RESEARCH PAPERS

An Exploration of the Generation Mechanism of Adoption Behavior of AI-Assisted Archival Open Access Review in Comprehensive Archives from the Perspective of Phenomenological

  • Li Cairong ,
  • Du Keting ,
  • Zhang Yijing
Expand
  • School of History and Culture, Hubei University, Wuhan 430062
Li Cairong, Associate Professor, PhD;Du Keting, Master’s Candidate, Corresponding Author, E-mail: duketing8888@163.com;Zhang Yijing, Master’s Candidate.

Received date: 2025-08-06

  Revised date: 2025-11-23

  Online published: 2026-04-08

Supported by

This work is supported by the General Project of National Social Science Fund project titled “Research on Information Security Influencing Factors and Guarantee System in Archive Open Access Review” (Grant No. 24BTQ019).

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] The integration of artificial intelligence technology into archival open access review work helps to improve the efficiency of archival open access review and, promote the open utilization of archival resources, which is one of the key priorities of future archival open access review work. [Method/Process] This article combines SOR theory to analyze the elements of the adoption behavior of artificial intelligence assisted archival open access review in comprehensive archives from three dimensions of “stimulus organism response”. Based on the interview texts of 45 comprehensive archives, the internal mechanism of such behavior is explored using phenomenological analysis research methods. [Results/Conclusion] The study finds that the generation mechanism of this behavior is “contextual trigger-cognitive judgment-behavioral feedback”. The contextual trigger mechanism includes multiple stimulus factors such as laws and regulations, data security, personnel security, input cost and output benefit, peer experience, and confidentiality bureau supervision. In the process of active or passive information search and communication in comprehensive archives, their psychological attitudes change positively or negatively, leading to behavioral feedback. By analyzing its mechanism content and functional relationships, a comprehensive archive artificial intelligence assisted behavior generation mechanism model for archival open access review is constructed to promote the intellectualization of archival open access review and improve the quality and efficiency of archival open access review work.

Cite this article

Li Cairong , Du Keting , Zhang Yijing . An Exploration of the Generation Mechanism of Adoption Behavior of AI-Assisted Archival Open Access Review in Comprehensive Archives from the Perspective of Phenomenological[J]. Library and Information Service, 2026 , 70(8) : 57 -68 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2026.08.005

