REVIEW & COMMENTARY

Panoramic Analysis and Consideration of Digital Humanities Research in Chinese Humanities

  • Pan Yuting ,
  • Ke Ping
Expand
  • Department of Information Resource Management, Business School, Nankai University, Tianjin 300071

Received date: 2024-01-08

  Revised date: 2024-02-25

  Online published: 2024-07-30

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] Investigating the reality of digital humanities research in the field of humanities is helpful to understand the views of humanities scholars on it, and provide important references for the development of digital humanities. [Method/Process] The publication of journals can reflect the current focus and emphasis of the discipline. This article selected five disciplines of literature, history, philosophy, linguistics and art as representatives of the humanities. Taking 106 digital humanities articles, which were published in CSSCI core journals of these disciplines, as research objects, it conducted an in-depth analysis of the content of the articles with quantitative methods such as document metrology, keyword classification statistics. [Result/Conclusion] It finds that digital humanities have not become the focus in the core journals, but many well-known humanities scholars have been involved in the research. The existing research is mainly qualitative and lacks practical exploration. Digital humanities present different characteristics in different disciplines. Moretti and his thoughts on distance reading have greatly influenced digital humanities research in literature. The historical digital humanities primarily focuses on the Qing Dynasty. In the field of linguistics, linguistic scholars are particularly interested in digital humanities translation studies and the impact of digital humanities on foreign language education. In the field of art, digital humanities research is significantly focused on film studies. Humanities scholars believe that it is difficult for digital humanities to break through the existing research framework and balance the contradictions with traditional Chinese hermeneutics. They, are confused about database quality, the particularity of Chinese characters, and research paradigms.

Cite this article

Pan Yuting , Ke Ping . Panoramic Analysis and Consideration of Digital Humanities Research in Chinese Humanities[J]. Library and Information Service, 2024 , 68(15) : 128 -140 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2024.15.011

References

[1] 吴利俊, 辛继宾, 宋元明. 数字人文研究概念、学科和热点的演变与趋势[J]. 图书馆理论与实践, 2023(4): 104-112. (WU L J, XIN J B, SONG Y M. The evolution and trend of concepts, disciplines and hot spots of digital humanities research[J]. Library theory and practice, 2023(4): 104-112.)
[2] 李娜. 国际数字人文研究的演化路径与热点主题分析[J]. 图书馆, 2021(5): 59-67, 73. (LI N. Analysis on the evolution path and hot topics of international digital humanities research[J]. Library, 2021(5): 59-67, 73.)
[3] 张旭, 洪逸暄, 尤剑. 我国数字人文研究热点与趋势[J]. 图书馆工作与研究, 2023(10): 69-76. (ZHANG X, HONG Y X, YOU J. Research hotspots and trend of digital humanities in China[J]. Library work and study, 2023(10): 69-76.)
[4] 林施望. 从“人文计算”到“数字人文”——概念与研究方式的变迁[J]. 图书馆论坛, 2019, 39(8): 12-20. (LIN S W. From humanities computing to digital humanities: the transformation of concepts and research methods[J]. Library tribune, 2019, 39(8): 12-20.)
[5] 刘炜. 作为数字人文基础设施的图书馆:从不可或缺到无可替代[J]. 图书馆论坛, 2020, 40(5): 1-2. (LIU W. Libraries as digital humanities infrastructure: from indispensable to irreplaceable[J]. Library tribune, 2020, 40(5): 1-2.)
[6] 于英香. 数字人文研究论争及思考[J]. 图书馆杂志, 2023, 42(2): 98-105. (YU Y X. Controversy and thinking on digital humanities research[J]. Library journal, 2023, 42(2): 98-105.)
[7] 董舞艺, 梁兴堃. 中国人文学者参与数字人文动机的二元结构及行为路径[J]. 中国图书馆学报, 2019, 45(4): 86-103. (DONG W Y, LIANG X K. Motivations and paths of Chinese humanities scholars participating in digital humanities[J]. Journal of library science in China, 2019, 45(4): 86-103.)
