2017.(LI B Y. Research on user demand and guarantee strategy of government data opening in China[D]. Wuhan:Wuhan University, 2017.)
[27] 胡卉,吴鸣.嵌入科研工作流与数据生命周期的数据素养能力研究[J].图书与情报, 2016(4):125-137.(HU H, WU M. Research on data literacy capability embedded in research workflow and data life cycle[J]. Library and information service, 2016(4):125-137.)
[28] 隆茜,刘继刚.高校馆员数据素养能力评价与教育主体结构研究[J].图书馆, 2017(11):61-65.(LONG Q, LIU J G. Research on the evaluation of data literacy ability of university librarians and the structure of education subject[J]. Library, 2017(11):61-65.)
[29] WOLSKI M, KRAHE M, RICHARDSON J. A model for librarians to assess the digital capability of research teams[J]. Journal of the Australian library and information association, 2020, 69(1):47-69.
[30] 钱瑛,徐绪堪,朱昌平,等.面向图书情报专业硕士的数据素养能力评价指标体系构建[J].情报理论与实践, 2022, 45(10):62-68.(QIAN Y, XU X K, ZHU C P, et al. Construction of data literacy ability evaluation index system for library and information professional master[J]. Information studies:theory&application, 2022, 45(10):62-68.)
[31] 宋甲丽,宋春健,程结晶.高校图书馆用户科学数据素养能力与需求调查分析[J].图书馆学研究, 2019(5):56-70.(SONG J L, SONG C J, CHENG J J. Investigation and analysis of scientific data literacy ability and demand of university library users[J]. Research on library science, 2019(5):56-70.)
[32] ANWAR M, KHAN S Z, SHAH S Z A. Big data capabilities and firm's performance:a mediating role of competitive advantage[J]. Journal of information&knowledge management, 2019, 17(4):1850045.
[33] 刘爱琴,刘蕾蕾,尚珊. MOOC环境下数据素养能力评价模型构建与度量[J].图书馆理论与实践, 2018(3):104-109.(LIU A Q, LIU L L, SHANG S. Construction and measurement of data literacy competence evaluation model in MOOC environment[J]. Library theory and practice, 2018(3):104-109.)
[34] 秦小燕,初景利.科学数据素养能力评价指标体系构建研究[J].图书与情报, 2020(4):56-66.(QIN X Y, CHU J L. Research on the construction of evaluation index system of scientific data literacy ability[J]. Library&information, 2020(4):56-66.)
[35] PANGRAZIO L, SEFTON-GREEN J. The social utility of'data literacy'[J]. Learning media and technology, 2020, 45(2):208-220.
[36] 朱红灿,沈超.认知视角下科研用户政府开放数据利用影响因素研究--基于扎根理论的探索性分析[J].现代情报, 2021, 41(10):40-46, 100.(ZHU H C, SHEN C. Research on influencing factors of government open data utilization by scientific research users from a cognitive perspective:an exploratory analysis based on grounded theory[J]. Journal of modern information, 2021, 41(10):40-46, 100.)
[37] ZELETI F A, OJO A. Capability model for open data:an empirical analysis[C]//Proceedings of the 11th international conference on theory and practice of electronic governance. New York:Association for Computing Machinery, 2018:403-411.
[38] 杨利超.图书馆员科学数据素养能力框架与发展策略研究[J].图书馆理论与实践, 2018(9):90-95.(YANG L C. Research on the framework and development strategy of librarians'scientific data literacy competence[J]. Library theory and practice, 2018(9):90-95.)
[39] 齐乾坤,王文龙.基于数据生命周期的高校研究生数据素养评价研究[J].情报科学, 2021, 39(9):125-130, 145.(QI Q K, WANG W L. Research on data literacy evaluation of university graduate students based on data life cycle[J]. Information science, 2021, 39(9):125-130, 145.)
[40] GASCO-HERNANDEZ M, MARTIN E G, REGGI L, et al. Promoting the use of open government data:cases of training and engagement[J]. Government information quarterly, 2018, 35(2):233-242.