References

[1] 中华人民共和国国家档案局.中华人民共和国档案法[EB/OL].[2025-12-25]. https://www.saac.gov.cn/daj/falv/202006/79ca4f151fde470c996bec0d50601505.shtml. (State Archives Administration of the People’s Republic of China. Archives Law of the People’s Republic of China[EB/OL].[2025-12-25]. https://www.saac.gov.cn/daj/falv/202006/79ca4f151fde470c996bec0d50601505.shtml.)
[2] 中华人民共和国国家档案局.中办国办印发《“十四五”全国档案事业发展规划》[EB/OL].[2025-12-25]. https://www.saac.gov.cn/daj/yaow/202106/899650c1b1ec4c0e9ad3c2ca7310eca4.shtml?ddtab=true. (General Office of the CPC Central Committee, General Office of the State Council. The General Office of the CPC Central Committee and the General Office of the State Council issue the“14th Five-Year Plan for the Development of the National Archives Industry”[EB/OL].[2025-12-25]. https://www.saac.gov.cn/daj/yaow/202106/899650c1b1ec4c0e9ad3c2ca7310eca4.shtml?ddtab=true.)
[3] 周友泉,连波,曹军.“浙里数字档案”重大应用场景实践——“档案AI辅助开放审核”组件的性能与应用[J].浙江档案, 2022(11):22-24.(ZHANG Y Q, LIAN B, CAO J.“Zhejiang Digital Archives” major application scenario practice:“archives AI auxiliary open audit” performance and application[J]. Zhejiang archives, 2022(11):22-24.)
[4] 刘力超,陈晓珑,牛力.大模型驱动档案开放智能审核方法研究:动因、框架与实践[J].档案学研究, 2025(2):130-140.(LIU L C, CHEN X L, NIU L. Study on LLM-driven intelligent appraisal methods for archives opening:motivation, framework and practice[J]. Archives science study, 2025(2):130-140.)
[5] 李军,徐志国,王楠.智能语义助推档案开放审核的研究与实践[J].中国档案, 2023(11):56-57.(LI J, XUN Z G, WANG N. Research and practice of intelligent semantic assistance in archival access review[J]. China archives, 2023(11):56-57.)
[6] 马怡琳,李宗富.赋能·助力·提升:人工智能技术在档案解密与开放审核工作中的应用探索[J].山西档案, 2022(4):112-118.(MA Y L, LI Z F. Empowering·helping·improving:application and exploration of artificial intelligence technology in archives decryption and open review[J]. Shanxi archives,2022(4):112-118.)
[7] TZOUGANATOU A. Openness and privacy in born-digital archives:reflecting the role of AI development[J]. AI&Society,2022, 37(3):991-999.
[8] GOODMAN M.“What is on this disk?” An exploration of natural language processing in archival appraisal[D]. North Carolina:The University of North Carolina System, 2019.
[9] JUEZ-HERNANDEZR, QUIJANO-SÁNCHEZL,LIBERATORE F, et al. AGORA:an intelligent system for the anonymization, information extraction and automatic map of sensitive documents[J]. Applied soft computing, 2023,145:110540.
[10] 汤志伟,叶昶秀,雷鸿竹.高校教育管理者对生成式人工智能采纳行为的影响因素研究[J].西北工业大学学报(社会科学版), 2026(1):48-55.(TANG Z W, YE C X, LEI H Z. Research on influencing factors of generative AI adoption behavior by university education administrators[J]. Journal of northwestern polytechnical university(social sciences edition), 2026(1):48-55.)
[11] 马凤,黎阳.整合TTF与TAME-ChatGPT视角的生成式人工智能研究生用户采纳行为研究[J].情报探索, 2025(4):1-9.(MA F, LI Y. Research on the graduate student users’ adoption behavior of generative artificial intelligence by integrating TTF and TAME-ChatGPT perspectives[J]. Information research,2025(4):1-9.)
[12] 赵娜,李怀琳,杨妮娜. TAM-TOE整合视角下建设行业人工智能技术采纳行为研究[J].工程研究——跨学科视野中的工程, 2024, 16(2):137-146.(ZHAO N, LI H L, YANG N N. TAMTOE integrated perspective research on adoption of artificial intelligence technology in construction projects[J]. Journal of engineering studies, 2024, 16(2):137-146.)
[13] 郑汉,肖谦,贺晨.出版从业人员人工智能生成内容采纳行为影响因素的组态效应研究[J].出版科学, 2025, 33(2):57-71.(ZHENG H, XIAO Q, HE C. Research on the configuration path of factors influencing AIGC adoption behavior among publishing professionals:a fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis[J].Publishing journal, 2025, 33(2):57-71.)
[14] 郭顺利,张雪宁.科研人员生成式人工智能应用中知识采纳行为关键影响因素识别研究[J].情报科学, 2025, 43(5):58-69.(GUO S L, ZHANG X N. Identification of key influencing factors of knowledge adoption behavior in generative artificial intelligence applications for researchers[J]. Information science,2025, 43(5):58-69.)