[8] 赵雪芹, 莫长镭, 李天娥, 等. 人文学者的数字人文接受意愿影响因素——以历史学者为中心的考察[J]. 图书馆论坛, 2020, 40(4): 40-49. (ZHAO X Q, MO C L, Li T E, et al. Influencing factors of humanities scholars’ willingness to accept digital humanities: an investigation centered on historians[J]. Library tribune, 2020, 40(4): 40-49.)
[9] 肖鹏, 衣春波. 万华镜里的自画像:关于中国人文学者数字学术认知与需求的质性研究[J]. 图书情报工作, 2021, 65(7): 4-14. (XIAO P, YI C B. Self Portrait in the mirror: a qualitative study of the digital scholarship cognition and needs of Chinese humanists scholars[J]. Library and information service, 2021, 65(7): 4-14.)
[10] 段青玉, 王晓光, 梁梦丽. 文史研究生的数字人文学术动机、需求与学术原语[J]. 图书情报知识, 2023, 40(1): 124-136. (DUAN Q Y, WANG X G, LIANG M L. Motivations, needs and scholarly primitives of digital humanities practices for graduate students in literature and history[J]. Documentation, information &knowledge, 2023, 40(1): 124-136.)
[11] 中国社会科学研究评价中心. CSSCI来源期刊目录(2021-2022)[EB/OL]. [2024-05-08]. https://cssrac.nju.edu.cn/cpzx/zwshkxywsy/20210425/i198393.html. (Institute for Chinese Social Sciences Research and Assessment. CSSCI Source Journal Catalog(2021-2022)[EB/OL]. [2024-05-08]. https://cssrac.nju.edu.cn/cpzx/zwshkxywsy/20210425/i198393.html.)
[12] 布里格曼, 布鲁道, 多克, 等. 褶子:重思可视化数据的交互性[J]. 电影艺术, 2022(4): 19-26. (BRUGGEMANN V, BLUDAU M, DORK M, et al. The fold: rethinking interactivity in data visualization[J]. Film art, 2022(4): 19-26.)
[13] 雷蕾. 语言数字人文:“小帐篷”理论框架[J]. 外语与外语教学, 2023(3): 63-73, 147. (LEI L. Digital humanities in linguistic: a theoretical framework of the “Small Tent”[J]. Foreign languages and their teaching, 2023(3): 63-73, 147.)
[14] 田媛. 文化记忆、数据库建构与在地身份探寻——以澳门电影史料数据库为例[J]. 当代电影, 2022(1): 141-148. (TIAN Y. Cultural memory, database construction and the search for local identity: the case of Macao film historical database[J]. Contemporary cinema, 2022(1): 141-148.)
[15] 徐小棠, 周雯. 建构数字文化记忆的辅助工具:虚拟现实记录影像的美学特征及其文化外延[J]. 北京电影学院学报, 2021(12): 60-66. (XU X T, ZHOU W. Aesthetic characteristics and cultural value of virtual reality documentary images[J]. Journal of Beijing film academy, 2021(12): 60-66.)
[16] 王贺. “数字人文”如何与现代文学研究结合[J]. 现代中文学刊, 2019(1): 78-80. (WANG H. How does “Digital Humanities” combine with modern literary studies[J]. Journal of modern Chinese literature, 2019(1): 78-80.)
[17] 黄兴涛. 当代中国历史学的时代使命[J]. 历史研究, 2019(1): 20-21. (HUANG X T. The mission of contemporary Chinese history[J]. Historical research, 2019(1): 20-21.)
[18] 赵薇. “数字人文”与现代文学研究中的计量方法[J]. 现代中文学刊, 2019(1): 72-75. (ZHAO W. Quantitative methods in the study of “Digital Humanities” and modern literature[J]. Journal of modern Chinese literature, 2019(1): 72-75.)