[41] 沈晶,胡广伟.利益相关者视角下政府数据开放价值生成机制研究[J].情报杂志, 2016, 35(12):92-97.(SHEN J, HU G W. Research on the value generation mechanism of government data openness from the perspective of stakeholders[J]. Journal of Intelligence, 2016, 35(12):92-97.)
[42] 周文泓.我国地方政府开放数据政策构建的进展与优化策略研究[J].图书馆学研究, 2018(15):39-45.(ZHOU W H. Research on progress and optimization strategy of local government open data policy construction in China[J]. Research on library science, 2018(15):39-45.)
[43] 段尧清,周密,尚婷.政府开放数据公众初始接受行为影响因素结构关系研究[J].图书情报工作, 2020, 64(2):4-12.(DUAN Y Q, ZHOU M, SHANG T. Study on structural relationship of influencing factors of public initial acceptance behavior of government open data[J]. Library and information service, 2020, 64(2):4-12.)
[44] 冉连,张曦,张海霞.政府数据开放中的公众参与行为:生成机理与促进策略[J].现代情报, 2022, 42(2):143-151.(RAN L, ZHANG X, ZHANG H X. Public participation behavior in government data opening:generative mechanism and promotion strategy[J]. Journal of modern information, 2022, 42(2):143-151.)
[45] 盛小平,杨志勇.开放科学、开放共享、开放数据三者关系解析[J].图书情报工作, 2019, 63(17):15-22.(SHENG X P, YANG Z Y. Analysis of the relationship between open science, open sharing and open data[J]. Library and information service, 2019, 63(17):15-22.)
[46] 谭必勇,刘芮.我国地方政府开放数据政策研究--以15个副省级城市为例[J].情报理论与实践, 2018, 41(11):51-56.(TAN B Y, LIU R. Research on local government open data policy in China--taking 15 sub-provincial cities as an example[J]. Information studies:theory&application, 2018, 41(11):51-56.)
[47] 陈为公,张娜,张友森,等.基于DEMATEL-ISM的城市灾害韧性影响因素研究[J].灾害学, 2021, 36(1):1-6.(CHEN W G, ZHANG N, ZHANG Y S, et al. Research on influencing factors of urban disaster resilience based on DEMATEL-ISM[J]. Journal of catastrophology, 2021, 36(1):1-6.)
[48] 完颜邓邓,宋婷.我国地方政府数据开放平台的安全风险测评[J].图书馆论坛, 2022, 42(2):119-128.(WANYAN D D, SONG T. Security risk assessment of China's local government data open platform[J]. Library tribune, 2022, 42(2):119-128.)
[49] 刘桂锋,聂云贝,刘琼.数据质量评价对象、体系、方法与技术研究进展[J].情报科学, 2021, 39(11):13-20.(LIU G F, NIE Y B, LIU Q. Research progress on object, system, method and technology of data quality evaluation[J]. Information science, 2021, 39(11):13-20.)
[50] 完颜邓邓,陶成煦.政府数据开放平台用户协议合规性评估[J].图书馆论坛, 2021, 41(7):116-124.(WANYAN D D, TAO C X. Evaluation of user agreement compliance of government data open platform[J]. Library tribune, 2021, 41(7):116-124.)
[51] 朱贝,盛小平.英国政府开放数据政策研究[J].图书馆论坛, 2016, 36(3):121-127, 120.(ZHU B, SHENG X P. British government open data policy research[J]. Library tribune, 2016, 36(3):121-127, 120.)
[52] 谭必勇,陈艳.我国开放政府数据平台数据质量研究--以十省、市为研究对象[J].情报杂志, 2017, 36(11):99-105.(TAN B Y, CHEN Y. Research on data quality of China's open government data platform:taking ten provinces and cities as research objects[J]. Journal of intelligence, 2017, 36(11):99-105.)
[53] 宋雪雁,管丹丹,张祥青,等.基于服务接触的电子政务门户网站知识服务质量影响因素研究[J].图书情报工作, 2018, 62(23):1-9.(SONG X Y, GUAN D D, ZHANG X Q, et al. Research on influencing factors of e-government portal knowledge service quality based on service contact[J]. Library and information service, 2018, 62(23):1-9.)
Outlines

/