[15] 靳雪晴.公共部门人员生成式人工智能技术采纳行为影响机理与助推策略研究[D].济南:山东财经大学, 2025.(JIN X Q.Research on the influencing mechanism and boosting strategies of generative artificial intelligence technology adoption behavior of public sector personnel[D]. Jinan:Shandong University of Finance and Economics, 2025.)
[16] JIANG Q, ZHANG J, WANG P H, et al. Technology acceptance and innovation diffusion:are users more inclined toward AIGCassisted design?[J]. International journal of human–computer interaction, 2025, 41(13):8370-8384.
[17] 毛太田,汤淦,马家伟,等.人工智能生成内容(AIGC)用户采纳意愿影响因素识别研究——以ChatGPT为例[J].情报科学, 2024, 42(7):126-136.(MAO T T, TANG G, MA J W,et al. Factors influencing user adoption intention of Artificial Intelligence Generated Content(AIGC):a study on ChatGPT[J].Information science, 2024, 42(7):126-136.)
[18] 刘齐平,张泽清,杨平.高等教育领域生成式AI工具的用户使用意愿研究[J].湖北第二师范学院学报, 2024, 41(8):85-93.(LIU Q P, ZHANG Z Q, YANG P. Users’ willingness to use generative AI tools in higher education[J]. Journal of Hubei University of Education, 2024, 41(8):85-93.)
[19] PRASAD A K. Towards adoption of generative AI in organizational settings[J]. Journal of computer information systems, 2024, 64(5):636-651.
[20] RAHMAN M R, KOKA R S, SHAH S K, et al. Enhancing lecture video navigation with AI generated summaries[J].Education and information technologies, 2024, 29(6):7361-7384.
[21] GUPTA V. An empirical evaluation of a generative artificial intelligence technology adoption model from entrepreneurs’perspectives[J]. Systems, 2024, 12(3):103.
[22] FAN P, JIANG Q. Exploring the factors influencing continuance intention to use AI drawing tools:insights from designers[J].Systems, 2024, 12(3):68.
[23] 谢雨杉,柯青,秦琴,等.现象图析学视角下情绪与信息行为的交互机理探析:以疫情场景为例[J].图书情报工作,2023, 67(13):99-110.(XIE Y S, KE Q, QIN Q, et al. Exploration on the interaction mechanism between emotion and information behavior from the perspective of phenomenography:taking the COVID-19 scenario for example[J]. Library and information service, 2023, 67(13):99-110.)
[24] 于良芝,刘怡君.现象学、现象图析学与信息用户研究的经验范式——信息经验研究的理论基础、核心概念与方法论评析[J].中国图书馆学报, 2021, 47(3):43-57.(YU L Z, LIU Y J. Phenomenology, phenomenography and the experience-based paradigm of user studies:philosophical foundation, core concepts and methodology of information experience research[J]. Journal of library science in China, 2021, 47(3):43-57.)
[25] CIBANGU S K. The origins and informed uses of the terms phenomenography and phenomenology[J]. Journal of documentation, 2023, 79(3):641-669.
[26] COLLIER-REED B. Phenomenography as a way to research the understanding by students of technical concepts[J]. Núcleo de Pesquisa em Tecnologia da Arquitetura e Urbanismo(NUTAU):technological innovation and sustainability, 2006, 1:1-11.
[27] 张艳丰,刘敏.现象图析学视角下移动社交媒体用户数字囤积行为机理研究[J].现代情报, 2024, 44(7):3-12, 73.(ZHANG F Y, LIU M. Research on the mechanism of the digital hoarding behavior of mobile social media users from the perspective of phenomenography[J]. Journal of modern information, 2024,44(7):3-12, 73.)
[28] 彭丽徽,周媛.现象图析学视角下高校科研人员数字囤积行为形成机理研究[J].图书馆工作与研究, 2025(1):25-34.(PENG L H, ZHOU Y. Research on the formation mechanism of digital hoarding behavior of university researchers based on the perspective of phenomenography[J]. Library work and study,2025(1):25-34.)
[29] LIMBERG L. Phenomenography:a relational approach to research on information needs, seeking and use[J]. New review of information behaviour research, 2000, 1(12):51-67.
[30] FORSTER M. Phenomenography:a methodology for information literacy research[J]. Journal of librarianship and information science, 2016, 48(4):353-362.
[31] 王文韬,唐思捷,钱鹏博,等.用户体验视角下AIGC与非理性信息行为交互机理研究——基于现象图析学的探析[J].情报理论与实践, 2025, 48(5):57-63, 90.(WANG W T, TANG S J, QIAN P B, et al. Research on the mechanism of AIGC interaction with irrational information behaviour from the perspective of user experience:an exploration based on phenomenography[J]. Information studies:theory&application,2025, 48(5):57-63, 90.)