[19] 陈刚. 计量电影学与费穆电影结构的可视化路径[J]. 电影艺术, 2020(4): 45-52. (CHEN G. Cinemetrics from the perspective of digital humanities: visualized path of Fei Mu’s film structure[J]. Film art, 2020(4): 45-52.)
[20] 赵薇. 网络分析与人物理论[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2020(2): 38-46. (ZHAO W. Network analysis and character theory[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2020(2): 38-46.)
[21] 邱伟云. 论数字人文研究中可视化数据的意义与价值——以数字概念史研究为例[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2020(2): 23-29. (QIU W Y. On the significance and value of visualized data in digital humanities research: a case study of the history of digital concepts[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2020(2): 23-29.)
[22] 向帆. 可视化设计视野中的视觉艺术研究[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2020(2): 46-53. (XIANG F. The visual art studies from the perspective of the visualization design[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2020(2): 46-53.)
[23] 王军. 从人文计算到可视化——数字人文的发展脉络梳理[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2020(2): 18-23. (WANG J. From humanities computing to visualization: a survey of the development of digital humanities[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2020(2): 18-23.)
[24] 陈晓辉. 世界文学、距离阅读与文学批评的数字人文转型——弗兰克·莫莱蒂的文学理论演进逻辑[J]. 文艺理论研究, 2018, 38(6): 114-124. (CHEN X H. Digital humanistic transformation of world literature, distance reading and literary criticism: Franco Moretti’s evolution logic of literary theory[J]. Theoretical studies in literature and art, 2018, 38(6): 114-124.)
[25] 都岚岚. 论莫莱蒂的远读及其影响[J]. 中国比较文学, 2020(3): 179-193. (DU L L. Moretti’s distant reading and its influence[J]. Comparative literature in China, 2020(3): 179-193.)
[26] 郑楠. 媒介构造与范式生产:“远读”方法的演变及其前景[J]. 文艺理论研究, 2022, 42(4): 104-112. (ZHENG N. Media formation and paradigm production: evolution of the method of “Distant Reading” and its prospects[J]. Theoretical studies in literature and art, 2022, 42(4): 104-112.)
[27] 姜文涛. 作为一种文学研究方法的数字人文——印刷文化基础设施, 20世纪文学批评史, 以及文学社会学[J]. 中国比较文学, 2019(4): 29-47. (JIANG W T. Digital humanities as a literature research method: print culture infrastructure, literary criticism in the 20th century, and the sociology of literature[J]. Comparative literature in China, 2019(4): 29-47.)
[28] 南帆. 网络空间与文学批评谱系[J]. 中国文学批评, 2023(2): 104-112, 191. (NAN F. Cyberspace and the genealogy of literary criticism[J]. Chinese journal of literary criticism, 2023(2): 104-112, 191.)
[29] 谭天, 蔡翔宇. 假升级, 真打脸:逃离不了家庭的赘婿[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2021(4): 85-95. (TAN T, CAI X Y. Fake upgrade, real hit the face: cannot escape the family’s Son-In-Law [J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2021(4): 85-95.)
[30] 吉云飞. 作为“计算批评”的“远读”——以网络小说“升级文”中的节奏与情绪为例[J]. 中国现代文学研究丛刊, 2020(8): 177-187. (JI Y F. “Far Reading” as “Computational Criticism”: a case study of rhythm and emotion in network novel “Upgrading Text”[J]. Modern Chinese literature studies, 2020(8): 177-187.)
[31] 高寒凝. 网络文学研究中的数字人文视野——以晋江文学城积分榜单及“清穿文”为例[J]. 中国现代文学研究丛刊, 2020(8): 201-212. (GAO H N. Digital humanities perspective in the study of network literature: a case study of Jinjiang Literature City’s score list and “QingChuanwen”[J]. Modern Chinese literature studies, 2020(8): 201-212.)
[32] 李强. 作为数字人文思维的“网文算法”——以“明穿”小说为例[J]. 中国现代文学研究丛刊, 2020(8): 188-200. (LI Q. “Web Text Algorithm” as a digital humanistic thinking: taking “MingChuan” novel as an example[J]. Modern Chinese literature studies, 2020(8): 188-200.)
[33] 许婷, 肖映萱. 由“一夫”至“多宝”:数字人文视角下女频小说的情感位移[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2021(4): 96-105. (XU T, XIAO Y X. From “One Husband” to “Multiple Births”: the emotional displacement of female network novels from the perspective of digital humanities[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2021(4): 96-105.)
[34] 彭雨. 数字人文作为儿童文学研究方法的实践与反思[J]. 当代文坛, 2023(5): 138-145. (PENG Y. The practice and reflection of digital humanities as a research method of children’s literature[J]. Contemporary literary criticism, 2023(5): 138-145.)
[35] 陈必佳, 康文林. 数字人文与清代官员仕途研究[J]. 史学月刊, 2023(4): 88-100. (CHEN B J, KANG W L. Digital humanities and the study of career trajectories of Qing officials[J]. Journal of historical science, 2023(4): 88-100.)
[36] 胡恒. 数据库建设与清史研究[J]. 清史研究, 2016(4): 17-25. (HU H. The establishment of databases and research in Qing history[J]. The Qing history journal, 2016(4): 17-25.)
[37] 胡恒, 朱浒. 数字人文与清代官僚政治史研究[J]. 史学月刊, 2023(1): 110-115. (HU H, ZHU H. Digital humanities and the study of bureaucratic and political history in the Qing dynasty[J]. Journal of historical science, 2023(1): 110-115.)
[38] 潘威, 岳佳雲. 关于数字人文进入清代河流研究的若干想法[J]. 史学月刊, 2023(1): 116-121. (PAN W, YUE J Y. Some thoughts on digital humanities entering the study of rivers in the Qing dynasty[J]. Journal of historical science, 2023(1): 116-121.)
[39] 毛立平. 清代性别史研究何处去[J]. 清史研究, 2023(3): 12-20. (MAO L P. Gender history of the Qing dynasty: retrospect and prospect[J]. The Qing history journal, 2023(3): 12-20.)
[40] 张婧文, 郭美廷. 数字人文视阈下文物信息可视化发展路径研究[J]. 东南文化, 2021(5): 162-168. (ZHANG J W, GUO M T. The visualization of cultural relics information in the context of digital humanities[J]. Southeast culture, 2021(5): 162-168.)
[41] 李峰. 文物知识聚合与传播的初步研究——以上海博物馆“宋徽宗与他的时代数字人文专题”为例[J]. 东南文化, 2022(3): 169-177, 191-192, 197-199. (LI F. A preliminary study on knowledge aggregation and dissemination of cultural relics: Shanghai Museum’s digital program “Emperor Huizong of Song and His Times” as an example[J]. Southeast culture, 2022(3): 169-177, 191-192, 197-199.)
[42] 柴英, 朱文旭. 大变局之际中国世界史研究的学术发展轨迹——以2020年《复印报刊资料·世界史》为中心[J]. 史林, 2021(3): 206-216, 222. (CHAI Y, ZHU W X. Mapping China’s study of world history in a changing globe: the 2020 world history of renda reprinted materials[J]. Historical review, 2021(3): 206-216, 222.)
[43] 赵思渊. 民间文书整理与研究中的数字人文方法与文献学本位[J]. 中国史研究动态, 2017(5): 46-49. (ZHAO S Y. The method of gigital humanities and the standard of philology in the collation and research of folk documents[J]. Trends of recent researches on the history of China, 2017(5): 46-49.)