[32] BAMIGBOLA A A. The use of phenomenographic approach to investigate students’ conception of Web 2.0 tools[C] //New trends in qualitative and quantitative methods in libraries:selected papers presented at the 2nd qualitative and quantitative methods in libraries. Chania:World scientific, 2010:161-166.
[33] 张霄,丁邦平.现象图析学:一种中观层面的教育学研究方法论[J].比较教育研究, 2017, 39(3):26-32.(ZHANG X,DING B P. Phenomenography:a meso-level methodology in educational research[J]. International and comparative education,2017, 39(3):26-32.)
[34] 王伟宾,丁邦平.现象图析学及其理论基础——兼谈与其他质性研究方法的异同[J].比较教育研究, 2021, 43(6):97-104.(WANG W B, DING B P. Phenomenography and its theoretical foundations:comparison with other qualitative research methods[J]. International and comparative education,2021, 43(6):97-104.)
[35] ORNEK F. An overview of a theoretical framework of phenomenography in qualitative education research:an example from physics education research[J]. Asia-Pacific forum on science learning and teaching, 2008, 9(2):1-14.
[36] PhD Assistance. Stimulus-Organism-Response(SOR)Model[EB/OL].[2025-12-25]. https://www.phdassistance.com/blog/stimulus-organism-response-sor-model/.
[37] 周淑云,李璐,邢文明.科学数据影响力的生成机制与提升策略研究——基于SOR理论和U&G理论[J].图书馆学研究, 2025(4):2-11.(ZHOU X Y, LI L, XING W M. Research on the generation mechanism and improvement strategy of the influence of scientific data:based on the SOR theory and the U&G theory[J]. Research on library science, 2025(4):2-11.)
[38] TUDORAN A, OLSEN S O, DOPICO D C. The effect of health benefit information on consumers health value, attitudes and intentions[J]. Appetite, 2009, 52(3):568-579.
[39] 孙琳,陈着,刘谨铭.人工智能技术在城建档案管理中的可能应用场景及推进策略[J].档案与建设, 2023(7):68-70.(SUN L, CHEN Z, LIU J M. Possible application scenarios and promotion strategies of artificial intelligence technology in urban construction archives management[J]. Archives&Construction,2023(7):68-70.)
[40] 王张雪,王向女.淬砺精进:省级档案馆应用人工智能进行档案开放审核现状、问题与优化[J].档案管理, 2025(2):102-106.(WANG Z X, WANG X N. Forging ahead:current situation, problems, and optimization of provincial archives’ use of artificial intelligence for archival access review[J]. Archives management, 2025(2):102-106.)
[41] 施浩然,吕元智.我国档案开放智能审核问题与优化策略研究[J].山西档案, 2024(6):20-26.(SHI H R, LYU Y Z. Research on issues and optimization strategies for intelligent review of open archives in China[J]. Shanxi archives, 2024(6):20-26.)
[42] SUSSMAN S W, SIEGAL W S. Informational influence in organizations:an integrated approach to knowledge adoption[J].Information systems research, 2003, 14(1):47-65.
[43] 刘崇瑞,徐东华.国家信息安全治理的国际经验与启示——基于人员安全保障的视角[J].太平洋学报, 2023, 31(6):14-27.(LIU C R, XU D H. International experience and implications of national information security governance:the case of personnel security assurance[J]. Pacific journal, 2023, 31(6):14-27.)
[44] 黄民锦.政府采购信用的理论逻辑和制度构建[J].中国政府采购, 2016(3):75-79.(HUANG M J. Theoretical logic and institutional construction of government procurement credit[J].China government procurement, 2016(3):75-79.)
[45] 孙芳.档案效益的特性与构成[J].档案管理, 2001(3):31.(SUN F. The characteristics and composition of archival benefits[J]. Archives management, 2001(3):31.)
[46] 陈沛芹,陈瑜.人工智能焦虑对生成式人工智能采纳行为的影响机理——基于技术接受模型的实证研究[J/OL].新媒体与社会, 1-17[2025-12-25]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/CN.20250929.1951.004.(CHEN P Q, CHEN Y. The mechanisms of AI Anxiety in shaping generative AI adoption:an empirical study based on the technology acceptance model[J/OL]. New media and society, 1-17[2025-12-25]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/CN.20250929.1951.004.)
[47] IVANOV S, SOLIMAN M, TUOMI A, et al. Drivers of generative AI adoption in higher education through the lens of the theory of planned behaviour[J]. Technology in society, 2024,77:102521.
Outlines

/

〈 〉