[44] 黄义军. 历史地理研究的新趋向(2015—2020)[J]. 中国史研究动态, 2021(6): 21-32. (HUANG Y J. New trends in the study of historical geography (2015-2020)[J]. Trends of recent researches on the history of China, 2021(6): 21-32.)
[45] 胡开宝, 王晓莉. 数字人文视域下翻译研究:现状、问题与前景[J]. 外语与外语教学, 2022(6): 111-121, 148-149. (HU K B, WANG X L. Translation studies in digital humanities: state of the art, issues and future directions[J]. Foreign languages and their teaching, 2022(6): 111-121, 148-149.)
[46] 胡开宝, 黑黟. 数字人文视域下翻译研究:特征、领域与意义[J]. 中国翻译, 2020, 41(2): 5-15, 187. (HU K B, HEI Y. Translation studies in the digital humanities: features, research areas and implications[J]. Chinese translators journal, 2020, 41(2): 5-15, 187.)
[47] 胡开宝. 数字人文视域下翻译研究的进展与前景[J]. 中国翻译, 2018, 39(6): 24-26. (HU K B. Progress and prospects of translation studies from the perspective of digital humanities[J]. Chinese translators journal, 2018, 39(6): 24-26.)
[48] 张威, 雷璇. 翻译研究的数字人文“转向”:现状及反思[J]. 中国翻译, 2023, 44(2): 99-106. (ZHANG W, LEI X. The digital humanities “Turn” in translation studies: current situation and reflections[J]. Chinese rranslators journal, 2023, 44(2): 99-106.)
[49] 王华树, 刘世界. 数字人文视域下译者数字素养研究:内涵、问题与建议[J]. 外语教学理论与实践, 2023(2): 70-79. (WANG H S, LIU S J. Research on translators’ digital literacy from the perspective of digital humanities: connotations, problems and suggestions[J]. Foreign language learning theory and practice, 2023(2): 70-79.)
[50] 吴苌弘. 数字人文发展中的法律术语英译规范与策略[J]. 外语电化教学, 2021(6): 81-86, 13. (WU C H. On english translation of legal terms: translation norms and strategies in the development of digital humanity[J]. Technology enhanced foreign language education, 2021(6): 81-86, 13.)
[51] 刘泽权. 数字人文视域下名著重译多维评价模型构建[J]. 中国翻译, 2021, 42(5): 25-33, 191. (LIU Z Q. A digital humanities-framed multivariant model for assessing the quality of retranslations of literary masterpieces[J]. Chinese translators journal, 2021, 42(5): 25-33, 191.)
[52] 焦鹏帅, 李野. 中国诗画多模态翻译与传播:一个综合文本视角[J]. 外语教学理论与实践, 2023(1): 86-97. (JIAO P S, LI Y. On multimodal translation and communication of traditional Chinese poetry and painting: from a perspective of syntext[J]. Foreign language learning theory and practice, 2023(1): 86-97.)
[53] 宁琦. 数字人文赋能外语学科的思考与探索[J]. 外语界, 2023(1): 12-17. (NING Q. Some thoughts on digital humanities empowering foreign language discipline[J]. Foreign language world, 2023(1): 12-17.)
[54] 佟和龙. 数字人文视域下我国英语专业改革发展的路径[J]. 外语电化教学, 2023(1): 25-31, 108. (TONG H L. The path of reform and development of English major in China in the context of digital humanities[J]. Technology enhanced foreign language education, 2023(1): 25-31, 108.)
[55] 苏红, 王银泉. 数字人文时代高校智慧型外语教师信息素养提升策略研究[J]. 外语电化教学, 2022(2): 55-63, 121. (SU H, WANG Y Q. Strategies for improving the information literacy of intelligent foreign language teaching in colleges and universities in the era of digital humanities[J]. Technology enhanced foreign language education, 2022(2): 55-63, 121.)
[56] 梁海英. 数字人文视阈下的大学英语写作教学:思想与方法[J]. 外语界, 2022(6): 50-57. (LIANG H Y. College English writing teaching from the perspective of digital humanities: notions and methods[J]. Foreign language world, 2022(6): 50-57.)
[57] 刘夏, 何高大. 数字人文与新文科视角下的英语专业人才培养探索[J]. 外语电化教学, 2022(1): 27-33, 105. (LIU X, HE G D. An exploration of English language major education from the perspective of digital humanities and new liberal arts[J]. Technology enhanced foreign language education, 2022(1): 27-33, 105.)
[58] 普泽南. 从数字人文的起源看影人年谱与其关系[J]. 电影艺术, 2020(4): 38-44. (PU Z N. On the chronicles of filmmakers and their relationship from the origin of digital humanities[J]. Film art, 2020(4): 38-44.)
[59] 李春芳. 《阮玲玉》计量分析与中国早期影人图谱[J]. 电影艺术, 2022(4): 34-45. (LI C F. Cinemetrics analysis on center stage and knowledge graph of Chinese earlier filmmakers[J]. Film art, 2022(4): 34-45.)
[60] 李道新. 数字人文、影人年谱与电影研究新路径[J]. 电影艺术, 2020(5): 27-35. (LI D X. Digital humanities and film chronology: a new approach to film research[J]. Film art, 2020(5): 27-35.)
[61] 张隽隽. 数据库与在华外国电影人研究(1897—1949)[J]. 电影艺术, 2020(4): 53-59. (ZHANG J J. Databases and the study on the foreign filmmakers and Cinema operators in China(1897-1949)[J]. Film art, 2020(4): 53-59.)
[62] 曼纽尔, 阿德海德, 约翰内斯, 等. 数字人文中的电影与视频分析:一场跨学科的对话[J]. 北京电影学院学报, 2022(10): 4-15. (MANUEL B, ADELHEID H, JOHANNES P, et al. Film and video analysis in the digital humanities: an interdisciplinary dialog[J]. Journal of Beijing Film Academy, 2022(10): 4-15.)
[63] 司若, 黄莺. 电影修复的历史、规范与时代意义[J]. 电影艺术, 2021(5): 102-110. (SI R, HUANG Y. History, norms and significance of film restoration[J]. Film art, 2021(5): 102-110.)
[64] 刘文宁. 电影数字修复:档案性、历史性、可见性[J]. 当代电影, 2023(8): 143-149. (LIU W N. Digital restoration of film: archival, historical and visible[J]. Contemporary cinema, 2023(8): 143-149.)
[65] 马诺维奇, 李鹤伊. 计算机视觉、人类感官与艺术的语言[J]. 当代电影, 2021(10): 129-136. (MANOVICH L, LI H Y. Computer vision, human senses, and language of art[J]. Contemporary cinema, 2021(10): 129-136.)
[66] 王征, 陈风明. 美国华人美术教授近40年现状之数据调研[J]. 南京艺术学院学报(美术与设计), 2020(4): 169-174. (WANG Z, CHEN F M. A data survey on the status of Chinese American art professors in the past 40 years [J]. Journal of Nanjing Arts Institute (fine arts & design), 2020(4): 169-174.)
[67] 秦龙, 陈洁. 面向岭南骑楼非遗街区更新的满洲窗文化资源数据档案实践与研究[J]. 装饰, 2022(10): 94-97. (QIN L, CHEN J. Practice and research on data archives of Manchurian window cultural resources for Lingnan arcade intangible cultural heritage block renewal[J]. ZHUANGSHI, 2022(10): 94-97.)
[68] 袁烽, 韩力, 张雯. 数字人文时代的乡村预制产业化实践[J]. 建筑学报, 2017(10): 71-73. (YUAN F, HAN L, ZHANG W. Practicing prefab industrialization in the era of digital humanities in rural China[J]. Architectural journal, 2017(10): 71-73.)
[69] 王兆鹏, 郑永晓, 刘京臣. 借器之势, 出道之新——“数字人文”浪潮下的古典文学研究三人谈[J]. 文艺研究, 2019(9): 79-88. (WANG Z P, ZHENG Y X, LIU J C. A trio talk on classical literature research under the wave of “digital humanities”[J]. Literature & art studies, 2019(9): 79-88.)
[70] 胡玄. 易卜生研究的新视角和新方法: 弗鲁德·海兰德教授访谈录[J]. 戏剧(中央戏剧学院学报), 2018(3): 39-45. (HU X. New perspectives and methodologies in Ibsen studies: an interview with professor Frode Helland[J]. Drama (The journal of the Central Academy of Drama), 2018(3): 39-45.)
[71] 庞贻丹, 郑永松. 法国数字人文与艺术史的交织与互进[J]. 新美术, 2023, 44(2): 219-228. (PANG Y D, ZHENG Y S. The interweaving and advancing of digital humanities and art history in France[J]. New arts, 2023, 44(2): 219-228.)
[72] 王峰. 生成式人工智能与文学知识系统的创新[J]. 文艺争鸣, 2023(7): 68-76. (WANG F. Generative artificial intelligence and the innovation of literary knowledge system[J]. Literary debate, 2023(7): 68-76.)
[73] 孙婧. 数字人文与电影史研究的“显宏镜”[J]. 电影艺术, 2022(4): 12-18. (SUN J. The “Macroscopic Mirror” of digital humanities and film history research[J]. Film art, 2022(4): 12-18.)
[74] 王秀涛. 当代文学史料的等级问题[J]. 文艺争鸣, 2020(1): 14-25. (WANG X T. The problem of the grade of contemporary literary historical materials[J]. Literary debate, 2020(1): 14-25.)
[75] 申斌, 杨培娜. 数字技术与史学观念——中国历史数据库与史学理念方法关系探析[J]. 史学理论研究, 2017(2): 87-95, 159. (SHEN B, YANG P N. Digital technology and the notion of history: a study of the relationship between historical database and historical methodology in China[J]. Historiography bimonthly, 2017(2): 87-95, 159.)
[76] 郭英剑. 数字人文: 概念、历史、现状及其在文学研究中的应用[J]. 江海学刊, 2018(3): 190-197, 239. (GUO Y J. Digital humanities: concept, history, status and its application in literary studies[J]. Jianghai academic journal, 2018(3): 190-197, 239.)
[77] 梁晨, 董浩, 李中清. 量化数据库与历史研究[J]. 历史研究, 2015(2): 113-128, 191-192. (LIANG C, DONG H, LI Z Q. Quantitative databases and historical research[J]. Historical research, 2015(2): 113-128, 191-192.)
[78] 王兆鹏, 邵大为. 数字人文在古代文学研究中的初步实践及学术意义[J]. 中国社会科学, 2020(8): 108-129, 206-207. (WANG Z P, SHAO D W. The preliminary practice and academic significance of digital humanities in the study of ancient literature[J]. Social sciences in China, 2020(8): 108-129, 206-207.)
[79] 包伟民. 数字人文及其对历史学的新挑战[J]. 史学月刊, 2018(9): 5-12. (BAO W M. Digital humanities: a new challenge for history[J]. Journal of historical science, 2018(9): 5-12.)
[80] 王贺. 追寻“数字鲁迅”:文本、机器与机器人——再思现代文学“数字化”及其相关问题[J]. 文艺争鸣, 2021(11): 77-94. (WANG H. Searching for “Digital Lu Xun”: text, machine and robot: rethinking the “digitization” of modern literature and its related issues[J]. Literary debate, 2021(11): 77-94.)
[81] 刘石. 大数据技术与古代文学经典文本分析研究[J]. 数字人文, 2020(1): 24-31. (LIU S. Big data technology and analysis of classical texts of ancient literature[J]. Digital humanities, 2020(1): 24-31.)
[82] 王兆鹏, 蒋晓晓. 时空一体化——唐宋文学编年地图平台的学术理念与学术价值[J]. 三峡论坛(三峡文学·理论版), 2020(5): 20-27, 35. (WANG Z P, JIANG X X. Space-time integration: the academic idea and academic value of Tang and Song literature chronicle map platform[J]. China three gorges tribune, 2020(5): 20-27, 35.)
[83] 王宁. 自然与技术视野下的当代人文反思[J]. 探索与争鸣, 2023(6): 143-148, 180. (WANG N. Reflection on contemporary humanities from the perspectives of nature and technology[J]. Exploration and free views, 2023(6): 143-148, 180.)
[84] 许鑫, 熊泽泉. 互动与争鸣——数位人文的方法与工具——第九届上海国际图书馆论坛数字学术与人文研究分会场互动环节综述[J]. 图书馆杂志, 2018, 37(12): 39-45. (XU X, XIONG Z Q. Interaction and contention: technologies and methods of digital humanities: a summary of the discussion panel in the digital academic and humanities research session of SILF2018[J]. Library journal, 2018, 37(12): 39-45.)
[85] 郑永晓. 传承与超越:数字文献学的未来发展刍议——兼论日本文献数字化对我国之启示[J]. 中国比较文学, 2019(4): 2-13. (ZHENG Y X. Inheritance and transcendence: on the future development of digital documentation and the enlightenment of Japanese document digitalization to China[J]. Comparative literature in China, 2019(4): 2-13.)
[86] 马霍尼. 数字人文的研究语言和研究对象(英文)[J]. 中国比较文学, 2020(1): 96-113. (MAHONY S. Language and the subjects of study in the digital humanities[J]. Comparative literature in China, 2020(1): 96-113.)
[87] 陈静. 复数的数字人文——比较视野下的中国数字人文[J]. 中国比较文学, 2019(4): 14-28. (CHEN J. Plural digital humanities: Chinese digital humanities from a comparative perspective[J]. Comparative literature in China, 2019(4): 14-28.)
[88] 王贺. “数字人文”与传统学术——以《解放日报》目录、索引及数据库为中心[J]. 文艺争鸣, 2020(10): 62-68. (WANG H. “Digital Humanities” and traditional scholarship: centered on Jiefang Daily’s catalog, index and database[J] Literary debate, 2020(10): 62-68.)
[89] 霍尔, 史国强. 走向后数字人文学科[J]. 当代作家评论, 2016(2): 179-185. (HALL G, SHI G Q. Toward a postdigital humanities: cultural analytics and the computational turn to data-driven scholarship[J]. Contemporary writers review, 2016(2): 179-185.)
[90] 严程. 文艺研究需要“数字”吗?[J]. 文艺理论与批评, 2020(2): 29-33. (YAN C. Do literary and artistic studies need “Digits”?[J]. Theory and criticism of literature and art, 2020(2): 29-33.)
[91] 耿强, 周知非. 数字人文视域下《人民日报》(1949—1966)生产的中国翻译话语研究[J]. 外语电化教学, 2023(1): 18-24, 107. (GENG Q, ZHOU Z F. Digital humanities approach to Chinese translation discourse produced in People’s Daily(1949-1966)[J]. Technology enhanced foreign language education, 2023(1): 18-24, 107.)
[92] 艾伦·刘, 朱子彤. 数字人文中的文化批评何在?[J]. 电影艺术, 2022(4): 27-33. (LIU A, ZHU Z T. Where is cultural criticism in the digital humanities?[J]. Film art, 2022(4): 27-33.)
[93] 黄水清. 人文计算与数字人文:概念、问题、范式及关键环节[J]. 图书馆建设, 2019(5): 68-78. (HUANG S Q. Humanity computing and digital humanities: concept, problem, paradigm and key step[J]. Library development, 2019(5): 68-78.)
Outlines

/